I’m so happy that you’ve covered this software product. I’ve been using MP3Tag for several years, and I’ve donated to Florian’s project on a few occasions. I use CDEx 1.71 in conjunction with LAME 3.97 beta 2 encoder DLLs to rip my music, and I then use MP3Tag and a whole slew of preconfigured scripts to tag and fill in metadata the way that I like it. The software can also fill in most blanks through predefined queries with ‘discogs.org’ and Amazon. the Discogs site is well-respected amongst music fans, particularly fans of much more obsure music and the requisite labels that puts out the music.

*Definitely* take a minute to look through the help file! What this package can do and still be offered for free is AMAZING!

Didn’t you also have iTunes? Wouldn’t iTunes do it?

If it only became logarithmically more difficult then that is good. Logs grow at roughly a rate INVERSE to time which means it grows less and less as time goes by. Exponentially would be awful seeing as how it grows at a rate equal to how big it already is! Logarithmic growth is really about the slowest type of growth you might hope for–except for perhaps log of a log growth, or log of a log of a log.. oh hell, you get my point. Cross the word off your list, but me thinks you didn’t really mean what you said.

However, nothing else I’ve seen when it comes to tagging has come close to Tag&Rename from softpointer.com – it is incredibly slick, fetches data from Amazon and other sources and can rename and reorganize stuff exceedingly well.

IMHO the standard by which to judge MP3 Tag editors, so far nothing else has beaten it as far as I have seen – but this one seems very interesting, thanks for the tip.