Blog Post

Wrong-Headed Newspaper Biz Tries Again To Charge For Links

Stay on Top of Enterprise Technology Trends

Get updates impacting your industry from our GigaOm Research Community
Join the Community!

You’d think the newspaper industry would be doing all it could to encourage links to its websites. But now it’s launching the latest attempt to tell people what they can do with hyperlinks to its stories.

The Newspaper Licensing Agency (NLA), which charges news monitoring and PR companies to reproduce printed articles from 1,400 member newspapers, says it will from September extend its licenses to cover web links. Uh-oh

There will be no regulation of free aggregators like Google (NSDQ: GOOG) News, but we say the distinction is meaningless – a public URL is a public URL. NLA may be justified in continuing to charge for reproducing copyrighted printed content – but a URL isn’t content, it’s a resource locator. As my colleague Patrick tells me, this is “applying 19th century laws to 21st century media”.

NLA is trying to hold on to the revenue it could charge on newspapers’ behalf in a time when the tangibility of content was the chargeable asset. It’s sad that newspapers might lose this revenue but, on the web as set up by Tim Berners-Lee, online media monitoring services are quite justified in freely gathering links to freely available pages.

NLA prices range from £15 to £150 a month. The organisation claims over 150,000 customers and was formed by Associated Newspapers, Financial Times, Guardian Media Group, Independent News & Media, Northern and Shell, News International, Daily Telegraph and Trinity Mirror (LSE: TNI), but News Int and FT are opting out of the new scheme (the latter operates its own semantic news aggregator).

One Response to “Wrong-Headed Newspaper Biz Tries Again To Charge For Links”

  1. Newspaper Licensing Agency

    The new NLA licence is to cover copying of newspaper content by paid-for ‘web scraping’ services. These typically copy the entire text of all stories on a newspaper website to a local computer index, searching the database created for relevant articles for clients – this is not permitted under the website terms and conditions.

    The NLA and publishers support linking in general – for example, material from free consumer services and use of links by bloggers and others will not be affected by the new NLA licences.

    Our view is that there is a clear and obvious distinction between advertising-supported consumer services which generate significant value in traffic for publishers, and paid-for services, which are used professionally by small numbers of users.

    Also, you are not linking to the right price list for licenses. This is available at: http://www.nla.co.uk/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=40&Itemid=68