If not, let me sum them up for you: mediocre to less than mediocre, although our own Kevin Tofel seems to like it. My experience with the Kindle Fire has been less than stellar, but honestly, I’m an iPad(s aapl) guy, so the comparison is always going to be unfair.
My review of Fire was going to mirror some of the widely circulated sentiments from experts such as Walt Mossberg, so I decided to skip it for now and spend some time with the device before I have my final say. Instead, I’m focusing on the other new Kindle: the Kindle Touch.
From the minute I held it in my hands and turned it on, only one thought ran through my mind: It’s the best Kindle yet. The Kindle Touch is fast, extremely light, easy to hold, sensitive to touch and more importantly, easy on the eyes. Kindle Touch works because it’s simple and singular in purpose. There’s no clutter. Gone are the unnecessary buttons I never used. The reading experience is exactly what you would expect from Kindle: clean with little or no strain on the eyes, thanks to the e-Ink screen.
Like every device I get to review, I ignore the instructions and try to see how intuitive the device is. Kindle Touch gets 8.5 out of 10 for its intuitiveness. I tried to navigate pages back and forth with one hand and encountered no problems. I even used the swipe gesture I learned on iPhone and iPad and moved the content back and forth. The only thing I had to learn and remember: I had to touch the top of the screen in order to bring up the menu and the Kindle store.
In short, it’s a delight. Just as the original iPod made other MP3 players look decidedly dowdy, the Kindle Touch makes its older self look sad. The analogy that comes to mind is of a nerdy teenager who turns into a heart-throb in his twenties. Not only that — the Kindle Touch is a lot cheaper compared to the $400 we paid for the original Kindle four years ago.
I praise the device with just one caveat: These are my first impressions. I’ve only had a few hours with it and have read only five chapters of The Information so far. My final opinions will come after a week, but sometimes, first impressions are the right ones.