Blog Post

Nexus 4 reviewed: A fantastic phone, even without LTE

Stay on Top of Enterprise Technology Trends

Get updates impacting your industry from our GigaOm Research Community
Join the Community!

Nexus 4 backGoogle(s goog) is continuing to push its direct-to-consumer Android brand with the Nexus 4 smartphone built by LG. The handset showcases the new Android 4.2 software while also improving hardware over the prior model: Samsung’s Galaxy Nexus. At a no-contract price of $299 for an 8 GB model or $349 for a 16 GB version, is this new flagship phone worth the money? Some may give pause by the lack of LTE support, but overall, the Nexus 4 is a fantastic phone for the price; especially for consumers that live in a recently upgraded HSPA+ network area.

Hardware: It’s the Galaxy Nexus; only better

I’ve been using the Nexus 4 for the last two weeks and prior to that, my main phone for most of the last year was Nexus 4’s predecessor: the Galaxy Nexus. This successor handset may be best described as the Galaxy Nexus evolved. The Nexus 4 feels like a more premium-built device with Corning’s(s glw) Gorilla Glass 2 on the front and back. Along the sides the phone has a rubberized, grippy material that feels good in hand. And the flat glass back means no protruding hump for a speaker like the prior model had. In short: This is a sleek, comfortable device that you won’t mind holding. About that speaker on the back: it’s not as loud as I’d like it; similar to the last Nexus. But call quality in general is good.

The 4.7-inch IPS display offers a 1280 x 768 resolution and to my eye, looks better than that of the Galaxy Nexus. Colors are vivid, but not over-saturated and everything is crisp and bright. The button layout is the same as the old Nexus: Power/wake on the right, volume rocker on the left and micro-USB port on the bottom. The headphone jack is up top now and a micro-SIM door is on the right. The Nexus 4 has a 2100 mAh integrated battery and with the glass back, there’s no way to get at it. I’ve been able to get through nearly every day of usage on a single charge, however. There’s no support for additional memory expansion, which is a bit of a let-down, even though I faced the same on last year’s model.

Inside is Qualcomm’s(s qcom) 1.5 GHz quad-core Snapdragon Pro paired with a generous 2 GB of memory and an Adreno 320 GPU. This combination makes Android fly, no matter what activities you throw at it. Browsing, email, games: You name it; all are fast. While you can close apps by hitting the recent apps software button and swiping the software off screen, I’ve stopped doing so with the Nexus 4: There’s simply no need with this hardware configuration because the phone is a powerhouse. Hard-core, heavy duty users may want to free up memory from time to time but  most folks won’t bother.

Much improved over last year’s Nexus is the 8-megapixel rear camera sensor, which is backside illuminated, and LED flash. Images and videos are noticeably better and on par with most other high-end handsets, save perhaps for the iPhone 5(s aapl) and some Nokia(s nok) Lumia phones. While stills and videos (up to 1080p) look quite good, the camera isn’t the fastest I’ve used, which surprises me, given the hardware inside. Letting the camera auto-focus on its own isn’t always quick when tapping the shutter button and I find myself pre-focusing with a screen tap more often than not as a result. The front-facing 1.3 megapixel camera works fine for video chat or a quick self-portrait.

Let’s talk LTE and HSPA+

All of the expected connectivity and sensor options are present: dual-band 802.11 b/g/n Wi-Fi; Bluetooth; GPS; NFC; accelerometer; gyroscope; compass; and even support for wireless charging (which I wasn’t able to test). As an unlocked GSM phone, the Nexus 4 supports typical voice network frequencies as well as HSPA+ channels for both T-Mobile and AT&T(s t) in the US. But — and this could be a sticking point for some — there’s no LTE compatibility.

I see this as a trade-off of sorts and it’s a personal choice if you want to accept the trade-off or not. The handset supports both HSPA+ and dual-carrier HSPA+ up to a theoretical 42 Mbps. In the right coverage areas then, the dual-carrier HSPA+ speeds can come close to that of an LTE network. I used a T-Mobile micro-SIM in the Nexus 4 but I don’t live in an area where T-Mobile provides 42 Mbps service.

As a result, my typical speedtests showed latency averaging 90 milliseconds, downloads topping 9 Mbps, and uploads approaching 1.6 Mbps. However, Myriam Joire, an Engadget review I know and trust personally, managed several speedtests in a 42 Mbps coverage area and routinely saw Nexus 4 throughput at 2 to 3 times my own experience. See her test result here (left) topping 27 Mbps down and 3.6 Mbps back up, for example.

So how much of a letdown is the lack of LTE? That’s up to you and could be based on where you live due to coverage areas. I’m quite fine with the HSPA+ speeds on the Nexus 4; particularly because I heavily supplement my connectivity with wireless hotspots. LTE is a nice to have for sure, but it’s going to cost you on a monthly basis. Since the Nexus 4 only supports HSPA+ and can be had without contract, you can shop around for an HSPA+ plan: I use a $45 month Straight Talk SIM but others may opt for the $30 T-Mobile deal at WalMart(s wmrt). With each, you’re getting full HSPA+ speeds but for much less on a monthly basis when compared to LTE.

Software: Best Android version yet

The Nexus 4 is the first phone to ship with Android 4.2. While other Nexus devices will get the software too, new Nexus 4 owners will be the envy of the Android smartphone world. There aren’t a massive amount of changes in this version of the software, which is stock on the Nexus 4, meaning it’s “pure” Android, without any user interface overlays. The lack of big changes shows that Android has matured to the point where it needs only minor tweaks and feature adds; something that I think will unify the platform as a whole.

Android Notifications on Nexus 4There are few nice new user interface changes, however. The notification shade has a new one-touch Quick Settings options for easy access to device settings. You can also take action on a small set of notifications such as returning a missed call. A new keyboard option is included as well.

Fans of the Swype keyboard will be happy to hear that a gesture-based keyboard is now included. Using a single finger, you trace your words on the keyboard for fast input. Although I’m not a fan of this method — I use two thumbs to type on all of my phones — I can vouch for Google’s effort here as it works well and includes word prediction by tapping the space button.

Nexus 4 lock widgetAlso new here is support for lock-screen widgets: Swipe the lock screen to the left and you’ll immediately be in the Camera app, for example. Swipe to the right and you can add several other widgets that show information on a locked device ranging from Calendar appointments, the Gmail Inbox, Messaging app or Sound Search, a Shazam-like app that identifies a song. Testing this last widget worked really well: The app never failed to get the right song and, of course, it provides a link to purchase the music in Google Play. I love having this — and other information — right on the lock screen for fast access.

The new Photo Sphere feature is interesting. With it you’re guided through a series of still images all around you and the phone then renders them into a single interactive image. It works OK indoors but is much better outdoors in my opinion as images with many straight lights show numerous alignment issues. You can share these pics, but only in a wide, landscape view for now

Is the Nexus 4 for you?

For those wanting a high-end, cutting-edge Android experience and can do without LTE, I see no reason to pass this phone up, although I’d recommend the 16 GB model due to the lack of memory expansion. Even with 16 GB, you’ll need to take heavy advantage of cloud storage for music and video streaming, not to mention the saving of pictures and videos. I’ve survived with a 16 GB Galaxy Nexus for more than a year, so while that’s not desirable, it’s not impossible.

As far as the Nexus line as a whole, my general strategy has been to upgrade every other Nexus. I bought the Nexus One but passed on the Nexus S, for example. I then upgraded to the Galaxy Nexus last year. For the first time, Google has created a phone that made me pause and rethink my strategy. Why? Because the Nexus 4 is that much better than my Galaxy Nexus and costs nearly 40 percent less than what I paid for the prior model.

Galaxy S III handsetSome may opt for the popular Samsung Galaxy S III which packs LTE but there’s a key difference here: The Nexus 4 will get software updates much faster than Samsung’s best selling Android phone. And like most other Android devices, the GS III uses Samsung’s TouchWiz overlay; not necessarily a bad thing, but pure Android is actually nice to use. Besides, you could always add a third-party launcher to the Nexus 4 if you wanted to.

This new handset is improved in every way and if I hadn’t recently purchased a Galaxy Note 2, I likely would be buying this new Nexus handset. It’s that good. In fact, I think it competes well against the latest offerings that run iOS or Windows Phone. And that’s what the Nexus should be for Google: A flagship line of devices that either lead the pack or are at least in the mix for the best currently available phones and tablets on the market.

Note that if you want to save some up-front money, you can buy the Nexus 4 directly from T-Mobile for $199 with a contract.

23 Responses to “Nexus 4 reviewed: A fantastic phone, even without LTE”

  1. Very nice review. I have a friend who simply must have the Nexus 4. The problem is that every time we go over features he wants or even needs in a phone, the Nexus 4 comes up short, all be it very, VERY slightly to the S3. But he is STILL tossing the Nexus 4 around, including switching carriers just to get it. IMO, thats as ridiculous as the people who switched carriers for the iPhone when it was released. I just dont understand that mentality. The primary purpose of your phone is to field calls and receive data. If your network doesnt do that, who cares what your phone is capable of doing? Im not really sure I understand Google’s thought process in releasing a non 4G phone in 2012 as your “premier” phone. It seems very “Apple-ish” to me. What I mean is the typical iPhone fanboy responses that I heard when I questioned why iPhone didnt have cut and paste. Oh you dont really NEED cut and paste… Umm ok…? Seemed like its pretty standard at this point but whatevs. I feel this is the same kind of thing. The only saving grace is that was software and this is hardware. I can understand Google’s desire to build a truly “world capable” phone by having it run only on networks that are well covered through out the world like 3G. But there is a 4G chipset in there. Its unpowered and possibly no antenna, and that makes me sad thinking about what could have been.

    For me personally the lack of 4G LTE is a deal breaker. I spend 99.999% (repeating) of my time in the US where VZW has a whole lot of 4G coverage. I think the lack of 4G is what caused VZW to pass on it. Im beyond happy with my network and hav no plans to switch it. I know that the Nexus line is designed to showcase software, but I think it should be top hardware as well. Ill personally be looking forward to the Nexus 5 with 4G capability. And if they price it like they have the Nexus 4… Ill be inclined to drop the coin on 1 to upgrade instead of waiting for my conteact renewal.

    Over all great review and thanks for the opportunity to sound off my opinion.

  2. Ajinkya Paranjape

    Hey Kevin, nice review. How was your experience with this phone in terms of daily usage? Did you experience any stutter or lag anytime in your usage or worse hangs? And did everything work flawlessly without any crashes like force close or incompatibility? Thnx…

  3. For the record, Android & Me had summary of various online reviews & said the 4 volume levels are not much better than the Gnex. Not sure why this keeps being a problem on these Google phones. Never had these issues before from cheap flip phones to what would be considered mid level smart phones. This wouldn’t seem to be that difficult. I know speaker on back doesn’t help but why are these phones having these issues that others don’t. Guess I’m wrong but I think volume is pretty important on a phone.

  4. Great review, made me confident in the fact that I ordered one. I wanted to mention one inaccuracy. You -can- share Photospheres. If you send the file (through any method I’ve tried) to another Android 4.2 phone it can view it properly in the gallery app. Additionally, you can upload the Photospheres to Google+ where anyone can view them through the web browser.

  5. Great review Kevin, I’ve pretty much followed the same pattern. Nexus One, then Galaxy Nexus (which I also paid a fortune for prior to the Google play store launch).

    If I had the phone as a loaner for review as you have, I would be quite temped as well, to upgrade to the Nexus 4. You’ve got me considering it while reading your review again! The price is so low.

    However the same caveat keeps bringing back to staying with the Galaxy Nexus, the removable battery. I like to have at least one extra emergency battery with my when travelling or being out for long periods etc… It’s come in handy a few times especially when travelling. With the Nexus 4, I would be out of luck with a dead phone on those occasions… Of course I could bring one of those battery packs for charging the phone, but that’s just extra weight, and I would have to tether it for it to charge, rather than just stick in a new battery, and go.

    • You can get USB ‘rechargers’ that run on common AA batteries, and tuck that in you bag for emergencies. They work quite well. The beauty is that you can pick up spare AA anywhere in the world.

  6. No need to be rude. Sorry for not using perfect grammar while quickly posting a comment. I have read reviews and many mentioned low volume. But considering none of the original Gnex reviews I had read even mentioned this (&Google Support as well as Samsung denies its an issue), its a valid question. And I’m not in the UK so never even heard of retailer you the US, T-Mobile is the only carrier offering the phone.
    You represent all that’s wrong with these tech blogs. You forget that everyone isn’t an Android expert. You tell me to check reviews; what do you think led me here? Don’t know why so many if you Androiders always have to attack people who may not know what you know or God forbid disagree. My Android experience has not been great so excuse me for trying to get more information vs immediately moving to iOS. (Here’s where u call me stupid and tell me to be an I sheep). Take your bad mood elsewhere..and sorry I didn’t realize you could sign up to get responses. But after getting yours, I’ll uncheck that box.

    • The Commons

      The volume situation is somewhat better, but it still wouldn’t overpower a crowded subway. As for rebooting, that’s just a matter of holding down a couple buttons, just like on the iPhone where you hold down the power and Home buttons for a few seconds to force a shutdown.

      IF you can get your hands on one this point, demand is so great that I imagine you could turn it over if you’re displeased with it without much (if at all) of a loss.

      “No need to be rude.”
      “You represent all that’s wrong with these tech blogs. You forget that everyone isn’t an Android expert….Don’t know why so many if you Androiders always have to attack people who may not know what you know or God forbid disagree.”
      A case of the pot calling the kettle black if I ever saw one. And that’s coming from someone whose primary phone is an iPhone.

  7. Kevin, I know the 4 camera & speeds have been upgraded from the Gnex. Any way you can email me if volume levels are better. I’ve been so dissapointed at how low volume levels are without headphone. I barely can hear tones, music, video,app sounds or anything else in Publix. GPS is barely audible in empty car due to traffic noise. I’ve started putting a ear phone in one ear to mimic a Bluetooth so I can hear while driving. Apparently no T-Mobile stores in my major market are even going to have it in store and I wanna test .. Don’t really need high speeds since I’m trying cheap mvno that prevent streaming..but the volume + the camera that leads to a lot of blurry photos are things I wanna make sure have improved with 4. I also wonder @ battery cuz whenever I have a problem, I’m told to take battery out for a minute & then reboot..mwont be able to do that anymore either… pls I keep reading people complain @ LG. But my 2 experiences w Samsung tech support have been nightmares

    • Other reviews address your questions, just do your own research instead of asking for emails.
      Volume levels are improved, however the quality is not excellent.
      Carphone Warehouse will be the ones stocking the new Nexus 4. Additionally, you can purchase your own and return it if it falls below par for you.
      Camera was majorly improved but will not perform equally to those on premium devices. When in its full resolution, pictures aren’t their clearest and, most importantly, moving objects will be hard to capture without a blur, likewise being with low light pictures. Again, this is true when compared to the likes of S3 and i5, not to the previous Nexus.
      I would also comment on LG being the maker, but while I still tolerated your banter about traffic noise, your child-like grammar upset me gravely. I think you are a loser.

      • In Atlanta? Which store? I called several & they said no plans to get it. A corporate store manager said he’d call& find out and said no stores are carrying it as of now