One Month Later: The iPad

27 Comments

It’s been a little over a month since I’ve introduced the iPad to my digital workflow. In a post last year, I wrote, “I’m not saying I don’t think there is a market for a device that’s larger than an iPhone but smaller than a MacBook …” and lo and behold, that is how Apple (s aapl) billed it.

I did have an iPad-sized hole in my life. For me, a MacBook is weighty overkill. I have two jobs: the corporate-level one that pays the bills and my writing gig where I blog, freelance, and work on personal projects. The day job comes with its own Windows laptop that I lug around. I try to maintain a separation between the corporate job and personal work, so there’s very little in the way of personal data on the work machine. My commute is almost four hours round-trip. Most of it’s on a train, but if I wanted to write, I’d need the MacBook with me.

For personal work, my needs are modest. I need to write, research ideas, and read a book or watch a video. Simply put, I just need a tool to let me put words down. I don’t care about how they look when I’m composing on the iPad; just want to get them out of my head and onto what passes for paper for these days.

Productivity

A month in, I find Pages whelming. I felt Pages was about one patch from elevating itself from “merely OK” to “good,” and the 1.1 patch did that with support for landscape toolbars. I find myself to be fairly proficient with the virtual keyboard. While I am clearly faster and more accurate with an external keyboard, the iPad doesn’t seem to handle swapping between virtual and physical keyboards well, so I tend to stay with the iPad’s.

What I wasn’t expecting is, even at home, I prefer to write on the iPad. I think it comes down to a fantastic screen and, oddly, the single-tasking nature of the device. Pages gives me enough of a distraction-free environment that I can focus on writing.

For an in-depth look at Pages for Mac, view Pages 101 (subscription required).

I’m going to be giving a talk in a month or so, and as much as I try and tell myself I can do it on the iPad, the fact is, I can’t. While I tend to use my own fonts for my talks, I can design an effective presentation for the iPad using stock fonts, but I don’t want to be chained to the podium with no remote control.

The presentation issue pales to getting files to and from the iPad. Original rumors hinted of some sort of a shared-pool for files, but that never came true. Instead, each app still has files isolated to its own sandbox. You can use iTunes to transfer files into the sandboxes, but it’s a pain. Since there’s no true syncing, I can’t really work on a file on a desktop and get it back to the iPad without feeling like I’m playing a shell game. My ideal solution would be to have a Documents version of Photos. Apps could read and write to that sandbox to their heart’s content and there would be  OS-level integration of MobileMe iDisk.

These issues, while frustrating, don’t make me regret my decision to buy the iPad at all. I’m getting more done with the device, so that’s a win

Recreation

Like most writers, I read. A lot. I probably read about 30-40 books a year, not counting assigned reading for class and the like. I also am somewhat of a magazine junky. The iPad is indispensable for consuming this type of media.

Amazon’s (s amzn) Kindle app and Apple’s iBooks are both fine readers. Amazon’s selection is better, but I like the flexibility in iBooks’s presentation; the ability to change the order of my library is huge. However, when I’m researching, Amazon’s note tool wins out.  One small thing iBooks does is tell me how many pages are left in a chapter. That’s great for reading in bed and deciding if I want to commit to the next chapter.

I find the Zinio app fine for reading magazines. Recent updates have significantly improved page load times. As with the Amazon app, my chief complaint is not being able to arrange the library the way I want it. Deleting magazines seems undoable, also. I’d love an archive feature like the Kindle’s. I have a few subscriptions that thoughtfully provide DRM-free PDFs and GoodReader is my choice for reading them.

3G vs Wi-Fi

This was one of the hardest decisions I made regarding the iPad. In the end, I chose the Wi-Fi because it was out sooner. A close family member was having some major surgery and hospital stay before the 3G came out. I’d had some luck using the iPhone during a previous hospital visitation, but knew the iPad would be better. I also knew I’d be weak and keep the $30 data plan going and didn’t want the expense. While there have been times I wished the iPad had always-on Internet, I don’t regret my decision.

Final Thoughts

A month later, like my iPhone, the iPad is a device I rarely leave the house without. Its excellent battery life means I don’t need to worry about charging out. A heavy night of writing, surfing and game playing barely takes 30 percent of the battery. I like that I can get a creative idea and be writing it in less than 30 seconds. I do see an anti-glare film in my immediate future. It’s almost unusable outside, and a frequent place I use it has a fluorescent light directly overhead.

How about you? One month later, what are your thoughts?

27 Comments

Jules

As a huge Mac fan, I anxiously awaited the 3G because I already had my iPhone, iPods, Mac desktop and apple tv. I bought the iPad primarily to use in my yard, otherwise,I would just use the Mac desktop inside the house.

After only three days of use, I am so majorly disappointed in my ability to use the iPad outdoors. It shuts down outdoors after 15-30 minutes of use with a Temperature shut off screen. I was using it in the shade, so I could see the screen and to keep it out of the direct sun. It was in the mid 70’s outdoors with a breeze each time it shut down. It is a fabulous device that I want to use outdoors, but can’t, so what is the point? Please, please, please will the powers that be at Apple address this! Also, not only does it shut down, but it does so without warning and doesn’t save any of your work.

PS…..where is the clock? I really miss it.

Clarkson

“I did have an iPad-sized hole in my life. For me, a MacBook is weighty overkill. I have two jobs: the corporate-level one that pays the bills and my writing gig where I blog, freelance, and work on personal projects. The day job comes with its own Windows laptop that I lug around. I try to maintain a separation between the corporate job and personal work, so there’s very little in the way of personal data on the work machine. My commute is almost four hours round-trip. Most of it’s on a train, but if I wanted to write, I’d need the MacBook with me.”

OMG it sucks to be you. 4 hours commuting, 2 jobs, and yet your concern is buying more unnecessary gadgets. Funny now people get so caught up in their lives they don’t see the big picture. Almost 30 hours a week sitting on a train? Sounds like a fine slice of hell. Oh well, join the herd.

Josh Flaco

still don’t see why you can’t use one of your EXISTING computers to write on, during the train ride. You are creating this need, not your work. Why you can’t pop open a laptop that you already have next to you and write on that, is beyond me. No, better go spend another $1000 bucks on another device. It’s OK to go buy things you want, but to justify it like you have; SAD dude, sad.

Enrique

The stupid thing hat kein USB anschluss…!! ;o) Oh MAN!
Wie blöd muss man sein um den eigenen Untergang nicht zu
merken. Wird es ab Freitag verkauft…?! Vorbestellung
notwendig…?! Dat glaubt Ihr selber nicht , oder? Dat
ding ist blöd wie “digitales bilder frame” , zum kaufen
schade , zum verschenken …na ja…wenn es schon die Mutti
will.
Das Ding hat nicht mal eine Cemera, habe ich gerade festgestellt. Oh MAN! Das hat sogar mein SAMSUNG second
hand / gebrauchtes ganze 15USD teueres ersatz handy was
ich in der Ukraine auf dem Flohmarkt gekauft habe. Oh ne ,ne?!
Steckkarten einschub fehlt auch noch…?! Oóh MAn ! Das hat
sogar das digitale bilder frame was meine OMA bei dem Kegel
Verein in Tombola gewonen hat! Eh MAN der Mittelalter ist
wieder da! Die Yankees werden untergehen …und das auf dem
weg dorthin gar nicht merken! Elwis Obama Superstar hat es bestimmt schon den Kindern gekauft/ vorbestellt … :)

Mike Stroven

I still compare the iPad with my Newton MessagePad 2100… So far, the iPad doesn’t do the one thing that I love the most about my Newton – handwriting recognition! Apple has shelved this amazing technology which they had a decade lead on all other players, and now my Nokia phone does it, but not the iPad… What is up with that?! Also, of all the things I see myself really enjoying with the iPad, iChat AV is probably top of the list. Lastly, the “iTunes” paradigm for data-transfer to- and from- the device has got to end. iTunes has become a giant hack because Apple has dumped everything from contact sync to Movie rental into it. C’Mon Apple!! This is NOT the way Human Interface used to be done in Cupertino.. In fact, it’s starting to look an aweful lot like Redmond around there…
My $.02

Hoya63

The ipad has essentially replaced my laptop. The major app left on the laptop is Quicken. I have the 3G model, and as of this writing haven’t had a need to invoke it, including a cross country plane trip ( during which I watched two movies on it).

Found Simple Note to be a great app for me. It synchronizes my iphone, ipad and imac almost instantly via the cloud. This type of synch should be a mandatory app spec.

Read the news every morning with coffee. Sad to say the Safari page of news like the New York Times and USA Today is far better than the app and you can load an icon for the web version via bookmarks. I have a subscription to the WSJ on my iphone, but dropped reading it do to its insane pricing policy for the ipad.

Read ebooks using ibook and the kindle apps. Like Kindle/Amazon selection & pricing but the killer feature for me is the imbedded dictionary on the ibook. Also nice is the ease of adjusting the illumination, especially in bed when the lights go down.

There are a couple of drawbacks:

Security — A 4 digit passcode is weak. I hope I don’t lose this. There are a lot of pw’s imbedded in the apps, eg email.
Remote printing–nuff said

Could go on and on about the positive features and experience.
( Did I mention battery life, weight, no heat, GPS etc)

The world is beginning to understand this revolutionary and exciting device. Other companies are about as far behind as they were at iphone announcement time. They don’t quite get it.

Now if they would just write this app for the ipad…..

Rich

Others have mentioned GoodReader as a means of moving docs on and off your iPad; I agree.

Give it a try!

Mark Crump

I do use Goodreader. My use if it may have gotten cut during an edit.

Jose Betancur

I love the iPad, at work I use a laptop and even that I bring my iPad to meetings giving the laptop a Desktop only use…

The whole iWork suite is amazing, but Apple has to learn more about using the Cloud even a MobileMe connection would be great on them.

GoodReader and Sketchbook are to great apps also.

And If you are an student you definitively had to check Quick Graphs, that 2d and 3d graphic calculator is very usable and its a great tool.

Khürt L Williams

I pre-ordered iPad 3G on April 3, 5:33 AM PST. The Apple store started selling that at 5:30 AM PST. I waited one month for my device. What do I think about it 19 days later? Well … my MacBook has only been opened once. I was a photographer at a martial arts event last weekend. The iPad Camera Connection Kit had still not shipped from Apple. So I had to use my MacBook in the field to dump my photos from my full SD cards. My iPad is my “going out of the house” device. I don’t leave home without it. I have my iMac for “real work”.

Nik

One month later? That we’re still waiting for it here in Australia… Eight days to go!!

Rob

There is no better tool for surfing the web than an iPad. When I’m at home (I have to carry a laptop for work, so my iPad is mostly for my wife and I to use at home), I never bother to get out may laptop; it’s just too cumbersome. I’m a Scrabble fan from way back and the iPad version is addictive – I play a game almost every day.

One thing I’ve never seen reviewed about the iPad before is the total lack of HEAT. Watching a movie on my MacBook Pro is painful, I have to find something to put between me and its heat. The iPad can play video for hours without heating up at all.

Randi

Have you tried Evernote for moving stuff around? I love it because I can clip just part of an article or web page to remember exactly what I need.

Mark Crump

yeah, I have.

I have a hell of a time getting the iPhone client to sync properly.

I’m an Evernote premium customer.

EA

I love the iPad! In fact, it replaced the wife’s computer, so I have one less macbook pro in the house (which freed up a 30″ display, KB, and magic mouse for my use!). She only needs access to the web; email, web sites, and daily news, so it was a simple move for her. The one requirement was a real keyboard, so I got the dock with the keyboard and now the iPad sits conveniently and prominently displayed in the kitchen, always charged and with a real keyboard.

As stated before, it is easy for visitors to check their mail, or browse some site when they’re over, as I don’t have to lend them my main computer (MBP 13″) or disrupt whatever work I may be in the middle of. The kids use it browsing, mail, games, etc as well, so it is the most used “computer” in the house by far as it is always available, on the couch, in bed, etc.

At night, she grabs it off the stand and brings it to bed where she can read her books, play her games, catch up on email, and browse the latest news. Once she’s asleep, I grab it to do the same as it’s much lighter and more convenient than a 13″ MBP in bed.

I have the WiFi only, as I wanted it on day 1, but the only time I really miss 3G is when on a long drive (like the one we just made from NY to FL) where a large map would be nice for navigation; the iPhone still fulfills this duty, but in a much smaller screen.

Overall, the iPad will never fully replace a laptop (which did replace all desktops with the addition of external monitor, KB, mouse) for me as I need applications like Photoshop, CAD, Windows, dev environments and more, but the iPad is the most popular “PC” in the house and certainly has won a permanent place there.

Andrew

@Unlimited Whilst getting data onto the iPad is a kludge, it’s getting it off that is the real issue. Dragging or e-mailing to myself is so last century. When I can save back from iWorkPad to Dropbox, MobileMe or anything else, I’ll be happy.

Come on Apple the cloud IS the answer.

Mark Crump

Yah, this is a mess. Right now, to get it back on the cloud I e-mail it myself, open it in Goodreader and move the file to the cloud.

About three steps too many.

Khürt L Williams

A service like Dropbox is one answer to that problem. Install Dropbox on your Mac or Windows computer. Install the Dropbox app on your iPad (or iPhone/iPod Touch). Save files from your Mac to Dropbox and they are synced to the cloud service. Open and edit them in the Dropbox app on your iPad. Save back to the cloud. Syncs back to your desktop. Think of Dropbox as a network drive where network = Internet.

Link: http://blog.dropbox.com/?p=492

Byran

Heh—”iPad sized hole”. And I’d have to agree, really. It’s the datebook I’ve never used until now, the iPod in my car, the note-taking app I’ve always wanted, and the way it opens apps so quickly—it’s a single purpose, do anything device. It’s also become the one computer I don’t mind letting people use, due in part to it’s single serving nature. Normally, I’m concerned when I let people use my MBP because of the sheer amount of things I have open (with most of it not backed up). Should they accidentally close something, shut down the computer, or otherwise fuck something up, I would cry (I think. Hasn’t actually happened yet to that extent). The iPad changes this.

Boy oh boy do I love my iPad! I am Jack’s playful, consumption-oriented computer that gets work done.

Tom Moore

I pretty much agree with your assessment, except that I don’t move files around using iTunes at all and find iWork to be quite serviceable for that.

The huge problem I’ve run into is that documents edited in Pages and exported to Word are not only butchered (headers and footers), but when one tries to copy something out of one of these Word files and paste it into an email, Word very reliably and fatally crashes. Mail.app is none too happy about the experience either!

Until the iWork suite is as good at this as it is on the Mac, the iPad is not going to work for my routine workflows, and will remain a disappointment.

Eric

Pages is far from useless. I like it a lot. (Being a journalist, that ought to count for something.) But I have found Numbers to be the most useful of the three, and I’m pretty much spreadsheet illiterate.

Chaitanya

I love my iPad. It is addicting. Always end up looking for ways I can use it than my laptop and its been a while since i carried it home. Handy. It is a killer!!

Unlimited01

Use Dropbox for your file storage. They just made a iPad update yesterday that will allow files to be exchanged with certain programs like iWorks and photo Sounds pretty snazzy and it is a easy way to get files from your PCs, Macs, and iPad…

I can send you an invite if you would like (I get more storage with referrals :-) )

Mark Crump

I have a drop box account. Stuff I need to sync with work goes on Dropbox, personal stuff is on iDisk.

rickla

You might want to proofread the article before it becomes too popular. Feel free to delete this comment if you do.

what passes for paper for these days
so I tend to say with the iPad’s
before the 3G game out

Comments are closed.