1 Comment

Summary:

Patent reform failed in 2011, in part because not enough people understood the patent troll problem. A new video that provides a crisp cartoon summary could help change that.

troll

In 2011, Congress tried — and failed — to fix America’s broken patent system with the America Invents Act. Now, reform advocates like Rep. Bob Goodlatte (R-Va.) are trying again with a bigger coalition of supporters, and some novel methods to educate the public about the problem.

This includes a clever YouTube video posted by the House Judiciary Committee, which Goodlatte chairs, that explains how patent trolls engage in “legalized extortion” and make everyday products more expensive for everyone:

The video astutely notes that patent trolls (like the one using a Holocaust foundation’s 1998 patent to sue the New York Times) have been a problem almost as long as the patent system, and how one ambitious troll almost stopped Henry Ford from making the Model-T. It concludes by asking for support for the bipartisan Innovation Act.

It’s a creative effort but, unfortunately, it may be too late. Microsoft and IBM, which make significant revenue from patent licenses, have already gutted the most important provision from the proposed law, one that would have made it easier to challenge garbage patents in the first place.

People close to the process, however, say that real reform still stands a chance in the Senate where influential figures like Sen. Chuck Schumer, Sen. Patrick Leahy and Sen. John Corryn have all taken stands against abuse of the patent system.

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. James Goldman Monday, December 2, 2013

    I applaud the congressperson for attempting to reform a fatally broken system and for attempting to widen the coalition using approachable and engaging media. The problem is that this cartoon barely explains what a patent troll is. “What if Henry Ford had lost the law suite?” He didn’t lose the law suite. The patent system worked. Are there no examples of a patent trolls actually hurting the innovation process? Why are patent trolls a new problem worthy of legislation?

    I’m not saying I need a book, but “Patent trolls are bad” isn’t enough to get a consumer/voter to take action.

Comments have been disabled for this post