Blog Post

Microsoft Surface reviews: come for the hardware, tolerate the software

Stay on Top of Enterprise Technology Trends

Get updates impacting your industry from our GigaOm Research Community
Join the Community!

Surface, Microsoft’s (s msft) first foray into building its own computer hardware, is a bold attempt to stay relevant in an increasingly post-PC world. But from early reviews of the device, Microsoft has some work to do to make it a competitive replacement to iPads (s aapl), Android tablets (s goog) and laptops.

Microsoft gets a lot of good marks for its hardware, which includes a keyboard cover and kickstand, though many question the usability of Surface when placed on a lap. But the bigger questions revolve around the Windows RT software, which is buggy and limited and isn’t able to run old legacy Microsoft applications the way Windows 8 devices can. Surface Pro, which will run Windows 8, will debut in a few months and may get a better reception.

Here’s a look at some of the comments from reviewers:

Microsoft Surface“Look, here’s the thing. You’d have to be fairly coldblooded to keep your pulse down the first time you see the Surface: its beauty, its potential, its instant transformation from tablet to PC. How incredible that this bold, envelope-pushing design came from Microsoft, a company that for years produced only feeble imitations of other companies’ fresh ideas. And how ironic that what lets the Surface down is supposedly Microsoft’s specialty: software,” said David Pogue in the New York Times.

“For all Microsoft’s claims to hardware perfection and software revolution, Surface RT is undone by too many little annoyances, cracks, and flaws. After the initial delight of an evolved tablet wears off, you’ll groan—because Surface brings the appearance of unity, but it’s really just the worst of both worlds. Instead of trading in your laptop and tablet for Surface, a cocktail of compromises that fracture the whole endeavor, you’ll miss them both urgently,” wrote Sam Biddle in Gizmodo.

“The big problem Microsoft has is that right now it doesn’t matter how good Surface is. The decision on whether or not to buy depends not on Surface itself, but on Windows RT. The only third-party applications that will run on Windows RT are those that use the Metro interface and are distributed through the Windows Store. At the moment, there just aren’t that many applications, and many of the ones that exist are mediocre,” wrote Peter Bright in Arstechnica. 

Microsoft Surface“For a device that’s supposed to feel more like an appliance, with seamless and beautiful software, there are a number of weird moments that scream “computer!” like black-and-white nightmares bursting into rainbow dreams. In general, the desktop environment feels like a trick, a kludge, because Microsoft didn’t have a fully touch oriented version of Office ready to go — so every time you want to use Word or Excel, you’re launched into Windows circa 2000-whenever,” writes Matt Buchanan of Buzzfeed.

“This is a great device. It is a new thing, in a new space, and likely to confuse many of Microsoft’s longtime customers. People will have problems with applications — especially when they encounter them online and are given an option by Internet Explorer to run them, only to discover this won’t work. But overall it’s quite good; certainly better than any full-size Android tablet on the market. And once the application ecosystem fleshes out, it’s a viable alternative to the iPad as well,” said Mat Honan of Wired.

“By supporting an ultra-thin, feather-light full keyboard accessory, the Surface instantly becomes one of the best tablets on the planet in terms of productivity without adding any bulk. Typing on a soft polyurethane keypad is not the same as typing on a regular keyboard of course, but I got pretty good with it after a few days of practice,” BGR,” said Zach Epstein of BGR.
Microsoft Surface“Overall, Microsoft has designed a beautiful tablet that’s unfortunately more functional as a laptop… on a desk. The styling and components are incredibly well made and high quality, but the form factor isn’t svelte or small enough to really come across as a true hybrid,” said Joshua Topolsky in the Verge.

“While (other) devices are primarily targeted at content-hungry consumers, the Surface is a slate upon which you can get some serious work done, and do so comfortably. You can’t always say that of the competition. It’s in the other half of the equation, that of the content consumption and entertainment, where the Surface is currently lacking. It needs a bigger pile of apps and games to make up for that and, while we’re sure they’re coming, we don’t know when,” said Tim Stevens of Engadget.

Stay tuned for our own review of Surface, as we take a look at Microsoft’s latest attempt at post-PC technology.

9 Responses to “Microsoft Surface reviews: come for the hardware, tolerate the software”

  1. I had one for two day. I like the way windows 8 lays out on the screen, however I really didn’t like the way IE10 laid out your favorites. There was no way to really organize favorites they just show up in a huge group, and it you want to use IE from the desktop the on screen keyboard becomes disabled to touch. It was a deal breaker for me.

  2. Jay Kreusch

    The poor software and lack of apps combined with with the juggernauts of Apple/Android make it a non-starter, right?

    What did people say about the XBOX when it released? Oh yeah, “good hardware, poor software, no games”

    Don’t count Microsoft out of any race – just ask Sony and Nintendo.

  3. But there is a Apple, Google, and people problem they won’t wait months on end for apps to appear for the surface, particularity with Christmas coming up, Apple was able to get away without apps five years ago initially because the iPhone was a iPod too.

      • How many apps did iOS have on when it was released? If there is one software brand where you can expect software innovation, that brand is windows. This tablets will sell in massive quantitites and no serious app developer can afford to ignore it.

      • Andre Goulet

        Morriscos said “How many apps did iOS have on when it was released?”

        What relevance is that today? I own an iPad that is all decked out the way I want it. Then, I buy a Nexus 7, go to the Play store, and in minutes I have my Flipboard, Currents, Kindle, etc all loaded and ready, making the device deeply personal and ‘mine’.

        When I bought the HP Touchpad, before the firesale, I returned it that day because I was used to having the iPad and I couldn’t get the Touchpad anywhere near as functional or fun.

        This is what MS is facing initially. We all know that many apps will come quickly for RT, but as the old saying goes “you never get a second chance to make a first impression”.