Stay on Top of Enterprise Technology Trends
Get updates impacting your industry from our GigaOm Research Community
Patent-holding company NTP yesterday filed suit in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia against Apple (s aapl), Google (s goog), HTC, LG, Microsoft (s msft) and Motorola (s mot) for alleged violation of eight NTP patents for wireless email delivery. In 2001, NTP filed a similar suit against Research In Motion (s rimm), and in 2006, the suit was dismissed after RIM paid $612 million in a settlement. As a result of that arrangement, RIM is not named in the new suit, nor is Nokia — the world’s largest smartphone maker — since both companies have licensing agreements with the patent company.
In today’s press statement, NTP notes that after the RIM settlement, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office Board of Patent Appeals reviewed NTP’s patents and ruled that 67 of NTP’s patent claims in four patents were valid. Without overturning those patents, the six handset and smartphone-software makers listed in the current suit appear to have the odds stacked against them, given that all provide wireless access to email. Unless these companies have developed some new or unique method to wirelessly transfer email, there’s a fair chance that NTP’s intellectual property is considered to be in use without permission or licensing.
NTP’s suit may sound like a slam-dunk, but there’s hope for the currently named companies. After the settlement with RIM in 2006, NTP turned to file suit against Palm (s palm) for similar alleged infringements. The following year, courts put the lawsuit on hold and the suit hasn’t moved forward since then, nor has NTP worked out any licensing deal with Palm, which is currently being acquired by HP (s hpq).
None of the companies named in the suit have commented on the NTP patent situation. If they do, we will update this post with their responses.
Related research on GigaOM Pro (sub. req’d):