New TiVo HD XL: Big Drive, Big Price


TiVo today announced the availability of its HD XL DVR as the company targets high-end users and people who watch a lot of television. The TiVo HD XL sports a 1 terabyte hard drive capable of recording 150 hours of HD TV and comes with a hefty price tag to match — $599.99. While it’s got impressive specs, this top-shelf play probably won’t bring a full turnabout for TiVo, which is still losing subscribers.

With its augmented HD drive and THX certification, TiVo is trying to prove itself as a high-end device that complements even the most extravagant home theater. But that beefy hard drive isn’t just going after those with bling, it’s hoping to up-sell current family TiVo owners who are scared their current skimpy hard drives will fill up on them halfway through the new season of Grey’s Anatomy.

The bigger hard drive is a nice feature, but that sticker price is sure to induce shock, especially when a cable or satellite service will rent you a DVR for cheap. Sure, it eliminates the need to worry about how much space is available, and that has value (especially when the new fall season is upon us) — but six hundred bucks? Why can’t the powers that be just create a network DVR already?


michael lawrence

FYI…..$600 for a 1T hddvr is a joke! As a new Dish
subscriber you can request a 722 hddvr with a
500GB hard drive that can record THREE streams at
the same time, and is by far the highest rated HDDVR
for functionality by every review I have ever read for the grand cost of $0!! Thats right, NO hardware cost!
Activate the external hard drive function for $40 and
buy a 500GB hard drive for $110 (costco) and you’re
total cost for 1Terabyte is $150…factor in Dish’s
current offerings of over 100 HD channels, 1080p VOD on certain movies and the incredibly fast function
response time and its a no brainer if you’re looking for
a new HD provider.

Dave Zatz

$600 is a lot but they’re targeting custom installers and Magnolia. It basically uses the same TiVo HD hardware, so the cost to get this out the door is low. As long as they keep production under control, this will be a high margin item for TiVo.

What they really need to do is get the TiVo HD down to 199. Given this early launch, I could see both units dropping by a hundred (rebate, maybe?) in mid or early November for holiday sales.

Davis Freeberg

Given that Comcast is capping their bandwidth at 250 GBs, I don’t think we’ll ever see a 1 TB HD networked DVR. After I got my series 3 (which was more expensive then the XL), I upgraded the hard drive and it’s made all the difference in the world. Last season, I was able to record the entire season of Desperate Housewives in HD without ever having to worry about running out of space. Over the summer I had enough saved up that I was able to watch first run shows when repeats were the only thing showing. It was really nice. When I had a cable DVR, there was no way to upgrade the hard drive even if you were willing to pay more and it seemed liked I could only go about a week without TV before I started losing shows. $600 is still a lot of money, but if you are going to spend the money on TiVo to begin with, it’s worth paying the extra to never have to worry about storage.

Comments are closed.