Blog Post

@ CES: Hollywood Digital Czars Rain On Smart TV Parade

Stay on Top of Enterprise Technology Trends

Get updates impacting your industry from our GigaOm Research Community
Join the Community!

Television manufacturers, take note: All those new sets you’ve crammed with apps and other internet-derived content experiences aren’t impressing some pretty key constituents in the entertainment industry.

A panel discussion here at CES on Thursday afternoon drew some sharply critical assessments of the so-called smart TVs.

“They’re clearly not ready for primetime,” said Curt Marvis, president of digital media at Lionsgate (NYSE: LGF), who went on to describe the poor functionality of one particular device whose manufacturer he did not identify. “Other than Netflix (NSDQ: NFLX) and Qriocity (Sony), there was nothing on there that worked very well at all. It reminded me of the old CD-ROM days.”

Marvis later added, “People are loading up these BD players and sets with all these apps but i haven’t seen many that are that compelling today.”

Hardie Tankersley, vice president of online content at Fox Broadcasting, also panned the consumer-electronics industry’s history of trying to bring the web-browser experience to the TV.

“I think web-browsing experience on TV has always sucked and still sucks,” said Tankersley. “Nobody wants it now on Google (NSDQ: GOOG) TV. It’s lame.”

Of course, Fox and Google TV aren’t on the best of terms right now given the broadcasters has blocked its programming from the new service, as have a number of other TV networks.

However, some of the other panelists noted that monetizing TV content in the app environment is going to be crucial to sustain the economics of premium-programming production.

“TV won’t exist five years from now if there isn’t a way to fund up-front development,” said Steve Canepa, general manager for IBM’s global media and entertainment industry division. “The app environment allows for authentication, it allows for a business model that gets a much better share for the content creator.”

Added John Penney, executive president of strategy and business development at Starz, “Staking out a position on the OS layer of this is what the battle is about right now.”

One Response to “@ CES: Hollywood Digital Czars Rain On Smart TV Parade”

  1. Seventy per cent of sports fans and 55% of drama viewers said they want to interact with TV –

    And there’s plenty more here.

    Some TV Apps on the Samsung, Sony, LG, Yahoo and other platforms work very well leaning back.

    For instance – well the obvious is Netflix. It’s being streamed via IP, not through cable. It’s a huge part of Connected TV that’s being missed somewhat here.

    My daughters love watching Justin Bieber when they want, on the big screen via the Youtube App on our Samsung [email protected] TV. They use the apps more than me.

    What about a Travel App? One that has HD video and info about destinations my family is thinking about going to for holiday? A la Carte – rather than watching the travel channel broadcasting places I don’t want to go, I lean back and relax – rather than everyone hovering forward over a desktop or laptop.

    We also have an app on the Samsung platform in Holland called Funda that shows all the properties for rent and sale in the country including video, images and descriptions. Searchable by postal code.

    Google Maps, Weather Radar, simple games, HD previews on what’s going on in the cinema down the street etc.

    Social is nice – but it’s just a part of the connected TV experience. And it’s likely not to be a one screen play but rather two – whether on a tablet, smart phone or advanced touchpad remote (Samsung has one that is shipping with a number of their Smart TVs in 2011 and Social Media Apps sit on the second screen rather than cluttering the one…. which is better for group or family viewing anyway.

    People are multi-stacking their media more and more according to a number of studies – particularly the Millennials.

    That’s my take anyway.

    Richard Kastelein