If a new online privacy bill proposed today by two U.S.
senators congressmen becomes law, web surfers could find themselves confronted with a growing swarm of disclosure notices, opt-in requests and user information licenses whenever they try to use websites and services that employ online advertising. The draft bill’s chief proponent — Rick Boucher, chairman of the House Subcommittee on Communications, Technology and the Internet — said it’s designed to strike a middle ground between privacy protection and the need for online companies to benefit from interactive and targeted advertising. But if the reaction by consumer groups is any indication, the two sides are still light-years apart.
Digital privacy has become an ongoing brush fire that flares up almost weekly. Google has been slammed by privacy authorities from countries around the world for its practices, and Facebook has come under scrutiny from privacy groups and a coalition of four senators who sent a letter to the company asking it to refrain from “opting in” users to new information-sharing features, and to provide easier ways to control what information is shared. One of the senators involved, Charles Schumer, has also written to the Federal Trade Commission asking it to take action against the company.
Facebook has even been criticized by its own former privacy chief, Chris Kelly, who is now running for California Attorney General. Rep. Boucher, meanwhile, has been discussing a digital privacy bill for at least a year, and says he’s been meeting with both industry groups such as the Interactive Advertising Bureau and privacy advocates trying to come up with a solution that satisfies both sides. But it doesn’t appear that such a goal is even possible.
Industry supporters say the bill would bring U.S. laws around digital privacy closer to the more strict European legislation in that area, and have complained that any restriction on privacy rules for advertisers would threaten the $23 billion online advertising market that’s still struggling to recover from the recession. Most of the privacy groups that responded to the proposed legislation on a conference call following its release, however, say that Boucher’s bill is a sop to the industry and perpetuates a “bankrupt notice and opt-out system that just doesn’t work.” One privacy advocate — Evan Hendrix, editor of Privacy Times magazine — said that the bill was actually worse than having no legislation at all. A coalition of these groups sent a letter to Congress on Monday complaining about a lack of appropriate legislation and calling on the FTC to get tough on web services.
Ginger McCall of the Electronic Privacy Information Center said on the conference call that the consumer advocacy group was disappointed by the proposed bill, and that it would do little to nothing to stop companies like Facebook from collecting and using information. She said that the group, which has already filed one complaint with the FTC about Facebook, was planning to file another complaint today. Peter Eckersley of the Electronic Frontier Foundation said that the bill should provide “better default rules of the road” for online companies “so that you don’t need to worry about reading all the fine print or opting out of everything.” He said the exemption for what the bill called “operational data” collected through cookies and web logs was also “troubling.”
In a Washington Post interview last year, Boucher said the bill would take a “measured approach” to privacy. “Targeted advertising has great value and encourages more Web traffic,” he said. “The goal is for people to use the Internet more and trust it more by giving a clear sense that the Internet is secure…If not for the ability to target advertising for Internet users, there would not be as much free content.” Members of the Interactive Advertising Bureau’s Public Policy Council are meeting next week in Washington to get an update on the bill. Council members represent entertainment and content companies such as Disney and ESPN, as well as data collection and analysis firms like Bluekai and major web players such as Google and Amazon.
Related content from GigaOM Pro (sub req’d): Social Advertising Models Go Back to the Future