Delicious hopes new taste will prove a hit

63 Comments

Less than a year ago news leaked that Yahoo (s yhoo) was planning to “sunset” the social bookmarking service Delicious. Then the company backtracked, saying it didn’t plan to shut Delicious down; a sale was its preferred option.

After a wobbly few months, the site was bought by AVOS, a new company formed by YouTube (s goog) founders Steve Chen and Chad Hurley, who promised “to take on the challenge of building the best information-discovery service on the web.”

Now we get to see exactly what they mean. The new-look Delicious launched overnight.

So what do you get? Let’s take a look.

First up, signing up is easy. Although I was a long-time Delicious user, first joining back in 2005, I stopped using the service last year and defected to Pinboard.in, a great clone aimed at power users. In fact, when AVOS moved to the new Delicious, they actually deleted my original account. So I was able to use the service as if for the first time.

Once inside, there are some obvious visual changes. Everything has a slightly warmer, softer tone; gone are the sharp edges and minimalist presentations that made Delicious look like the work of an engineer.

Popular links are presented in a straightforward list, while groups of links (known as “stacks”) are pushed to users in a glossy format supported by photographs. It’s nice eye candy, but takes up a lot of screen space.

In terms of functionality? Well, it’s tempting to say that the new Delicious is a bit like Pepsi (s pep) of old: “new look, same great taste”. But it’s probably more accurate to simply point out that the revamp is less than radical.

[youtube=http://www.youtube.com/v/HcgtFUN8bgE?version=3&hl=en_US]

Most of the obvious changes are essentially updating the slightly dated lexicon of Delicious and bringing it in line with a more modern, social web context. For example, users can now add avatars — something that seems almost idiotically simple, but had never emerged with its previous, spartan approach.

Elsewhere, users now “follow” somebody instead of adding them to their network. And collections of links — which were previously known as bundles — have become “stacks”. These are described as playlists for the web, a signpost that AVOS wants to make Delicious more appealing to mainstream audiences.

In truth, however, none of this is a major departure from what Delicious already did, and it’s certainly not much of a departure from other link collecting or list-making tools such as Bitly.

In a blog post announcing the launch, AVOS admits that most of the work was behind the scenes, rather than in adding new elements to the site.

We realized that in order to keep innovating over the long term, the eight-year-old site needed to be rebuilt from the ground up. The result is a new homepage, interface and back-end architecture designed to make Delicious easier to use.

We’re proud of what we built, but the process has also brought the site “back to beta” as a work in progress.

But in doing so, it’s also managed to break some things that old-time users were used to. A string of my Twitter followers pointed out broken features. For example, existing users complain that their old bundles seem to have disappeared completely; there are lots of reports of problems with browser plug-ins, RSS feeds appear to have stopped working and some of the old pages aren’t working.

Still, these are early days. The product is essentially starting over again, and if users are prepared to accept that this is a beta then there is time — and trust — to rebuild.

Can new users be enticed? Will old users stick around? Even though the new Delicious looks juicier, it’s not clear whether the flavor it had has disappeared or been improved upon. Either way, it looks like the hard work is only just beginning.

63 Comments

Carl

Correction to the above article.

‘And collections of links — which were previously known as bundles — have become “stacks”.’

Actually, that’s not accurate; “stacks” are collections of links, true, but bundles are collections of tags, not links.

oth

(Where can I find your other article with a title something like: Delcious sucks)It still sucks.

I just entered a new link with several tags including the ones below, but I get this message when I try to find it:
“you have no links with the tags: Review, AlexaSouced”

Cathy Jo Leonard Swain

I want my bundles back. I never used Delicious as a social media site. I used it as a place to store urls for ME. I sorted everything with tags and bundles — the same way I use folders and subfolders to store documents. I looked at the video on Stacks and I’m not interested in that. I want my bundles back!!

Douglas Carnall

I’d just like to join in the chorus of disapproval on the Delicious redesign. It is not an improvement. Screen real estate is less efficiently used. Tag autocomplete was broken. I did all the required changeover steps so I don’t seem to have lost data, but the RSS feed is lost to my blogger weblog.
Time to go and check out the alternatives again. Diigo was the frontrunner when I looked at this last year. Hurley and Chen should have read this: http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000069.html

L

As far as I know, my bookmarks (links) are all there…but what happened to my tags?!

Lisa

My account is completely gone and my username is not recognized. Thanks a lot. All those bookmarks gone.

Mike Manning

Lisa, I’m with Delicious communications and want to let you know that your account is not completely gone. It’s either stored with AVOS or Yahoo, and we’ll do what we can to get you access to it again. More info on our blog: http://www.avos.com/missing-bookmarks/

James

4 years of organization and collecting gone. I used it for reference almost everyday. This has to be temporary. What have they done with all this data?It has to be re-implemented ASAP. I WANT MY BOOKMARKS BACK

Mike Manning

James, I’m with Delicious communications, and want to point you to a blog post we published for people who aren’t seeing their bookmarks: http://www.avos.com/missing-bookmarks/. If you opted into AVOS, we have all your data. If not, we’re working with Yahoo! on a solution to get you that data.

Henri

This was meant to be a cloud BOOKMARKING tool for me – a replacement of separate Bookmarks in Chrome/IE/FF . My Bundles are gone. My cloud is gone. The functional list of easily accessible tags are gone- replaced by eye-candy and whitespace. Time to look around….

DigitalAtrophe

Not only are the tags gone but 90% of my bookmarks are gone as well. I’ll look for another service that cares slightly more about my data.

Arlessiar

My account is still there. Sounds as if the time I invested into the whole data-transfer-agreement was good for something, not? Well, wrong. The account still exists but ALL MY LINKS are gone. Not “just” scrambled tags or something, no, everything’s gone completely, as if I never saved any links in the past few years at all. Seriously, Delicious – FAIL!

Ivan Borodachev

To everybody: repost your posts to Delicious page on Facebook: facebook.com/delicious

Charlotte

They’ve stripped out all the funcitons that made it so useful for me: if Delicious had functioned this poorly when I first joined four years ago, I wouldn’t have used it much at all. Avos doesn’t seem to understand how its users used the site and they were too arrogant to ask. The current site could have been developed without paying for the original Delicious, so I have to assume they wanted the brand name and the core loyal users, but they’ve utterly alienated me. Not giving me a chance to back my bookmarks up in a manner that preserved ALL my tags is utterly unforgivable. They are not to be trusted or supported after this. It’s a major fail.

Comments are closed.