Blog Post

RIM vs Kik, Round 3: A Patent Infringement Suit

Stay on Top of Enterprise Technology Trends

Get updates impacting your industry from our GigaOm Research Community
Join the Community!

Updated: Research In Motion (s rimm), maker of the popular BlackBerry OS and handsets, filed suit in Canada on Tuesday against Kik, creators of a popular third-party instant messaging app. According to David Lam, an Ontario-based lawyer, the suit alleges that Kik has infringed on RIM patents with its messaging software, which attracted 2.5 million users roughly one month after launching in October.

This legal action is the third shot RIM has taken at Kik, which rivals RIM’s own BlackBerry Messenger Service by providing real-time instant messaging, even across multiple phone platforms. On Nov. 12, RIM pulled Kik out of the BlackBerry App World software store, citing a breach of contractual obligations. According to Kik, just two weeks later, RIM disabled push access for Kik, leading to delayed messages for Kik users on BlackBerry devices. In addition, RIM removed Kik’s access from the BlackBerry Developer Kit and Signing Keys, effectively stopping any future BlackBerry development on Kik.

While I haven’t seen the legal complaint nor the alleged breach of contract, I’d like to see RIM and Kik work out the issues for the sake of BlackBerry users, if possible. Clearly, with such demand for Kik, it provides a service that RIM currently doesn’t — or provides a similar service that’s better. If Kik broke some contract to provide the service, that is an issue, of course, and RIM should indeed protect its rights.

But the situation illustrates another alarming example of contentious control in the mobile space: Apple (s aapl) has it with iOS hardware and software, Google (s goog) has it in Android with its apps and marketplace and RIM has control with the centralized infrastructure services it provides. This current control issue with Kik is currently only rearing its head on BlackBerry devices; versions of Kik that are available for iOS and Android are unaffected by RIM’s actions.

Update: The full statement of claim from RIM is embedded below. Kik has also posted a response to the lawsuit on the company’s blog, entitled “A Sad Day in Waterloo,” which states:

RIM sued us yesterday… the company I worked for as a co-op student. The company I loved. The company that I thought could benefit from Kik’s vision for a mobile community. The company that placed Kik on Blackberry App World without issue. The company I shared our entire plan with every step of the way, is suing us. I’m not afraid. I’m not surprised. But I am disappointed. RIM, I wish it could have been different. I wish you would have returned our calls. I wish we could have worked together to bring great things to all of our users. Maybe next time.

Related content from GigaOM Pro (sub req’d):

4 Responses to “RIM vs Kik, Round 3: A Patent Infringement Suit”

  1. Meh.

    I know the internet tends to root for the underdog, put IP is IP people. I’ve read (speculative) reports saying that Kik uses some of BBM’s code. I’m inclined to believe that since RIM hasn’t had a beef with similar products (What’sApp comes to mind).

    I suppose we’ll see once this goes to court.

  2. Narayanan

    One of the main reasons that RIM is able to keep its head above the water is the BBM driven market in the conservative Middle East and India. No way the are going to open it up ;)
    On top of it, the whole BIS service is really a good money spinner for the carriers ! upwards of $20-40 a month!

  3. Every survey focused on consumer/corporate smartphone adoption has RIM losing ground to Apple and Google.

    RIM should focus their attention on innovation (i.e., developing new products and services), instead of acting like a 3-year old trying to protect their precious “toys.”

    The world is “growing up” and RIMs throwing a temper-tantrum.

    Just my two cents. I’m sure I have “change” coming.

    • “change” – nice.

      Agreed that RIM should support Kik eventually, but they might stall it while they still enjoy some unique advantages in their messaging apps. Also, kicking Kik’s hind quarters in court might keep some Palm – er,RIM – features out of iOS and Android for a while longer.