Blog Post

For the iPhone in China, Freedom Is the Great Wall

Stay on Top of Enterprise Technology Trends

Get updates impacting your industry from our GigaOm Research Community
Join the Community!

Now that the iPhone is officially on sale in China — a huge market that few once thought it would be allowed to enter — the focus has turned to its high price, and whether that will hinder its prospects in the region. China Unicom began selling the phone today; a 32GB iPhone 3GS goes for 6,999 yuan ($1,024) without a service contract, according to the Wall Street Journal. “Add in the cost of a service contract, and over two years a Chinese subscriber will pay around $3,000, approximately the yearly average salary,” notes TheAppleBlog.

It goes on to note, however, how Apple has proven many times over that people who can pay more for a superior product will do so. Indeed, price isn’t necessarily going to hinder the iPhone’s success in China so much as issues pertaining to freedom, functionality and a Chinese predilection for open source platforms.

As TheAppleBlog reports:

More than 100 million Chinese use their mobile phones to access the Internet. Considering the iPhone’s superior web browsing experience, it’s easy to imagine millions of iPhones sold in China. In fact, it’s already happened. The gray market of around 2 million iPhones is possibly the biggest competitor to the official model. All of those imported units have Wi-Fi, too, unlike the iPhones currently being sold by China Unicom due to government restrictions. However, the ban on Wi-Fi has been lifted, so future iPhones in China will have Wi-Fi.

China Unicom and Apple have a non-exclusive three-year agreement to sell iPhones in China, and OStatic previously reported on how the Chinese government was favoring limitations on Wi-Fi. Lack of Wi-Fi in first-generation Chinese iPhones is a significant limitation. More importantly, China Unicom is doing its own application platform, which will no doubt be heavily promoted for Chinese users and lag far behind Apple’s App Store.

As has always been true — from the birth of the personal computer to the success of the iPhone — great applications help ensure the success of hardware technologies. In the U.S. market and elsewhere, great applications are driving the iPhone’s rapidly increasing adoption. For censorship reasons, and many others, the Chinese government is unlikely over time to be as open as other governments are to a free-flowing, homegrown iPhone application ecosystem.

In the best analysis that I’ve seen on how the Chinese government may hinder the success of the iPhone through closed attitudes, standards guru Andy Updegrove recently noted that an open source platform such as Android may have the brightest prospects:

“A smartphone based on an open source platform clearly offers more opportunities for creativity, extension and (in China) hacking to get around government-imposed technical requirements…in China, it will be interesting to see whether savvy users opt for a platform that gives them the most freedom, or one where what they can buy is controlled by a government that places the highest priority on maintaining a ‘harmonious society’…”

Indeed, freedom, or lack of it — more than price — will help determine the iPhone’s prospects in China.

8 Responses to “For the iPhone in China, Freedom Is the Great Wall”

  1. Given Sebastian’s non-sensical explanation, it’s clear he’s not familiar at all with how the iPhone works nor does he seem to have any personal experience with the App Store.

    We’re still waiting for you to explain how China Unicom is going to push their own app store in place of Apple’s App Store for iPhone user, Sebastian, especially since Chinese users have been using the App Store day in and day out, whether on unlocked grey market iPhones or iPod touches.

  2. timjones17

    seems like how it may go is that, aside from Apple having to approve apps, then the Chinese government may have to approve it too? Another reason why open source platform such as Android may have the brightest prospects? China iPhone=Fail

  3. Umm, ok – care to explain how Chinese iPhone users will download Unicom apps onto their phones? It’s not like you can go to a website and click “Download” and an app magically installs itself.

    Sure, there are less apps on Apple’s China App Store but you still go through the App Store (which Chinese iPod touch users have been doing for a long time now.)

    So enlighten us – this Unicom app store – how does an iPhone user downloads apps from it without going though Apple’s store?

  4. @Lava — Chinese users won’t just be limited to China Unicom’s App Store, but it’s probable that it will be heavily emphasized for them, and probable over time that Chinese users won’t have the same freedom to use all apps as people do in other countries. China Unicom has heavily trumpeted its app store.


  5. China Unicom is doing its own application platform? And somehow Chinese users will be limited to that?

    WTF? Did you guys even try loading up iTunes and switching countries on the store home page? Like to China?

    OMG! China has an App Store where Chinese iPhone and iPod touch users can already buy apps!!