Blog Post

Downturn Pins Coskata's Commercial Plant on Government Aid

For young companies toiling over how to convert plant waste and non-food crops into ethanol — the next generation of biofuels — the effects of the downturn are starting to play a familiar beat: access to capital is so limited that companies that could have snagged funds in better economic times are seeing their commercialization plans crippled. The latest is Coskata, one of the better known cellulosic ethanol makers, backed by car maker GM (s GM) and venture capitalist Vinod Khosla. At the Wall Street Journal Eco:nomics conference this week, Coskata CEO Bill Roe said the company is now waiting for a loan guarantee from the Department of Energy to build its first commercial scale plant and that the plant is basically stalled until then.


Coskata was previously hoping to break ground on the plant — expected to produce 50-100 million gallons of ethanol annually — this year and to complete the factory in late 2010 or early 2011. Coskata Chief Marketing Officer Wes Bolsen told us back in December that the commercial plant time line would probably run more solidly into 2011. When we asked Bolsen yesterday if there was a new time line for the commercial plant, he told us:

“We are highly encouraged by what Secretary Steven Chu and the Department of Energy are saying about how fast they can issue the loan guarantees. The Coskata technology is ready to deploy, but we are hesitant to put any revised timeline out there until we see the closing of the financing.”

Chu said last month that new loan guarantees will be offered under the stimulus legislation by early summer, and at least 70 percent of its share of the stimulus will be disbursed by the end of 2010. Bolsen further explained Roe’s comments and the effect of the downturn on the company’s ability to raise financing: “In this financial environment, banks are not lending to themselves, let alone renewable energy projects.”

If Coskata is having trouble, smaller less-well-connected firms will be struggling even more. Coskata told us last November that it was able to close a Series C round in financing, and the company is backed with at least $30 million from Globespan Capital Partners, GM, Khosla Ventures, GreatPoint Ventures and Advanced Technology Ventures.

Other cellulosic ethanol makers like Verenium (s VRNM), that has a similarly strong partner in oil giant BP (s BP), are feeling the effects of the downturn on commercial plant plans, too. Verenium is moving forward with its first commercial plant, but has pushed back breaking ground to 2010 from a previously planned timeline of 2009.

16 Responses to “Downturn Pins Coskata's Commercial Plant on Government Aid”

  1. QDS Inc.

    Presents Extraordinary Patented Technology
    Highest Efficiency, Inexpensive & Most Importantly;

    Clean, Metal Free CO2 Sources for ALGAE – BIOFUELS.

    To Algae & BioFuel Producers:

    We are QD Sciences, Inc. located in TX, FL and NC USA. We have developed this enterprise currently we are focusing on commercializing our technology worldwide. We have a PCT PATENT; additionally we have 12 giant technologies that are pending in the clean energy field.

    For ALGAE & BIOFUELS we can supply the only CLEAN CO2 Source.

    Primarily ODS technology is supplying 100% completely clean, metal free CO2.


    QDS technology can remove all the toxins from stack and separate and clean CO2 from Coal, oil, gas, and waste fired power plants, cement manufactures etc.

    We have successfully finalized a low cost, high efficiency: AIR POLLUTION CONTROL TECHNOLOGY. This technology is for any capacity and can be applicable to any kind of pollutant industry.

    A minimum of 98% efficiency has been obtained through this single process to capture and hold such pollutant chemical compounds as: COx, SOx, NOx, nitrous oxide (N20), haloflurocarbons, CH4, HO (hydroxide), H2S, Aldehit (H-CHO), Mercury (Hg), Hydrogen Florid (HF), Trifluoromethane (HFC-23), phosphor (P), lead, SnO2 micro crystals, (Cl2), Vinyl Chloride (C2H3Cl) volatile organic compounds (VOC), sulphur hexafluoride (SF6), particulate matter, odor, etc. as well as separate and contain clean metal free CO2.

    The cost of removing these toxins is less than $5 for each ton of coal or any other fuel.

    New remarkable techniques are now able to convert these toxins into fertilizers to be safely degraded into the environment.

    98% removal efficiency to meet the new coming regulations and stay within permitted limits.

    QDS technology CO2 removal allows 90% of clean CO2 recovery from the QX used liquid to provide for ALGAE farmers other commercial uses.

    Installation is possible without interrupting production.

    QDS has developed technology to remove flying ash, particular matters and metals at 100% efficiency and operation cost is maximum $1 / ton fuel.


    Primarily ODS technology is supplying 100% clean CO2 for ALGAE-BIOFUELS producers.

    • Coal, oil, gas, and waste fired power plants,
    • Industrial chemical plants,
    • Oil refineries,
    Removing H2S from Natural gas, Syngas,
    • Aluminum, Copper producers, Cement manufacturers, Steel or Paper mills, etc.
    • Plastic, Rubber or similar polluting industries
    • Transatlantic vessel exhaust, Train and Automobile Exhaust,
    • Incineration and medical organic waste fired plants,
    • Kitchen chimneys, Odor creating industries, etc.

    The QDS technology promises to; capture and transfer the CO2 into green houses or any other CO2 end users and ALGAE TO ETHANOL producers, the fuel of the new century is Ethanol obtained from ALGAE, and ALGAE desperately needs CO2 to grow faster and obtain extremely higher yields.

    We are removing more than 98% efficiently without exception all the toxins from any kind of pollutant industries.
    Optionally: We are able to separate and take back CO2 to use in other areas of industry.
    Optionally: We are able to keep CO2 in store to keep our planet safe.
    Optionally: We are able to turn waste to fertilizer.
    Optionally: We can supply CO2 for algae farm use or we can contain it in safety.

    Comprehensive FLUE GAS tests, certified by the Environmental Protection Agency of the United States of America were conducted on four different occasions. The resulting reports are available for viewing.

    We have International Patent,
    We have 4 separate EPA/USA reports,
    We are ready to build plant of any capacity and at any place at the world.

    Rhonda Carey
    V. President
    QDS, Inc. Science council
    Phone: 1-407-797-2622 / 719 271 7787

  2. LittleWally

    1) can someone please stop Brian Donovan’s spam for Renergie.
    2) Katie, the real reason Coskata can’t get financing for commercial scale is that it has not proved the concept with its pilot scale plant. How do you expect any investor to put money towards a $300 mil project without at least having one year’s worth of data from a pilot scale plant that shows the concept works!! You bloggers are missing big stories here – all the BS the vendors are spreading around. Ask some critical questions once in a while. Biofuels have great potential, especially non-ethanol fuels, but you can’t hurry these technologies – complex science and engineering (and feedstock development) takes time.

  3. Brian J. Donovan

    Louisiana will create jobs by growing ethanol demand, specifically hydrous ethanol demand, beyond the 10% blend market.

    Governor Bobby Jindal has signed into law the Advanced Biofuel Industry Development Initiative, Act 382, the most comprehensive and far-reaching state legislation in the nation enacted to develop a statewide advanced biofuel industry. The legislature found that the proper development of an advanced biofuel industry in Louisiana requires implementation of the comprehensive “field-to-pump” strategy:

    (1) Feedstock other than corn;
    (2) Decentralized network of small advanced biofuel manufacturing facilities;
    (3) Variable blending pumps, in lieu of splash blending, will offer the consumer E10, E20, E30 and E85; and
    (4) Hydrous ethanol.

    “Field-to-Pump” is a unique strategy created by Renergie, Inc. (“Renergie”) to locally produce and market advanced biofuel (“non-corn fuel ethanol”) via a network of small advanced biofuel manufacturing facilities. The purpose of “field-to-pump” is to maximize rural development and job creation while minimizing feedstock supply risk and the burden on local water supplies.