Blog Post

WMG Loves Spotify And Sees Music Riding The Cloud To Digital Tipping Point

Stay on Top of Enterprise Technology Trends

Get updates impacting your industry from our GigaOm Research Community
Join the Community!

The music industry will soon reach that fabled tipping point at which digital revenue exceeds lost physical sales, Warner Music Group (NYSE: WMG) CEO Edgar Bronfman Jr reckons.

The top line from WMG’s Q3 earnings today is “Digital revenue approaching half (47.6 percent) of U.S. Recorded Music revenue.”

A 13 percent growth in global digital income to $203 million helped push overall revenue up 5.2 percent to $686 million. Sold to Access Industries on July 20, WMG took $12 million from Limewire’s $105 million industry settlement. Net loss improved to $46 million. Bronfman Jr told investment analysts…

“Whilst we steadfastly refuse to call the bottom, because I’m not a clairvoyant, regardless of the positive physical trends in the US in last six months, when you look at our digital revenue, as that becomes even a larger part, it will begin to outweigh declines of physical.

“You can see the turn in the US coming. Europe is anything from 18 to 24 months behind that, but it is inexorable. All of that has happened pretty much up against one business model, which is digital downloads, and pretty much one digital downloads provider (iTunes) overwhelming everyone else.”

Of course, an acceleration in physical’s decline rate will help get us to the tipping point just as much as digital growth will.

But the thing to take Bronfman there – new models like unlimited access, mobile and streaming. For all the kerfuffle about how WMG was supposedly the main sticking point to Spotify’s U.S. launch, Bronfman Jr, who wants to ween WMG off iTunes, has long been the biggest cheerleader for these new models, including Spotify – as long as they can give labels sufficient income through their paid subscription services.

“It’s something we have been calling for and has taken much longer, frankly, than anyone would have hoped,” Bronfman Jr said today.

“(There are) many new digital business models and services – with the advent of the cloud, you’re going to see significantly broader music service introduction, strategic distribution and, I hope, a reacceleration of overall digital growth beyond the growth of digital downloads, which is what the industry has really been living on since their introduction in 2004.”

Asked about Spotify specifically, he showed none of the reluctance which he is often characterised as exhibiting last year.

We’re very pleased with the arc of Spotify’s growth. Their traction has been very encouraging. We’re very pleased with the progress so far,” he said.

“The kinds of levels that Spotify is achieving in Europe with regard to moving free users to premium paid subscriptions is also encouraging.

“If that keeps up, they will be a very profitable company themselves and will generate significant profit to Warner and the industry.”

All of which makes the method by which such services pay labels particularly intriguing, since this increasingly is no longer a per-track-download world.

“We receive a certain percent of the revenues from Spotify and a certain percentage based on a per-stream rate from Spotify,” Bronfman Jr said. “That industry pool is then apportioned on a share rate based on what’s being streamed on the Spotify service. Spotify pays advances which we recoup against the revenue that is earned.”

The CEO cited a “strict confidentiality agreement” precluding him from talking about iCloud terms, but: “We have a retail-wholesale agreement for iCloud that is not dissimilar to the way it works for download,” he said.

U.S. downloads of individual tracks (ie. iTunes Store sales) have flatlined. That’s why labels are seeking new models. Not even lowering track prices has worked. “Where we have lowered price on songs to $0.69, it has not driven any real increase in volume,” Brondman Jr said. “If you don’t particularly want a song there’s not a price at which you’re gonna buy it.”

Release | Webcast

3 Responses to “WMG Loves Spotify And Sees Music Riding The Cloud To Digital Tipping Point”

  1. ” “If you don’t particularly want a song there’s not a price at which you’re gonna buy it.” ~EGB Jr.
    But if you want a song, a reachable price helps.  At the Digital Content Exchange, we’ve created a patent-pending method for creating a board of exchange where prices can be individualized by artist and track and changed at an instant, just like stocks.  Even by “lowering” all prices, Mr. Bronfman has not helped maximize WMG’s revenue because you may make some of the more preferred tracks *too* cheap.  Having all prices at a “list” price of 99 cents or 1.29 or whatever .. is a remnant of the 1990s days of limited shelf space and makes no sense in the digital world.  Plus, it’s anti-competitive.
    See e.g.

    • albsure

      If you can hear a digital track in all its “binary glory” on a radio, on MTV/Cable, on an advert etc.. the only thing you are paying for when you buy it is the “convenience” to hear it when you want. Music is everywhere, in its top quality and can be consumed in so many places where there is no “price per song” environment, just an all you can eat buffet (i.e. cable tv cost etc, bbc license fee, ISP fee etc..).

      So it seems to me that “per song” pricing is dead. The genie is out of the bottle and its no longer apt. It reflected a time when the real cost of hearing a song in top quality was how much it cost to make a copy of the physical product (i.e. the vinyl/cd). That was tangible and the public understood that because they carried away this big block of plastic.

      They no longer see that relationship, especially if you are under 25. The future is Spotify et al.. and in turn, maybe ISP’s adding an all you can eat fee for content/media. Stop delaying the inevitable.. 

  2. Nu_Wri456

    His points are valid and interesting, but I’m baffled at why it has taken so long for the industry to jump on board and realize that the internet and it’s innovations move at the speed of sound, not old industry let’s wait and see what happens then move standards.
    Yes sites like Spotify, iCloud, TurntableFM, itunes, and many others, are all part of the new Digital Industry and cannot be ignored,we just have to make sure that the inclusion of musicians and Independent Artist are kept in the negotiation factoring when all said and done.
    Who am I? The Silver Conductor at:
    Remember:”Always know who loves you”
    The Silver Conductor