Review: The Galaxy Nexus from an iPhone owner’s perspective

113 Comments

While I most often use an iPhone (s aapl) as my primary mobile device, I’m not an Android-hater by any means. And resisting the lure of Google’s(s goog) Android reference device is nearly impossible for an early adopter like me. This year, the Samsung Galaxy Nexus is that device, and it’s the first phone to ship with Android 4, otherwise known as “Ice Cream Sandwich.” Here’s what I think of the Nexus, and the latest iteration of Android, and how both stack up to the iPhone 4S and iOS 5.

First impressions

The Galaxy Nexus feels like a very different device compared to the iPhone; almost enough that it seems like it could belong to a different device category. Of course, it’s to be expected that a smartphone with a plastic back and much larger 4.65-inch screen would feel different than one made of metal and glass, sporting a 3.5-inch display. And the screen plays a big part in the different feel, making the Nexus appear to have more in common with something like the 7-inch Kindle Fire(s amzn) than it does with the iPhone, in a lot of ways, including its suitability for consuming media like feature-length movies.

But  not everything about the Nexus impressed me off the bat. I actually managed to nick the plastic back within about 15 minutes of opening the box, for instance. Maybe I should have a cleaner desk, but maybe Samsung should use stronger materials.

Also, the display, while stunning for blacks and whites on high brightness, shows some faint criss-crossing lines when brightness is turned down on whites, or when brightness is turned up on grays. This is something users of other Samsung Android devices have complained about before, and might be easily resolved by a software update. Plus, I’ve had iPhone screen issues on new devices as well, which were fixed in time, so it’s not something I’m counting against the Nexus too much. Likewise, the volume bug some customers are experiencing, which Samsung has said it will soon fix.

How big is too big? Hint: Surprisingly, not 4.65-inches.

The Galaxy Nexus has one immediately striking difference from the iPhone 4S in terms of hardware: A screen of epic proportions. It isn’t quite as large as that found on the Galaxy Note, but at 4.65-inches, it beats the 4S by more than an inch measured diagonally. Some of that extra screen comes from a lack of hardware buttons, but the Nexus is still much larger than the iPhone, as you can tell from this image of the two stacked atop one another.

Surprisingly, however, the larger footprint doesn’t actually add up to a much bigger-feeling device, overall. Thanks perhaps to the curved screen and back, or just to smart distribution of the extra surface area, the Nexus feels comfortable both in my hand and in my pocket. It actually feels better than the 4S when you’re using it to make a call, as the curved surface wraps your face in something like a light embrace. Sound silly, but it feels good.

The Galaxy Nexus might be too large for some smaller hands, however (mine are larger than average), so be sure to get to a store and try one out before you make a purchase if you’re concerned about that.

Sparring screens

Both the Galaxy Nexus and the iPhone 4S have beautiful displays. The 4S’s Retina Display, despite being a year old, still renders text more crisply than the Samsung phone, at least to my eyes. But the Nexus does blacks very, very well. So well, in fact, that I use a basic black background as my wallpaper; icons appear to float out of nowhere on an otherwise completely powered down display as a result. Both devices boast very high pixel densities, with the Nexus managing 316ppi and the 4S managing 330ppi, so any differences are down to the use of LED backlit IPS panels for the iPhone, vs. Samsung’s Super AMOLED technology, and preference for either is going to be a matter of taste.

The Galaxy Nexus is a much better device for watching movies and video on, as I mentioned above, partly because of the deep blacks, and partly because of the huge screen size. If you use your device to watch a lot of video, go for the Nexus. If you spend more time reading than watching on your smartphone, the iPhone is the better choice.

Battle of the batteries

Switching between Android and iOS devices, I’m always reminded of just how weak most Android-powered handsets are when it comes to battery life. Even the Galaxy S II, which was strong in most respects, faltered in this one. But the Galaxy Nexus, maybe because of Android 4.0.1 power optimization, has managed to make this a much tighter race. In my use, I managed to get a whopping three days of usage out of a single charge on the Nexus, admittedly with very little movie watching, but using apps and the browser with fair frequency. Given normal use, about two days looks to be very possible, putting it on nearly even footing with the iPhone.

I’m still a little wary, since I often find that battery life on Android devices can be highly erratic depending on which apps you happen to be using at any given time, but the Galaxy Nexus definitely improves in this regard.

No contest for cameras

The iPhone 4S takes better pictures than the Galaxy Nexus. The 4S feels like an adequate replacement for most point-and-shoot cameras, while the Nexus feels like what the Nexus S was; a decent shooter for a smartphone. Discerning mobile photogs should stick with Apple, even though the Galaxy Nexus might have a very slight edge when it comes to shooting speed, but if you’re upgrading from an iPhone 4 you’ll probably appreciate the speed advantages of the Android device more, since photos are otherwise of similar quality.

Mobile OS match-up

Of course, the Android vs. iOS debate will rage endlessly, and Ice Cream Sandwich likely won’t do much to sway either side that much one way or another. But it is a solid update for Android, bringing a level of polish to Google’s platform that it hasn’t really seen thus far.

Android 4.0.1 on the Galaxy Nexus feels like it actually borrows more from Windows Phone 7.5 (s msft) than iOS, at least in terms of aesthetics, and everything in general seems to work better and smoother. That also might be the result of the dual-core processor powering the Nexus than its software. The new software buttons work well, too, and though I miss the context-sensitive Settings button among them, and don’t quite use the new multitasking tray that replaces it enough to appreciate the change, I don’t find myself missing hardware controls.

I prefer iOS 5’s notification systems to Android’s, as the lock screen still tells me very little about what’s happened while I’ve been away. Update: if you pull down the notification bar from a screen set to slide unlock, you can see your notifications in detail. But the Galaxy Nexus does get one thing I love: A notification light. Practically, it’s really not all that useful; I’m going to check my notifications on either device with about the same amount of frequency, light or no light. But it’s good-looking and provides one more avenue of feedback for users who want one.

In the end, though, Android still has the same problems it always did: it’s harder for new and inexperienced users to get into and navigate, and apps either may or may not work with the device depending on what version of Android they’re coded for and/or what devices they support.

A much tighter race

The Samsung Galaxy Nexus is a great smartphone that gets a lot of things right, and is more forward-looking than the iPhone 4S in a number of ways. It’s better at consuming mobile video, for one, and it features a lot of on-board connectivity options the iPhone doesn’t, including NFC and Wi-Fi Direct.

But in terms of the average smartphone user’s priorities right now, I still believe the iPhone 4S is the superior device. The iOS web browsing experience is still better (text rendering is better, the interface is more usable, and double-tap zooming is a necessity for one-hand browsing. Update: ICS supports this on the Nexus, it turns out), text looks better all around, it has a much better camera for capturing mobile memories, and with iOS 5, notifications provide exactly the right kind of information exactly where you want it.

The Galaxy Nexus is the best Android device yet, and ICS is the best version of Android to date, and they do a lot to narrow the gap between Google and Apple’s mobile efforts, but they don’t close it, at least not completely.

113 Comments

john

Well in my opinion, iv used both devices and to me tho Samsung and the ics has helped android pull even further ahead of apple

Gustav

It’s a good review and even though I’m an android-user since years, I know, that the iPhone is still more “complete” than all android devices! It doesn’t sound like a fanboy-report and I guess, Android really needs one more version to come to “kill” the apple-phone!

guest

fanboy forgot to mention that you can talk dirty to Siri…and she likes it.

Guest

I totally agree… Seriously a comparison with 4s without the mention of Siri. Thats absurd.

glutenfreepdx

Thanks for the review, it’s appreciated! After reading the Steve Jobs biography, and learning his absolute fury over Android’s interface theft, it’s hard for me to like a phone like this. Though as revisions go, it seems like Android is beginning to find itself, and where it excels, I give it credit. Competition is a good thing, though the iPhone still gets the bulk of the credit for taking the smartphone into the 21st century. Also, the naming scheme for Android’s OS?: idiotic.

jjh

Yeah, Apple really invented the smartphone. And as far as interface theft, development of both operating systems began in 2005. Touch screens have been around since the ’70’s, multi-touch since the ’80’s. Steve Jobs did a good job of promoting his product, and got iPhone into production before Android.

sd

I think Palm can take real credit for inventing the smart phone,the treo line of phones were out years before the iphone. Perhaps you can credit the iphone with bring smart phones to the masses.

evan_wd

interface theft? you mean like when steve jobs took the idea of a GUI from xerox?

McD

Anyone who’s compared System 1 with either Alto or Star knows what a dumb comment this is.

Tom903

Jobs PURCHASED the rights to Xerox. Not a major distinction between that and theft to some people, but we’ll let a patent judge sort it all out.

James

Your response to stolen technology is to equate it with more stolen technology? Where you born in prison? Basically your saying apple mugged xerox which makes it ok for google to mug apple. It seems both ifans and Fandroids are both stuck in the reality distortion field, here on Earth if you steal you go to jail.

mikejmobile

You read Steve Jobs biography and now you know exactly how it went down with smartphones. You are an idiot and have no idea what you are talking about. Continue using your iPhone and all other products that start with “I” because that is so incredibly creative

lang

Really? You are complaining that Google uses alphabetic codenames with a dessert reference? Just don’t let Steve Jobs biography tell you what to love and hate.

I liked the article, provided a brief comparison of the G-Nex to iPhone 4 and 4S features. Like you said, it all comes down to what you prefer.

AppleFUD

Android interface theft?

Uh, you mean the Graphical User Interface that was developed by Douglas Englebart and then worked on by others at Xerox PARC where Steve Jobs was given a demo and then his team set out to copy every aspect of it, so much so that they actually ended up creating new features that they thought they saw but weren’t actually working the way they thought they were?

You mean that theft?

Stibu

while scrolling down, I read the battery part, and just didn’t read the rest lol c’mon u think iPhone users have right to criticize battery life on android ? This is definitely a review done by an iFan.

N

and I have to mention that this comment was written by an AndroidFan – I’ve moved to an Galaxy S II from an iPhone 3GS in the past two months and am certain now that the Android battery is worse.
I love Android for a lot of reasons – built-in searching, Google account integration is stunning, built-in sat-nav is better than any sat-nav I’ve ever used so long as you have a decent connection
I also find some of it’s shortcomings woeful considering the OS has been in the public domain for a few years – in a similar way to how I thought it was inexcusable that the iPhone notification system only got an update in late 2011) but the review above definitely nailed it about battery life.

Marion

You’re right about Android battery life. It is short. My next Android phone is going to be the Motorola Photon (Sprint) because the talk time is advertised at 10 hours. The Nexus is at 8 hours .

Kevin

Will u guys shut up -____-‘
Just because a person found the iphone to be a “better fit” to their life style doesnt automatically make them a fan boy.
Jesus Christ people……

James

No end your sacrilege! Every knows anyone who mentions that the android interface is still mediocre at best, samsungs devices tend to brake quickly is a fan boy. Because I bought the iPod and iPhone I am an ifan (supposedly), although I think apple stole microsofts tech and own an Xbox 360, htc hero and Hp computer I am supposedly still an ifan. While in reality I simply believe android is and always will be junk.

throwbot

But it does when he says its a better fit for people other than himself. How does he know what size I am? He definitely tried being objective, gotta give him that. I do have to say that this article goes against 9 out of 10 battles where these phones are pitted against each other. Especially the part when he says browsing is better for the apple. He obviously didn’t go into labs and turn the side thingy on in the browser– its a one touch icon the size of half a quarter that gives you great control in the browser– in the space the size of half a quarter.

bob

Let’s be honest, if your everyday mobile device is an iphone, you will always find some fault with android.

Pete

Re: the double-tap zoom in web browsing – does ICS not have that? My OG Droid has had that all along – I can pinch to zoom on a web page but double tapping zooms in, and brings up a +/- icon in the corner to zoom in or out as well.

I’ve seen some other remarks about the plastic-y back and flimsy nature of it…I wonder if there will be after market battery covers that are made of better materials?

jdduncan

I will be buying the Galaxy Nexus whenever Verizon decides to release it. I actually feel that this was a fair review of the two devices overall. I, however, do not agree that web browsing is better on the iPhone. The Galaxy Nexus is much faster in terms of loading pages by far, over the iPhone. I don’t even think there is a question there. Plus, the text rendering is virtually the same, and you can double tap on the GNex as well. Overall – nice review

mmarceau

Not to mention that the LTE version soon to be released on Verizon will blow the iPhone out of the water when it comes to browsing speed and doing other tasks online.

Bo Philpot

yea cause all the other lte phones have been able to do this att 3g kills verizon lte, plus iphone4s does have a light for notifications

Leo Mueller

Excellent article… First initial review of the Nexus that kept me reading until the very end.

Comments are closed.