8 Comments

Summary:

There’s currently a trio of main wireless charging groups, each with its own standardized solution, and now Qualcomm is a member of all three. Here’s why this gives hope for a single standard.

Image 1 for post WildCharge: wireless charging at the same speed of wired( 2008-02-11 15:12:34)

Qualcomm joined the Power Matters Alliance (PMA) on Tuesday, which the PMA is touting as a big win. And it is, considering that Qualcomm is one of the top chip-makers used in mobile devices. Interestingly though, this is the third wireless power group Qualcomm has joined of late. In fact, it’s now a member of all three of the top groups, each of which has its own idea of the best wireless charging standard: the PMA, the Wireless Power Consortium (WPC) and the Alliance for Wireless Power (A4WP).

So what gives? Why would Qualcomm decide to back all three horses in this race? It’s not just to cash in on a Win, Place or Show ticket; I figure Qualcomm is looking for something that’s sorely needed in the wireless charging industry: A single standard.

I reached out to Qualcomm and received this statement, which verifies my initial thought:

“Qualcomm, a founding member of the Alliance for Wireless Power (A4WP), has joined the WPC and PMA. Qualcomm remains a board member and driver of the A4WP. Qualcomm remains committed to the industries transition to a resonant based wireless power technology. By joining these organizations, Qualcomm aims to provide an opportunity to standardize around a single global implementation if all parties can agree on the way forward. The Company believes that A4WP represents the most mature and best implementation of resonant charging. We are bringing this time to market advantage to the PMA and WPC for their consideration.”

Qualcomm obviously thinks its own solution — that of the A4WP — is better than the Qi standard and other implementations, However, instead of trying to push it alone, it figures it can bring the technology to the other groups.

A bit heavy-handed? Perhaps, but at this rate, individual groups don’t seem to be working together for the consumer’s benefit; instead, the approaches have all been to disparage technology from rival groups.

Although I use a Qi wireless charger today, it does have limitations that Qualcomm’s solution avoid. I can only charge one device per “spot” on a pad and my device must be placed directly on that spot. The A4WP has already demonstrated more spatial freedom and multiple device charging on a single pad. Here’s a quick look at the technology:

  1. Honestly, this is a solution looking for a problem from my point of view.

    If I have to take my device to a specific location and orient it a specific way, then I might as well drop it in a dock or plug up a cable.

    The extra amount of effort compared the complexity and cost of these solutions is extremely small.

    Share
    1. “If I have to take my device to a specific location and orient it a specific way, then I might as well drop it in a dock or plug up a cable.”

      Agreed, but check the A4WP video: its solution allows for multiple devices to be charged regardless of how they’re oriented.

      As far as a specific location, I actually charge my devices in specific locations over USB wires: nightstand and desk mainly. Why not be able to just drop them there without plugging/unplugging cords?

      I’m not saying this is game changing tech, but after I tried a wireless charger, I really came to appreciate it.

      Share
      1. I want to like wireless charging; Qi makes it very, very hard to do that.

        I’d be curious about something an order of magnitude better, but having had a dual iPhone dock for the past couple of years that “just worked”, it’s hard to get excited about any wireless charging solution that isn’t much better.

        Share
  2. All of these technologie are ok, but have you checked out WiTricity at all? Their technology promises a much better solution…

    Share
    1. WiTricity is a member of the PMA.

      Share
      1. Yes, but there technology has yet to be integrated into the “Power 2.0″ PMA standard. It’s quite interesting stuff, wireless charging over distance to power everything from light bulbs to smartphones.

        Share
  3. I meant “their” technology not “there”, I really should proof read before I submit…

    Share
  4. In the world of IT, many activities are evolving from a product to a utility service stage of evolution. We call this ‘Cloud’.It wasn’t the innovation of wireless that changed the world, but the provision of utility services that enabled the mobile industry. Today Qualcomm and the PMA joining forces on doing to same to Wireless.
    PMA ia the pioneer in that space

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post