Why I Need the Tablet
It’s a bad idea to ask a geek if they “need” some new gadget. Invariably, the answer will be an emphatic “yes!,” followed by all manner of perfectly reasonable explanations as to why. I’m guilty of this behavior. Every self-respecting tech-enthusiast is guilty of it, too. Predictably, I need a Mac tablet. Let me tell you why.
This past week I spent almost all my days in my bed, moaning softly to the four walls and complaining that life is unfair. Yep, I was sick. I had a nasty allergic reaction to something (we apparently will never know what) and my skin everywhere became inflamed and painfully sensitive. My feet were so swollen I couldn’t walk, and my fingers so sore and stiff I couldn’t even flip the lid on my MacBook Pro.
After a few days of treatment, the condition stabilized enough for me to (finally!) hold my iPhone. So I was able to process a little email and do some simple RSS reading. The iPhone was the (almost) perfect instrument for me since it’s light and thin and doesn’t have a fiddly hardware keyboard. For someone with almost-useless hands (as mine were at the time), that’s an accessibility boon!
Even when the swelling had subsided enough that dexterity returned, I still wasn’t ready to use my laptop. I could barely sit up for very long, and anyway, when every part of your skin is screaming at you whenever it gets touched, you really don’t relish the thought of snuggling-up to a toasty-warm MacBook.
With that in mind, the iPhone might seem like an obvious alternative, but it really wasn’t. You see, the iPhone screen is fine for when you’re tweeting or quickly checking mail, but it’s completely inappropriate for lengthy, detailed tasks such as word processing, document editing or web-based research.
Since I couldn’t do much serious computing, I decided to catch up on my reading. I used my trusty Sony eBook Reader PRS-505, a gorgeous little device that remains, at least here in Europe, a favorable alternative to the Kindle. It doesn’t have a web browser, or a Wi-Fi chip. It’s not backlit, doesn’t have a color screen nor a particularly impressive processor. But it’s great at what it does — electronic books. It requires only two buttons be used; Next or Previous Page. It couldn’t be simpler.
But the whole time I was using it, I felt I was missing something. A few things, in fact. Email, for a start. The ability to look-up words in a system-wide dictionary. A web browser, for those times when I wanted to do a little background research on the subject matter in my book.
But more than any of that, I felt I was missing something deeply fundamental that we take for granted on the iPhone; I wanted the screen to respond to my touch. I wanted to tap, swipe and pinch. Having to use those fiddly hardware buttons (only two of ‘em, remember!) was a distasteful necessity, sort of like Microsoft Office on the Mac.
It was (in a quite literal sense) painfully clear to me that I needed a tablet device. A ten inch touch screen, backlit, color, Wi-Fi enabled and… oh, you know the rest. I desperately wanted and needed the long-rumored iTablet.
I’m writing this on my MacBook Pro, on a train that is limping between London and Manchester. I’m gonna be spending the day traveling, but I don’t want to have to lose a day of work. That means needing to find a space to open my MacBook and get typing. That generally means only when I’m seated somewhere, and only if there is ample room to place the laptop securely before me so I can type.
But with a tablet, I could continue to work almost anywhere. In a queue, standing on a crowded train or even crammed into a tiny seat somewhere, I’d need no more than the space usually required to read a book. And I’d be able to work.
I’m not for one moment suggesting the fabled tablet will provide me with a replacement for my MacBook Pro. I think it’s safe to say that, for most writers, nothing can replace the convenience and comfort of a traditional keyboard. Frankly, I shudder at the thought of having to author something significantly lengthy using a touch screen with virtual keyboard. But a few hundred words here or there? A tablet would be ideal for that. Typically, my emails are never more than a hundred or so words (usually far fewer in fact), and my iPhone is great for dipping in and out of email — but for all the convenience, the iPhone screen is still a little on the small side.
In many ways, the tablet could be the spiritual successor to the venerable Newton. Reminiscent of Star Trek’s PADDs, a gadget that works as a personal digital assistant and entertainment center. For all the talk we’ve heard in the last few years about the tablet being Apple’s answer to netbooks, this device would be in a league of its own, creating an entirely new family of portable computers.
I’m getting carried away with myself. I must try to remember the pain of Early Adopter Syndrome. We rush out to buy Generation One and then suffer horribly when we realize the battery life is less than stellar, or worse, the software platform proves terribly limiting (anyone remember Web Apps?).
Still, I’m a Geek. I’ve already thoroughly convinced myself I need the tablet. I don’t know what it will do yet, but I know I need it. I’ve just spent minutes of your reading time explaining why it is so useful and necessary, in the process maybe enforcing your own Geeky justifications for laying out the green when the Great Launch Day is upon us.
Do you have a better reason why you really, absolutely need the tablet? Share your Geekscuse in the comments, or hit me up on twitter and call me a pathetic Fanboi.
Related research and analysis from GigaOM Pro:
Subscriber content. Sign up for a free trial.
A 10-inch tablet would be perfect for me to access training materials and other documents at work, but they would NEVER buy me one, and would NEVER allow me to use my own on their network.
As a developer I need Apple to make a tablet (and have it be successful) so I have another red-hot platform to target consumers on. ;)
No but seriously, it all comes down to the implementation. I could see a tablet as being an almost essential element in the “Apple Gadget Stack” or something that could be passed over in favor of a Kindle or other e-reader. It really just depends on how far they push the envelope. Personally, I certainly hope they do give it a shot and I hope even more they knock it out of the park.
I’m with you on this one, for all the reasons you describe – I’d like a good colour reader, not all books are in just “black & white” I’d also want full OS X functionality – I guess the big issue will be battery life – small and portable but not with the battery in a back pack!
Tablet computers are interesting, but I don’t see one being very useful to me. I was sitting next to someone on a flight to Houston who was using a tablet PC to write out some notes. I was intrigued by how this man was writing so easily and naturally. It almost made me want a tablet. Then, I remembered how awful my handwriting is. I’ll stick with a keyboard :) The only thing that makes me hope Apple finally releases a tablet Mac soon is really to shut everyone up who has been whining for one for years. I really don’t see many tablet PCs, so that must mean that the market has pretty much rejected them. Of course, Apple may release one that has a “killer feature” that makes the use of a tablet computer more enticing. I guess we’ll see.
Under 1 Pound.
Yikes!
Get outta my way.
It seems odds on that Apple will release a tablet.
They wouldn’t contemplate releasing a ‘netbook’ and risk diluting their current product range; they’ll take the tablet concept and turn it on its head and astonish us all with their design genius (and in the process drain another load of money from my bank account).
I am with you all the way. The only thing I would add is that we need something else that pushes the envelope on this mobile broadband phenomenon.
If the tablet is as you described, I won’t be carrying my laptop any more. The keyboards can stay in the office or at home. I will just take the tablet and my iphone with me wherever I go. The two will suffice for most of my needs while I am not home or at work. The keyboards will still be used for extensive typing.
so you’re saying that you need a tablet because you’re too ill to be able to use a laptop, or because you’re too much of a work-a-holic to stop working while standing in line.
yes, you’re absolutely right, I think you’ve identified the target market that Apple is aiming for.
or, you’re completely wrong, and are struggling to justify why you need their next device.
which one is it?
I totally think there is a use for a 1-2 lb, “on the go” device. There’s plenty of times I need something larger than my iPhone but smaller than a Macbook when I’m out and about.
Ebook reading
On-the-go movie watching
Email
Secondary screen
Self-refreshing wall-mounting portrait
Basic Gaming
Showing-off
TTC – Total Toilet Compatibility
For all of the above…. OH YES PLEASE !
What I think a lot of people don’t get is that Apple saying they wouldn’t release a low cost, bare bones netbook is not the same as concluding that there isn’t a large market positioned between the tiny, pocket sized iPod Touch and a full fledged MacBook.
Envision a bookish sized device that offers a superior input, viewing and playback environment for accessing your iTunes library, personal media, syndicated content services, eBooks, iPhone Apps and potentially, Mac Apps.
Give it a decent video camera so it can run video conferencing and VOIP apps (Skype already has a client for the iPhone/iPod touch).
And position it as the must-have device for the cafe, living room and classroom for the Mobile Broadband Generation, pricing it slightly less than a low-end MacBook.
Does this sound more of less compelling than an el cheapo netbook? Does it capture a segment who might otherwise not buy a MacBook, or who in the $600-800 range might add another computing device to the household (my kids are CLAMORING for this type of device).
Btw, if interested, here is the expanded analysis of the forthcoming Apple iPad Tablet device.
Apple, the ‘Boomer’ Tablet and the Matrix
http://bit.ly/DwziS
Cheers,
Mark
Because the MacBook is too heavy.
Because the MacBook is too large.
Even the MacBook Air is too heavy and too large.
Just make a smaller MacBook or a tablet with these specs:
400 g or less.
Pocketable if possible.
Video-out.
USB.
That is the ultimate Keynote and PowerPoint presentation tool.
I like your reasoning.
As much as a tablet would be a great toy for me, it wouldn’t get much practical use. My MacBook and my iPhone totally satisfy my needs, as a fourteen year old that is yet to complete high school. The only thing that it would really aid me in doing, is completing my homework on the bus after failing to complete it the night before ;)
If I had the money to spend, chances are: I would buy one – in fact, chances are that I would buy one of everything in Apple’s lineup – but now, at this stage in my life, I can’t see it having great benefits for me. When I get to college? Perhaps, but to be honest, I really love my MacBook, and would rather take that around. Do any other students plan on purchasing one?
Anyway, regardless of my lack of plans to buy a tablet, I know how useful they will be to a great deal of working individuals, and I can’t wait to see what Apple comes up with.
I don’t know if I “need” a tablet, but it could be a contender for a pretty durable note taking tool.
For a math or a physics class, you could directly write your notes on the tablet with a stylus. For other classes, you could take notes via an external keyboard if Apple provided a way to prop the tablet up to use as a screen / monitor. I wouldn’t have to carry anymore spiral notebooks around – which would be fabulous considering how big they are (usually full by the end of a semester). Besides, keeping everything organized on a computer is way better than having my notes stuffed in boxes in the attic over the summer.
I suffer with you !!!
Oh how much I suffer …
Although a lot of people think that the rumored iTablet is a viable ebook reading device, it isn’t for me. I will need an e-ink screen to avoid eye-strain.
Why I do need an Apple Tablet is to take notes. Right now if I take notes on a MBP, I can’t add diagrams to it. I can’t add a hand drawn graph to it. I can’t make hand-written annotations on a document. And it’s too bulky to open up on those tiny desk-chair thingys.
If I had Apple’s tablet I could type out notes on a virtual keyboard, draw a diagram underneath, add a graph to the side. I can even see this replacing my Ti-89, if I could do all my calculations right where I’m righting.
Even more awesome would be capability similar to the Livescribe Pulse pens. It records everything in a lecture as you write, and when you tap on a word, you can hear what was being said at that point. How cool would that be?
So, yes I need Apple’s tablet.
I have been using a tablet for 2 years now. I even have single touch capability, with my Toshiba M700. Frankly its the only thing that keeps the mac folks quiet around me. I use it as a digital notebook and with USB and FW is great as a VOIP/ conferencing tool inside the enterprise. A Mac tablet would finally get my interest.
While the situations that you describe would make a tablet neat, the reality that is that for all of the rest of your day, it would not be enough. When you arrive at your destination, your natural desire or need for the missing capabilities would require that you also have your laptop. Thus, now you are carrying around 2 devices. Not a very good answer.
I have the best of both worlds… I write, several hundred words at a time, using ShapeWriter on my iPod touch.
In the latest incarnation of iPhone, it’s possible to cut ‘n’ paste from it directly into any other program, so I’m quite the happy camper.
Not nearly the learning curve one would think, and almost the speed!
Anything which can make my multi-media bag lighter would be welcome – a tablet to check photos, videos and audio in the field before returning to the office? Beats the 3-inch screen on the camera…
Unit needs USB, decent capacity (128GB), Bluetooth (for mouse/keyboard), WiFI, Phone tethering, all-day battery, SD card slot. HDMI out would be good – display stored media on any big TV.
I went through four years of college never taking anything more with me to class than my Newton Message Pad. I’d take my notes in my own handwriting, take it home, convert it to text, sync the notes to my Mac, and file them by class. It was genius.
The journalists who sabotaged the product’s success are not called scribblers without reason. The handwriting recognition worked beautifully.
I had to give up on the Newton after moving to Mac OS X, since there ceased to be a way to easily sync it, but I still miss it. Sometime desperately.
If Apple comes out with a Newton OS X, provided it has a way for me to write and convert my own own handwriting (non of this silly virtual keyboarding silliness), I’ll be waiting at the store on day 1.