Blog Post

Thin Plastic Netbooks Show Design Flaws

An analyst tells CNET that some new, thin notebooks are showing cracks in the base due to the construction with plastic. OEMs are being advised that thin notebooks and netbooks should be made entirely out of metal cases to avoid these design flaws that are being seen.

This is not surprising, as thin notebooks are pushing the envelope as far as sturdiness is concerned, and with netbook makers trying to keep costs as low as possible, thin plastic is being used for many cases. There is a reason that Apple (s AAPL) and others are using metal for thin notebook construction.

“Early production units being built in plastic, with the bottom case being plastic, are cracking,” said Broadpoint AmTech analyst Doug Freedman, in a phone interview, referring to discussions he had with original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) and and original design manufacturers (ODMs). Typically ODMs don’t market under their brand name but supply devices to OEMs, which then slap on their own brand.

Metal cases drive the cost of notebooks up over plastic, and this may make it difficult for a thin netbook to be price competitive. In other words, cheap notebooks make for cheap quality.

(via Liliputing)

5 Responses to “Thin Plastic Netbooks Show Design Flaws”

  1. Uh…. The white macbooks and iphones have the same problem and they aren’t cheap. I had my iphone replaced under warranty 3 times because it always cracked in the same spot.

  2. AndyT

    I noticed some manufactures are making their thin and light notebooks using carbon fiber (the same stuff used in airplanes, bicycle frames, etc).

  3. I think this has a lot more to do with using cheap plastic than anything else. Plastic, like any other material, has its high and low ends.

  4. HuntForPaper

    thin plastic laptops or thin gauge plastic used in laptops? metal based are heavier, hotter, interfere with reception.

    what are people doing to actually CRACK the base of their laptops? ive owned as many laptops & used them in more ways than just about anyone & thats never happened.