Blog Post

Surprise! HTC Doesn’t Agree With Apple Regarding Suit

HTC has finally spoken out regarding the pending lawsuit Apple (s aapl) launched against the smartphone maker regarding its use of multi-touch as an interface navigation mechanism, and around 20 other technologies. It should surprise absolutely no one that the Taiwanese company doesn’t see eye-to-eye with the iPhone maker regarding the appropriateness of its use of the tech.

HTC CEO Peter Chou released a statement Wednesday addressing the recently filed suit directly. According to Chou, as quoted by InformationWeek, “HTC disagrees with Apple’s actions and will fully defend itself.” HTC’s stance, like that of Apple, is that it respects and values healthy competition and innovation. Of course, that shared premise leads both companies to quite different conclusions.

Chou elaborates HTC’s position further in the official statement:

HTC strongly advocates intellectual property protection and will continue to respect other innovators and their technologies as we have always done, but we will continue to embrace competition through our own innovation as a healthy way for consumers to get the best mobile experience possible.

Apple is no stranger to suits from other companies, and it certainly hasn’t shied away from pursuing legal action itself in the past. A suit against Nokia (s nok) along similar lines is still ongoing. HTC shouldn’t be surprised about the move, either, considering the fact that multi-touch wasn’t officially introduced as a launch feature on the Nexus One, even though the hardware supported it. It was added later by Google (s goog) to the device via a software update. Sure seems like an attempt to dodge the ire of multi-touch’s proclaimed originator to me.

The Nexus One is almost certainly the catalyst for this suit, and with good reason. Despite the fact that the device itself isn’t selling anywhere near at the level of the iPhone, recent evidence suggests that the phone has raised the profile of Android, which seems to be positioning itself to make a serious bid on Apple’s smartphone market dominance. If Apple is ever to strip Google of some of that momentum, the time to do so is now.

But are the claims Apple is making valid, or is it just an attempt to strike down any and all competition before the consumer gets a chance to choose? I’m no legal expert, but it seems to me that Apple is going after some very basic concepts in its legal claims, ones without which the concept of a modern smartphone would be untenable. I’m all for giving credit where credit is due, but if we’re to see cell tech progress, it has to be at the behest of the free market, and that means not unduly placing restrictions on Apple’s competitors.

8 Responses to “Surprise! HTC Doesn’t Agree With Apple Regarding Suit”

  1. @ Alexis & : the superiority of Apple’s implementation of touch technology is not at stake here. It is whether the concept of multi-touch – and some other basic smart phone functions – is intellectual property of Apple. And as most people agree most of those functions were not invented by apple, only ‘perfected’, there seems to be little basis for a IP claim.

    It seems to me that Apple is pursuing these cases more for their publicity than fortheir potential legal success.

  2. and as far as multi-touch being IP…try using some other companies trackpad and then use the Macbook trackpad…

    3 billion times different…and trust me there has been multi-touch in trackpads for years…hell…the iBook can see 2 fingers if you install a 3rd party program…but what Apple has created is light years beyond anything else out there…

  3. Apple bought Fingerworks years ago for this technology and they then perfected it…and placed it in their iPhone, iPod Touch, and Macbooks…

    so if the HTC phone is using the same tech behind the multi-touch in those products then Apple has a claim…I have used other touch phones and will never use them again…they are unreal…the fact is that Apple figured out how to do it…and placed patents on that way…and if someone else is doing it too…then they are breaking the law…

    if you want to figure out how to do it yourself without taking advantage of Apples investment in the process then go ahead…do it better but don’t copy it…and from what I see it seems they copied it in many ways…and that is not right…

    I hope Apple reigns supreme on this matter because they are the best…can’t wait for the iPad…April get here quick

  4. I love apple and all but claiming that multitouch is an intellectual property is like saying using a button on a remote control to change the channel is an ip. It may have been at one point but really isn’t anymore. Unless there is some underlying physical technology that htc is using, and not just the concept of multitouch, I don’t agree with apple at all on this one.