Thinking about switching to iOS 8’s new Family Sharing? Here’s what you need to know

19 Comments

Families have found different ways to manage their iTunes purchases over the years, but the best way required you to set everything up properly from the beginning. Starting off on the wrong foot meant that purchases were spread across multiple accounts, and not shared.

Making maters worse was the fact that there was no way to consolidate accounts or even transfer ownership of content from one account to another. Once a purchase was made, it was part of that iTunes account and that account only.

Here is how it was done. You had to:

  • Create separate Apple ID for each family member. Use this Apple ID to create individualized iCloud accounts. For each device, use this ID and the primary iCloud account on the device.
  • Select one Apple ID (or create a separate new one) to use exclusively with iTunes. Use this account as the iTunes & App Store account across all devices (configured separately from the primary iCloud account on the device).
  • To control spending, set up parental controls on children’s devices to block all iTunes purchases and updates.
  • Select one Apple ID (or create a separate new one) to use as the family calendar account. Configure this account as a secondary iCloud account across all devices.
  • Create an iCloud Shared Photo Stream and add all of your family members to the share. Allow family members to add photos to the share.
  • Invite Family members to be your ‘friend’ using the Find My Friends” app.

iTunes Family Sharing with iOS 8

But iOS 8 Family Sharing makes the this task of sharing purchases across six different iCloud accounts much more manageable with a much easier set up process.

Here’s how the new system works:

  • Create separate Apple ID for each family member. Use this Apple ID to create individualized iCloud accounts. Use each account as the primary iCloud account on each family members device (same as step one above).
  • Choose which family member will be the family organizer. From within the Settings app on that family members device, tap on iCloud > Family Sharing > Get Started.
  • Sign into the Apple ID that will be used for iTunes and App Store purchases. You may be prompted to validate your accounts payment options.
  • Choose whether or not you’d like to share your location with your family.
  • Tap on “Add Family Member…” to start adding up to six additional iCloud accounts to your family share.

So, what is missing?

There are still some differences between the two different tactics. While it is true that developers have to agree to the new licensing terms, and that there is a new field in the iTunes App Store indicating whether or not the app is eligible for Family Share, I have yet to encounter an app that is not eligible for Family Sharing.  If you do happen to run into a situation where you are prevented from downloading an app that has been purchased on your Family Share plan, simply try logging off and back on to your iTunes account and see if that fixes the issue.

You may also run into a situation where you find that you cannot enable the new “Ask to Buy” feature. Ask to Buy is enabled by default for iCloud users under the age of thirteen. You may have created an Apple ID for your children and set the date of birth to your own. If such was the case, you will need to log on to appleid.apple.com and correctly set the date of birth for each of your children, as the “Ask to Buy” feature will not be there for anyone over the age of 13.

Something else to consider is the limitation on how often you can switch from one family account to another. In the old style of sharing an iTunes account, computers and devices could switch between different accounts every ninety days. With the new iTunes Family Share, each iCloud account can only be associated with one Family Share at a time, and can switch only twice in a calendar year.

One thing that the new iTunes Family Share is not currently able to share is an iTunes Match subscription. If you happen to have iTunes Match, it will be limited to the one account that established it. Additionally, not all in-app purchases or newsstand subscriptions will carry through to every family members account. If sharing access to such features is important to you, the you may want to hold on to your current setup a little while longer.

Benefits of switching to a Family Share

When Apple introduced iOS 7, the one main features that was taken away from family sharing was the ability to track all of your family’s devices from one iCloud account. iOS 7 made the “Find My iPhone” setting exclusive to the primary iCloud account on the device. With iOS 6 and earlier (as well as on any OS X device), you could set up the “Find My iPhone” setting on any iCloud account on the device. Now with iOS 8, you can track all of your family’s devices from one account without having to use the iCloud web interface from a desktop computer. This is certainly a nice to have feature, but may not be worth switching everything around.

What makes it worth switching is the fact that the children on the account can start building up their own account with their own apps. This may not be important for any child under the age of thirteen, but will become important once your child grows up and wants to manage their own purchases. With the old style of sharing an iTunes account across multiple devices within a family, there was no way to break away from the family and start of with a library of your own apps, music, books and movies. Now there is, family members can start building up their library before moving out of the family.

19 Comments

AnneG

Jay – you may already have your answer as your post is a few months old but thought I would share anyway. I was having the same problem of having the “ask request” never appearing on my iPad (I’m the organizer). It turns out I had my kids logged on to the iCloud with their accounts but in iTunes with my account (I hadn’t yet figured out how to see each others apps). Once I logged them off my account on their iPads and logged onto iTunes with their iCloud accounts, the request came over once resent.

Betsy Green

I do not want family sharing on my iphone. I did not set it up and I want to delete it and I cannot. It will not allow me to wet up icloud.

Katie P

Is it possible to setup family sharing with an organizer, without losing the ability to still purchase apps and such on my own account?

Substance

Nice summary of iOS Family Sharing and how it benefits its users and where it’s still lacking instead of just listing features like most other sites. One question though – does iOS Family Sharing allow for backing up your devices to one iCloud account or do you still have to buy extra iCloud space for every account that hits the 5GB threshold?

Max

Can family members make purchases independently of the Shared group ? In other words; if my daughter wants to buy something (app music movie) for her kids, can she do so on her account independently of my “family organizer” account?

Thanks
Max- Colorado

Jay

I am very technical and I have found that Family Sharing just flat doesn’t work. I have tried for hours to get one device to “ask to buy” and actually get the popup for the ask. It pops up on my childs iPod, then click ask to buy but NEVER receive the request on the organizers device. Its a joke and the thing just does not work.

monty241070

Tried with iOS 7 device. You can add to family. You can download new stuff. But… When you want to reinstall something that another member of the family already has installed you can not install it.
It seems that family sharing actually makes iOS 7 disfunction.

Roland

Thanks for the article. My biggest issue is not being able to add my kids accounts – it requires they each have a separate payment method They’re both well under 13, but I created the accounts for them some time ago. Made it easier for them to have their own backups, etc. And I can’t change the DOB to under 13 in Manage Apple ID. I wish the process to “add kids under 13” would let you add already created accounts. Has anyone found a work around? One that doesn’t require creating a new account?

Matt

Just change their year of birth to 2001, that puts them at 13 and shows them up as kids on your account, from there you just need to turn on ask to buy

Rick Brown

Recently bought iPhone 6. Amazing features and accessibility of apps. No doubt, lots of amendnments have been made to iOS 7. Atlast, bending of the device still needs some improvement.

Zach Wise

Another drawback for me is no true shared Photostream. My wife and I have always shared the same Photostream, but now we have individual accounts we have to go through true shared stream, which means that not all of the photos she has on her phone automatically make it into our iPhoto library on our Mac.

glennrempe

If you have not found apps that are not eligible for sharing you didn’t look very hard.

(My iPhone) > App Store > Updates > Purchased > My Purchases

I see literally dozens of applications that indicate ‘Not Shareable’, including apps from Apple itself. What’s also strange is that some apps indicate ‘Not Shareable’ when you look at them on the previously purchased screen, but say ‘Family Sharing : Yes’ on the applications main info and installation screen in the App Store (e.g. Apple’s WWDC app says this for me).

While it is pretty easy to workaround re-installing free apps that are not shareable, it should be made more clear that it is the third-party developers who are in complete control over which apps can be shared and which cannot.

My wife has had to re-install about a dozen free apps that she could not auto-update due to sharing restrictions.

Buyer beware.

Nathan Pritchard

I hadn’t noticed that the Family Sharing status wasn’t the same across all possible views, but everything else is the same as my experience. I felt like a dumbass when I convinced my wife to switch over to a separate Apple ID and then on day 1 she gets a pop-up message that some app couldn’t be updated because it had been originally downloaded with a different Apple ID.

Jeff Bickart

You missed another big difference, each device needs its own iCloud backup account and no longer shares storage.

Geoffrey Goetz

In the ‘old’ technique outlined above, the primary iCloud account on each family members device was different. In such a configuration each family member was already using their own separate iCloud storage. The ‘shared’ iTunes account used on all devices is configured seperately for the iTunes and App Store and did not affect iCloud storage.

Christopher McKinney

True but the technique you outline is not the technique used by most users. Most users DID share one iCloud account across all devices as the main account and then added a second account just for email, etc. I think the lack of a shared photostream and lack of shared backup is going to hit many users pretty hard.

It’s still pretty awkward and clunky for an apple product.

Chris

I never had any trouble tracking all my family’s devices in ios7 but I like the new ios8 interface.

Also–my 15 year old daughter has “ask to buy” enabled–no problem.

Comments are closed.