Blog Post

Update: Judge Refuses To Let Ceglia Lawyer Withdraw From Facebook Case

Stay on Top of Enterprise Technology Trends

Get updates impacting your industry from our GigaOm Research Community
Join the Community!

Five lawyers have already parted ways with Paul Ceglia, the man who claims he obtained control of Facebook for $1,000 in 2003. A sixth lawyer hasn’t be so lucky.

[Update: In an order on Friday, the judge confirmed Ceglia’s lawyer would not be permitted to withdraw from the case until he obtained a signature from Facebook’s lawyers permitting him to do so. The order reads in part: “Accordingly, it is ineffective to permit Mr. Lake’s withdrawal and must be struck.”]

The latest development in the strange case comes after a judge cast doubt on the hapless lawyer’s application to drop his client. In an order on Thursday, U.S. Magistrate Judge Leslie Foschio wrote that Jeffrey A. Lake had failed to comply with procedural rules and ordered him to explain why the withdrawal application should not be thrown out.

Meanwhile, in a separate filing, Facebook asked the Buffalo court not to approve Ceglia’s request for a three-week delay to find a new lawyer. Facebook’s attorneys said the request was an attempt by Ceglia to buy additional time in order to destroy evidence and manipulate the case from “his apparent hideout in Ireland.”

The lawsuit has taken on a surreal quality in recent weeks. It all began last year when Ceglia, who was convicted in a 2009 scam involving wood pellets, grabbed international attention with his claim that he had a contract showing that Mark Zuckerberg had signed over 50 to 84 percent of Facebook in exchange for $1,000. The possibility of sharing billions in riches proved irresistible to several law firms, including prestigious DLA Piper, which signed on to represent Ceglia in April. The firm, like others before, quietly dropped the case a short time later.

Facebook appeared to get the upper hand in the case in August after obtaining forensic evidence from Ceglia’s computers that apparently proved the contract was a fake. The company has since filed for misconduct sanctions against Ceglia and his lawyers. The lawyers, including Lake, filed a response imploring the court not to sanction them and stating that Ceglia instructed them not to comply with court orders. Lake applied to withdraw from the case last week, but the order yesterday means he may be forced to stay on a while longer. In much the same way that surgeons can’t just walk out on a patient mid-procedure, lawyers are bound by professional rules that set out how and when they can cease representing a client.

Federal rules provide judges with a broad range of disciplinary measures for those who breach orders or procedure. These can include fines, suspension or disbarment. The outlook for Team Ceglia does not look like it will brighten anytime soon as Ceglia is currently in Ireland, where Facebook says he is hiding after destroying USB devices containing evidence.

“We believe that Ceglia and his counsel should be held accountable for their extreme and disturbing behavior,” Orin Snyder, a partner at Gibson Dunn and an attorney for Zuckerberg and Facebook, wrote in a statement earlier this week.

Magistrate Order Re Lake Withdrawal
var docstoc_docid=”100344491″;var docstoc_title=”Magistrate Order Re Lake Withdrawal”;var docstoc_urltitle=”Magistrate Order Re Lake Withdrawal”;

One Response to “Update: Judge Refuses To Let Ceglia Lawyer Withdraw From Facebook Case”

  1. I have being following this story since the start and have seen a lot of
    evidence on Ceglias side which is not being broadcasted because it is
    damning to FB. Why isnt the expert views in favour of Ceglia who all
    agree Ceglia’s evidence is authentic? .Lets take this simple fact of
    email preservation, Ceglia and Zuckerberg used a program called Webmail
    to email eachother and anyone with any computer knowledge knows that
    Webmail deletes sent email in order to avoid exceeding storage limits.
    So according to Ceglia he copied the headers and texts of these emails
    into word documents in 03-04 in order to not loose them by leaving them
    in Webmail to be deleted at a later date and put them on floppy
    discs..comouter forensic expert Jerry Gran after analyzing them says
    they are consistent with how Ceglia says he copied and saved them here
    is a link to Ceglias Lawyers website it contains grants evidence along
    with others and i have to say its quite convincing
    .. Ther is much more evidence you just have to look at the facts,,
    unfortunately the media is refusing to report such facts. Or what about
    Michael McGowans biased analysis of Ceglias computer, at while ago
    McGowan outlined a framework on how to find out the authencity of such
    things, he used them on Ceglias computer but refused to use the same
    framework when analysing the computers of Zuckerberg