Blog Post

Did Wal-Mart Throw A Lawsuit To Get Access To Netflix Customers?

Stay on Top of Enterprise Technology Trends

Get updates impacting your industry from our GigaOm Research Community
Join the Community!

Wal-Mart (NYSE: WMT) recently surged into third place in the movie-download business, barely a year after buying the startup Vudu. Now, the giant internet retailer may have scored another coup.

A new court ruling gives Wal-Mart a major boost in its effort to muscle in on Netlix’s streaming subscribers. A federal court in California late last week approved a class-action settlement that requires Wal-Mart to pay out $27.5 million. But here’s the key element of the ruling: Wal-Mart will be allowed to pay the 40 million Netflix (NSDQ: NFLX) subscribers in the form of gift cards for — where there is prominent advertising for Vudu, which rents and sells movies a la carte..

The court ruling is a blow to Netflix, which had earlier blasted the settlement as “the equivalent of a marketing campaign that costs Walmart only 68 cents per potential customer.”

The class action came in response to a dinner meeting in 2005 at which the CEOs of the Netflix and allegedly agreed to divvy up the DVD market. Consumer advocates say that under the pact, Wal-Mart agreed not to rent DVDs if Netflix agreed not to sell them. Class action suits were filed against both companies in 2009.

In what now appears to be a shrewd move by Wal-Mart, the company reached a settlement with the plaintiffs in July. The court ruling last week gave tentative approval to the settlement. Under its terms, approximately 40 million past and current Netflix subscribers in the U.S. and Puerto Rico will be notified by email that they are entitled to redeem an online settlement card at Members of the class action can also choose to receive a check in the mail. The settlement states that claimants will receive their share of the $27 million, minus 25 percent legal fees.

In court filings, Netflix argued that the settlement effectively hands over its customer list to Wal-Mart at a time when the retail giant is trying to expand its online video offerings. In response, the court approved an arrangement that will see a third party, not Wal-Mart, manage the payouts. The procedures also say that Wal-Mart cannot keep track track of which people that register their gift cards on the site are class action claimants.

Still, the way the settlement is being carried out will likely increase awareness of Vudu as a potential alternative to Neftlix at a time when Netflix is facing some new challenges. In recent months, Netflix has failed to renew a key agreement major content provider Starz and announced a controversial plan that will significantly increase costs for subscribers who elect to receive movies both in the mail and a streaming service.

For the first half of the year, Vudu had 5.3 percent of the online rental-and-purchase movie market, behind only Apple’s ITunes, with a 65.8 percent share, and Microsoft (NSDQ: MSFT) Corp.’s Zune Video Marketplace, with 16.2 percent. Vudu was more popular than comparable offerings from both Amazon (NSDQ: AMZN) and Sony (NYSE: SNE).

“Netflix continues to believe the lawsuit is without merit and the settlement changes nothing,” said spokesman Steve Swasey by email. Wal-Mart didn’t reply to phone requests for comment.

The Wal-Mart settlement is slated to receive final approval next February. Meanwhile, Netflix says it will continue to fight ongoing court claims that it is also liable for the same antitrust allegations.

8 Responses to “Did Wal-Mart Throw A Lawsuit To Get Access To Netflix Customers?”

  1. stephen ingo

    I found out about this through regular mail they sent me a letter saying you could get cash or the gift card. So i selected cash lets see how little this check is going to be. But it also depends on how many ppl file to yeah there are 40 million but if only 1 million send reguest its split up among them

  2. Sur Veilled

    Just got the email notifying me of my “rights” in this lawsuit. 
    So, I stand a chance of winning a Walmart Gift Card?!?! 
    I wipe my rear end on their Walmart Gift Card, and on Walmart too, for that matter;
    AND on the plaintiff’s attorneys.   

    Just another case of lawyers out for the lawyers. 
    They get over $6 million bucks, plus $1.7 million in expenses, and we get gift cards. 

  3. I know its like ($27mil – $6.75mil in legal fees)/40mil subscribers = $0.51 per subscriber.

    $6.75mil in legal fees/say a law firm of 100 = $67,500 per law firm employee

    Who’s getting screwed here twice?

  4. Nael Nael

    Vudu is too expensive so until it gets into the subscription business or matches Redbox pricing strategy, I will not use it. I’ve only used it a couple times but at a cost of 4.99 or 3.99 a movie, its just not worth it.