Blog Post

Why this Apple TV fan has come to prefer Amazon’s Fire TV

Stay on Top of Enterprise Technology Trends

Get updates impacting your industry from our GigaOm Research Community
Join the Community!

Being part of a family whose members own multiple Apple products, moving away from the notorious walled garden is not only a difficult choice to make, but often times a costly one. So when a product from someone like Amazon makes it easy for me to venture out even a little, I take notice. And with some of the latest apps and improvements that are now available on Amazon’s Fire TV, I just may be upgrading my collection of Apple TVs around the house to Amazon’s Fire TVs, and here’s why.

Everything you’d expect from the Apple TV

AirPlay through Reflector – There are several different developers that make AirPlay apps for your desktop that will turn either your Mac or your PC into an AirPlay receiver. AirSquirrels is one such developer and Reflector is its app that does just that. Recently AirSquirrels came out with a version of Reflector that supports the Amazon Fire TV. When AirSquirrels’ Reflector app for the Fire TV is running, you can stream music and video from your iOS device directly to the Fire TV as if it were an Apple TV. You can even enable AirPlay Mirroring and use the Fire TV to transform your television set into a big screen display for your iOS device. This was a feature that until the end of last year was pretty much exclusive to the Apple TV.  The only downside, and depending on how you use your Apple TV this may be an minor inconvenience for you, is that the Reflector app must be running before the FireTV will show up on your AirPlay list of devices.

iOS Remote App for Fire TV – Showing continued support for the iOS platform, Amazon just recently released a native remote app for the Fire TV that mimics the functionality of Apple’s own iOS Remote app for the Apple TV. It complements the included remote that comes with the Fire TV by adding a virtual keyboard. This makes interacting with the various apps on the Fire TV much easier. One feature that Amazon’s remote has that Apples remote for the Apple TV does not is that it adds voice search capabilities to the Fire TV. While this feature is included with the remote that comes with box-shaped console version of the Fire TV, it is a feature that is lacking on the remote the comes with the tiny USB powered Fire TV Stick. Amazon’s iOS Remote app brings voice search to the Fire TV Stick without having to buy a replacement remote.

Home Share iTunes Music with Plex – If you have not yet uploaded your entire music library to Amazon’s Cloud Player, and you still have a sizable music library on your Mac or PC that you want to continue listening to on the Fire TV, then consider using Plex as a replacement to Apple TVs own Home Share feature. While this is a great way of instantly accessing your desktop’s iTunes Music library from the Fire TV, you may run into some problems when accessing your iTunes Video library. Plex does not have the ability to play back any media files with DRM (Digital Rights Management). As a result, any movies or television episodes that you may have purchased through your iTunes account will not be playable on the Fire TV. This may not be an issue if your video library is more Ultraviolet than iTunes as noted below.

Camera Roll Backups to Amazon’s Cloud Drive – If you happen to be an Amazon Prime Member, then you have unlimited photo storage on your Amazon Cloud Drive. Using the Amazon Photos app for iOS, you can automatically sync all of the photos you take on your iPhone up to the cloud in much the same way you do with Apple’s own iCloud Photo Stream service. Once you have Cloud Drive set up, you can instantly access all of the photos you take on your iOS devices directly on your Amazon Fire TV.

And everything else that the Apple TV doesn’t have

Apps – Of course there are some apps on the Apple TV that you can also get on the Fire TV like Netflix, Hulu and HBO Go. But there are quite a few more apps available to the Fire TV that you simply cannot get on the Apple TV like Revison3TWiT.TVPluto and even Sling to name a few. Some of the more notable apps on the Fire TV are the games. With the optional Fire TV Game Controller, you can play games like MinecraftTerraria and BADLAND. While the video quality of the games will not rival that of the Xbox or Playstation, it is a convenient way of playing a game or two in front of your television.

Ultraviolet Movies on Flixster – One of the more interesting online developments lies in where you can store a digital copy of your purchased movies online. It use to be that when you received a Digital Copy with a physical DVD or Blue-ray purchase, you would get an unlock code for either iTunes or Microsoft’s Media Player. You would then download that digital copy and store it on your computer. Now-a-days what you get more often than not is an unlock code for Ultraviolet copy of the movie which is stored online in a digital locker. Flixster is one app on the Fire TV that you can use to access your online Ultraviolet movie library. Even if you purchased your digital movies from Target’s online video service (that has recently been shut down), you can still access all of your Ultraviolet movies via Flixster. In fact all online digital video services that use Ultraviolet share access to the same digital locker. It would be great if the rumors of Amazon joining Ultraviolet do pan out.  Then I would have just three movie libraries in the cloud rather than the four I have now.

Amazon Prime – I probably would not have been as excited about how well the Fire TV adapted to all of my Apple products if I was not already an Amazon Prime Member. As such, I have been itching to drop Netflix streaming video in favor of Amazon Prime instant video. The one thing holding me back was that the Apple TV did not support it, and the Apple TV was the only internet connected device attached to every television in my house. With the Fire TV I can also access Amazon Prime Music as well. The only service not included with Amazon Prime is Amazon’s Digital Music service. Subscribing to this service would allow you to store up to 250K songs in Amazon’s cloud. The annual cost of this add-on service is the same price as Apple’s iTunes Match service. So once all of my Apple TVs are replaced by Fire TVs, I may have to switch over to Amazon’s Music service as well.

18 Responses to “Why this Apple TV fan has come to prefer Amazon’s Fire TV”

  1. I have both Prime and Netflix. I don’t know why you would be “itching” to drop Netflix; it still has a lot of original content that is great, and non-Netflix content that is non-free on Amazon Prime Video.

    They are both cheap enough that you can easily just have both…

    For me the combination of Prime + Netflix + occasional iTunes TV purchases has totally replaced cable. When HBO joins the current century and offers online one subscriptions I’ll probably add that also, though since mostly I just want one or two shows from them It’s been cheaper to buy seasons individually on iTunes anyway.

  2. It’s crazy how technology has came a long way. I myself am an apple consumer. I fell in love with Amazon Fire Tv because it truly does work great, not as great as the roku, yet does a better job than apple tv. We are so adapted to new technology that even little features such as the voice control remote is something great to have. I must say I am amazed at the product and it’s success. I also am an amazon prime user, since I am addicted to amazon. All the features amazon fire had supported, definitely won many over.

  3. I own Fire TV, Apple TV and Roku. Roku’s remote control is the best of all; I can use the volume buttons on the side to control the sound directly; if I want to watch something alone and don’t want to disturb others, I can plug in the headsets directly into the remote. I find Roku’s interface is easier to navigate than Fire TV. I hardly use Apple TV anymore except listening to songs purchased through iTune. I think the biggest problem of ATV (Apple TV) is it doesn’t allow you to install third party apps and Apple doesn’t have an App store for ATV. My favourite is Fire TV. You can exclusive access to HBO collections, prime video and music if you’re a prime member. Because Fire TV is operating system – Fire OS is based on Android, that means you can sideload (install) many Android apps like KODI, Beats music etc. You can also install VPN on it if you know Android well:

  4. Brandon Davis

    I have a Roku (albeit a really old model), Apple TV, and Amazon Fire TV stick. The Apple TV used to be the de facto standard in our house, but its getting a little long in the tooth and with my somewhat recent discovery of Plex has deemed it almost useless. My Apple TV 2 seems to work pretty well, still, but my Apple TV 3 seems to require an almost daily reboot to see Home Share or not get an error message on the streaming apps. My Roku wouldn’t be fair to compare with any of the device due to age. The Amazon Fire Stick right now is my preferred as I can use it for Plex and it has many of the streaming apps I used Netflix, Amazon, and recently a tryout of Sling. The main thing that keeps the rest of the family from moving from the Apple TV to the Amazon Fire is the lack of being able to setup with the universal remote. Now, my preferred is the Xbox One but not really a fair comparison to the above referenced.

  5. Roku is still the best option, especially if you want to use a universal remote. The Fire doesn’t have an IR receiver and afaik does not support IP drivers from any of the major players in the control system world

  6. Did you read the reviews on amazon for reflector? Can’t stream videos without incredible lag. Without the ability to stream mp4’s from my mac, I cannot switch from apple TV to the Fire.

    • I tried it out for myself. I have two FireTV sticks, one FireTV and one Game Controllet. For the way that we tend to use AirPlay around the house, Reflector was performing well enough to suite our needs. The one major inconvenience is that we have to navigate to the reflector app on the FireTV in order to get it to work.

      I have recently completely overhauled my WiFi network. It is now performing extremely well compared to my prior configuration.

  7. Did you read the reviews on amazon for reflector? Can’t stream videos without incredible lag. With the ability to stream mp4’s from my mac, I cannot switch from apple TV to the Fire.