Blog Post Beta Updated, Still No Editing

Stay on Top of Emerging Technology Trends

Get updates impacting your industry from our GigaOm Research Community
Join the Community!

The team at Apple (s aapl) sent out an e-mail to registered users today touting new accessibility from Apple mobile devices and more sharing options for all. However, the biggest feature, really the only feature that matter — editing documents — remains missing.

Carefully not introduced as an online productivity suite designed for collaboration, the beta site has existed as little more than an online repository for sharing iWork documents. The only real advantage over simply e-mailing documents has been the ability to comment via sticky note and downloading in multiple formats.

More than a year later, the changes have been minimal, and that may be exactly the way Apple wants it.

As of today, “ allows you to share a document by creating a public link” with an incredibly long URL. However, accessing the public link does not allow the adding of comments or notes. Sharing documents is a little more efficient with a single page for doing so and a counter indicating the number of views for the document.

The other change, likely in anticipation of the iPad, is something that should have included from the beginning: a mobile interface.

The new interface has “improved scrolling” and supposedly helps you “find your shared documents faster.” Unfortunately, what it does not do is show comments and notes, making the value of even more dubious, if that’s possible. It’s becoming more and more apparent that an online version of iWork akin to Google Docs may not be coming at all. After all, Apple has never suggested was meant for anything more than sharing, rather a collaborative online productivity suite was just logically assumed.

Well, the new logic is even simpler, that being is cloud storage for the iPad. With the announcement of a native version of iWork for the iPad, makes a lot more sense. Instead of syncing with iTunes to transfer documents to your computer, you upload them to, hopefully with an option to synchronize in the near future. Apple gets $10 for each iWork App for the iPad and gives away the online storage.

Those waiting for to leave beta status and be useful may get the former on April 3, but don’t count on logging into and editing documents anytime soon.

Related GigaOM Pro research(sub req’d):

Who Owns Your Data in the Cloud?

11 Responses to “ Beta Updated, Still No Editing”

  1. I like iWork’s simplicity. I find commenting more useful than editing when working on group projects in school. I don’t really see the point in Apple trying to replicate Google Docs with iWork unless they could make it significantly better.

  2. Andrew Gough

    My feeling is that long term the iPad’s appeal is going to be limited by the need to have a home computer of whatever flavour. Cut that umbilicus and it really does start to become a netbook killer. With limited physical connectivity, the cloud is the saviour to Moses’ Tablet. That being the case, Apple needs to a) raise the game of and b) get that new data centre online pronto.

  3. I agree, I too don’t see the point in online editing. I mean, look at how complex a Pages layout can be. I don’t see a web application capable of matching that complexity in the near future.

    Sharing the documents is useful because it allows my clients to see the docs and post comments, and works pretty well. The commenting system is almost real-time, it’s working like a chat. Thats really awesome.

  4. Tsubame

    Sounds about all I need honestly anyway. I hate the idea of google docs, never really used it because I don’t see the point in online-editting.

    Being able to get/share out my docs online is all I’m really looking for, so this looks to be pretty sufficient for that.

    • Apple has decided to go the App Store route, at least for now, and for now I think it’s the right move. However, it’s not just Google Docs we are talking about online. Microsoft, which bases a large part of its business model on desktop office applications, is currently running a trial of “lightweight” office applications on the web. It might be several years, but eventually fast connections and web apps are going to take the place of dedicated desktop productivity applications.

      • Rick Mahmoud

        Needless to say I work on a Mac but 100% of my co-workers around the world use PCs. I consolidate the creation and proliferation of presentations (which I use keynote for) that will be eventually be presented to clients around the world by our field service reps. My reps can’t download keynote docs on their PCs neither the PPT version ’cause keynote and ppt are not entirely compatible and the presentation when converted in to PPT gets out of whack and most of the animations are gone. And if their only option is to download and print a fixed PDF version, why is the point of creating animated presentations? iWork should allow people on the field to be able to not just look (and sure, download the PDF if they want) but also iWork should show the keynote presentation as the keynote application does. Kind of keynote-online but without the ability to create and edit. That way, apple’s application key features (editing and creating) are safeguarded but allowing my reps to simply be able to get their laptops connected to the internet at the clients’ offices and show the presentation in their PCs via their browser (and/or by hooking to a projector) while logged into with all the visual beauty and impact of application.