Blog Post

News flash: Americans remain conflicted on government data gathering

Stay on Top of Enterprise Technology Trends

Get updates impacting your industry from our GigaOm Research Community
Join the Community!

Fifty-percent of Americans seem to have no huge beef overall with the U.S. government’s data collection programs as exemplified by the NSA PRISM program, according to the latest Pew Research survey.

But, the just-released research shows that citizens do have mixed feelings about the program; More than half — or 56 percent — said they felt there was not sufficient court supervision of what data is collected but 50 percent approved of the program overall compared to 44 percent who disapproved. Six percent don’t know or, presumably, don’t care.


Despite assurances to the contrary, 63 percent think the government is going beyond metadata to grab up the actual content of communications and nearly a third (27 percent) believe the government is listening to or reading their own personal communications

Once again, younger people were more concerned about government incursions than their elders and once again, this surprises me. I would have thought that younger people, who are more used to sharing information about their private lives on social networks, would be less upset about the practice.

The survey reinforces earlier results that also showed younger citizens were more irked at government snooping and that in general U.S. citizens seem to think that sacrificing privacy is the price to be paid for better security — a stance that some technologists, including former Microsoft top software guy Ray Ozzie, find perplexing. Ozzie thinks that American citizens blithely gave up valuable privacy rights when Congress enacted the Patriot Act after 9/11 and have been paying a high price ever since.

Skeptics feel that the net result of all this data gathering has not been better security at all, and point to the Boston Marathon bombings as a top example of that.

This survey is based on phone interviews that took place between July 17 through 31 of 1,480 adults who are 18 years old or older in all 50 states.pew2

6 Responses to “News flash: Americans remain conflicted on government data gathering”

  1. I find the abject hypocrisy of the administration supporting this outrageous.

    That said, I would like to know one thing. Six degrees of separation?

  2. Virtuous

    The examples the Government uses to justify their actions are laughable, total jokes.The Government has literally scared people to death to get their way.

    • That scare factor is sort of what Ray Ozzie spoke about. After 9/11 it was sort of “do what you have to” to protect us. Now, after more than a decade, you might think some parsing of the results would be in order. Has the snooping really saved us more catastrophes? We’re told so but then again there’s the sneaker bomber, the marathon bombers etc….

  3. danbourdeau

    I too am surprised, and a bit saddened, by this report. Unfortunately, of the people I have talked to, about half don’t seem to care or are perfectly fine with the status quo….. so, pretty consistent with this survey.

    Are there any websites that clearly document the extent to which we are being tracked and clearly explain the ways in which the data could be used? I would like to have something to show people who aren’t exactly tech savvy.

  4. Part of the reason for the high approval ratings are people simply don’t understand that Congress and the President cannot violate the Bill of Rights. But that Congress passed the laws and are overseeing the programs is given as justifications for the programs. Many people fall for that argument.