Is Google+ starting to get on Facebook’s nerves?

25 Comments

There’s no question that Google+ has quickly become the most successful social offering that Google has ever released, racking up more than 25 million users in a matter of weeks. That may still be light years behind Facebook’s user base of more than 750 million, but the search company’s social platform seems to be getting Facebook’s attention, particularly with the recent launch of Google+ social games, such as Angry Birds. While a Facebook executive recently dismissed the Google network as inconsequential, it seems clear that the competition is keeping Facebook awake at night — which may be a good thing.

It was fairly easy for Facebook to dismiss Google’s earlier social efforts such as Buzz and Wave, in much the same way it was easy for users to dismiss them. Neither one managed to gain much traction outside a small group of Google fans and early adopters, in part because Buzz suffered from some serious privacy concerns early on (after it automatically added people from a user’s email address book without making it clear that this would happen) and Wave was just too complicated and the purpose of the service was unclear. Although Buzz continues to exist — for now — Wave has been shut down.

Google+ is everything Google’s other social efforts weren’t

Google+, by contrast, has been hailed by many users as everything Google’s previous social efforts weren’t: attractively designed, easy to use, and with some appealing features such as the use of Circles to separate a user’s social graph into different groups. The company’s approach to the use of pseudonyms has gotten criticism from users — including us — but apart from that it has been well received. And according to comScore, Google+ got to 25 million users more than 10 times faster than any other service in the history of social networking (although some are already complaining it is a ghost town).

Last week, Google upped the ante by adding social games including the popular Angry Birds and Bejeweled to the platform. And that entry into social games definitely got Facebook’s attention, since games are one of the big drivers of revenue and engagement on the larger social network, thanks to a partnership with social-gaming leader Zynga.

Not only did Facebook quickly tweak its game-related features to make them more appealing to developers such as Zynga, but a Facebook executive seemed downright snippy when asked about this new competitor at a recent game-industry event, according to a report in Fortune magazine. In talking about Google’s offer to developers — the search company is offering to take only 5 percent of the proceeds from games, in contrast to Facebook’s 30 percent — director of game partnerships Sean Ryan said:

Google is at 5 percent because they don’t have any users.

Like McDonald’s and Starbucks

Ryan went on to describe Google’s effort as being similar to McDonald’s getting into coffee in an attempt to compete with Starbucks (although that might not be the best comparison from Facebook’s point of view, since a number of analysts believe McDonald’s entry into the coffee business put substantial competitive pressure on Starbucks). And the Facebook executive described Google’s launch as a copycat move, saying the company had managed to “emulate aspects of our system, which… they have the right to do.”

Games aren’t the only element of Google+ that seems to be getting on Facebook’s nerves. There have also been reports — which have been circulated on Google’s network by the company’s head of social, Vic Gundotra — that invitation links to Google+ posted on users’ Facebook pages are not showing up. Given the history of tension between the two companies over issues such as the exporting of contact information, there has been speculation that Facebook might be blocking these links, but the social network says that it isn’t aware of any such blocking.

Can Google+ become a full-fledged competitor for Facebook? The web giant has said that the launch of social games is “just the tip of the iceberg” when it comes to what the company plans to add to its social platform, and some see mobile photo-sharing as a big element of Google’s plans for the future — in part because of the recent launch of a mobile photo application called Photovine. This would take Google+ straight into another core product area for Facebook, which has become the world’s largest photo-hosting service.

This isn’t just about competing with Facebook

As I described in a recent GigaOM Pro report (subscription required), Google is making this push into social networking not just because it wants to compete with Facebook, but because it needs to tap into the “social signals” and activity that users are engaging in on such networks as part of its core search and advertising business. And Google’s new CEO and co-founder Larry Page has made it clear that these efforts are a central part of what the company wants to do by restructuring Google’s incentive system to compensate employees who contribute to its social plans.

Facebook may have had the social-networking business more or less to itself for the past few years, thanks in part to the rapid decline of MySpace, but Google has made it obvious that it wants to become a major player — and while it is still early, the launch of Google+ shows that the search giant may just have what it takes to put some competitive pressure on the larger network. In the long run, that is likely to be good for Facebook users, and for developers of third-party applications as well.

Post and thumbnail photos courtesy of Flickr user Umberto Salvagnin

25 Comments

Jim

Google as a company and breadth and depth and is taking a long view by entering the social market place. Both FB and Google+ will be able to live side by side in the longer term: we are witnessing the pangs brought about by change (which a new entrant always causes).

Eric Lam

Google is offering 5% not because it doesn’t have any users, but because it doesn’t need game/developer revenue to survive. It needs to get into user demographics and behaviors to strengthen it’s search engine.

YoungTrepGuide

My initial reaction to getting Google Plus, was excitement and optimism for the site. However, over the weeks my interest in Google Plus has decreased. There is no question, that I personally would rather be on Google Plus than Facebook, but the fact of the matter is, all of my friends, family, and colleagues are already on facebook interacting, not Google Plus. And honestly, I want to be where they are. In Facebook’s early days they initially went after the college students, and then gradually opened up to the general public. I think Google Plus should follow this strategy. If they can get the college age demographic (the trendsetters) then I believe the rest will follow. If I were google, I would bring to light the general privacy issues with facebook. Do all these kids really want a bunch of pictures of them doing beer bongs floating around the internet? No they dont! And with Google’s supreme privacy rules, this could be a huge driving point for them to get the college age kids. Then slowly the rest will follow. If facebook doesn’t become more user friendly when it comes to privacy then they definitely have a reason to fear Google Plus. I have written more about Google Plus and its future on my blog. Tell me what you think :)

-Eric
http://www.youngentrepreneurguide.com/2011/07/22/google-enters-facebooks-realm/

Ssamfffeger

I see no reason at all to switch, because there’s nothing wrong with Facebook. I think people overly concerned with switching to Google+ are just trendy kids and dumb adults who don’t understand that it’s all essentially the same concept.

cellounge

I’ll use both! Shhh don’t tell normal people about Google Plus. Intelligent conversations on Google+ while Herp Derp conversations on Facebook.

Fazal Majid

Google+’s photo sharing solves an important problem, that of securely sharing photos with selected circles of friends. Public photo-sharing sites like Flickr are too open for safety-conscious parents to post photos of their kids, and Facebook’s photo-sharing makes it hard to set permissions (ACLs, really) on a per-photo or per-album basis.

PC Support

I think its too early to say that google plus will overcome facebook, we have a very good example of My Space and Flickr…facebbok has emerged as a leader in Social media and for google plus to overcome that would take long time…

Ashtin

Google Plus is surely getting popularity at a faster rate than facebook, but facebook is a strong player it has been ruling social media till now, and in todays scenario they are not just limited to information sharing, and friends access but has become a medium to earn business, entertainment and fun, It would not be that easy for google to reach at facebook’s position…

Craig Phillips

Would someone send me an invite? Would love to join in the fray. Many thanks

John Doe

you gotta give google credit… they are the best thing
since sliced bread when it comes to the market with an
unoriginal idea… yet they manage to do it in a manner
that is ‘different’ not necessarily ‘better… they did
it with android (vs. ios) and now google+ (vs. facebook)

Arpit

I believe, “Change” is always constant in the life and Google+ is the “healthy” competition and change.

sleaf

It would be interesting to see what would happen if Google+ opened up their access, I keep reading about how great it is, but I still can’t get into it to check it out myself. If they keep this up, I’m going to give up on Google+ the way I gave up on Google Voice.

bob

The same can be said about MySpace and Friendster before that. Only time will tell as the social site trend changes. If Google did mangage to overthrow Fb then it would be hard to see anyone after g+ topping them. Could see a monopoly over many things.

Nicki

I love Google+. Facebook doesn’t catch my attention anymore. I barely go anymore. It’s too old.

jay

I highly doubt G+ will ever reach the level of FB, G+ is late to the show. The avg non-techy has already invested a great deal of time and effort to their FB profiles. G+ as it stands today is just a hub for FB haters, nerds, and journalist. All is not lost; perhaps G+ has a chance at competing with LinkedIn.

Rick Bucich

Will G+ beat FB in numbers? Doubt it. But I think the assumption about who is using actually it is pretty erroneous, I find it adopted pretty widely, especially by photographers. Remarkable since it’s still in beta and pretty much only promoted by current users.

Anon

Honestly G+ is just copying FB and other social neworking sites. I’m not a google fan to begin with. I’m sick of all the invasion of privacy from them. It’s companies like google that force me to proxy everything.

Anon

LOL, you can’t be faQing serious. Google’s invade your pivacy? How? Do you know you can delete everything they have for you? Do you know you have option to not share your personal information to companies they sell ads?
Do you know you don’t have this in FB? Yahoo, Microsoft.
And FB just rapes your butt with privacy’s invasion.
You are just stupid sir.

c

i posted an invite on my FB page, the next day my business FB page was fried. coincidence? maybe.

Comments are closed.