7 Comments

Summary:

Beleagured Chinese solar giant, Suntech Power, was once the largest solar maker in the world. This week the company was forced into bankruptcy. But it’s not all bad news.

Suntech install

Once the world’s largest solar panel maker, Suntech Power, has finally been forced into bankruptcy. The company has been running out of cash for months, defaulted on a loan payment recently, and has now become the biggest casualty yet of the coming consolidation of the global solar industry.

This week eight Chinese banks asked a court to find Suntech subsidiary Wuxi Suntech insolvent and to allow it to begin restructuring. Suntech responded to the court and said it would not object. The New York Times reported that the bankruptcy is “expected to lead to a takeover of the Wuxi operations by Wuxi Guolian, a financial conglomerate controlled by the city government of Wuxi.”

The solar market has seen an oversupply of solar panels and plummeting prices for those panels for over two years now. Two thirds of solar cells are made in China, where the Chinese government has given Chinese solar makers access to large low cost loans. The oversupply and drop in prices has led to huge solar manufacturers like Q-Cells to startups like Solyndra and Abound Solar to file for bankruptcy.

It's an American right to have solar

Suntech solar panels

Suntech may be the largest to date, but it won’t be the last solar maker to crash. As MIT Tech Review put it earlier this week: “hundreds of solar companies need to fail to help bring the supply of solar panels back in line with demand.”

The weeding-out process will help slow the fall in solar panel prices and allow demand to rise back up again. Down the road the re-balancing will enable these companies to continue to invest in more efficient cells and new innovations, which will bring down the cost of solar through technology even more. Another 180 solar panel makers could reportedly disappear by 2015 due to consolidation.

At the same time, Suntech’s woes partly come from a financial scandal. The company got in trouble with a fund it controlled that financed solar power plant development in Europe.

Of course, it’s not all positive that Suntech has declared bankruptcy. As Ucilia Wang wrote for us last week:

The drama presents an ugly turn for a company that was solid and took technology and market risks to grow. . . Chinese companies in general had been known more as mass producers rather than innovators. . . Suntech’s decline also leaves a depressing note in the efforts by the federal and local governments to expand solar manufacturing in the U.S.

  1. It’s not a good thing for innovation either. No one’s going to want to invest in solar now, and it takes capital to make innovations.

    Share
    1. IMHO as solar continues to become a commodity, investors will be willing to invest in non-manufacturing innovation, like financing, services, marketing, installation, etc.

      Share
      1. Albert Hartman Wednesday, March 20, 2013

        Innovation theory (C.Christensen) says that when one part of the value stack commoditizes, profits move to the adjacent layers above and below. Look for opportunities there.

        Share
  2. Innovation will continue and many more will collapse. Once the market is ready to restore itself there will be new investors and all will be good. Mister Sunshine.

    Share
  3. Can you pl explain how this makes sense: “slow the fall in solar panel prices and allow demand to rise back up again.”

    I would have thought that as prices increase, demand for solar panels will decrease; basic economics, no?

    Its the Managers and Investors who want prices to increase so they can “profit” more; they are really not pro-consumer.

    (After much travels in rural india) the current lower demand tells me that prices are still too high. Drop prices further to the average cost of black-top roofing and demand should soar.

    Best
    Arun

    Share
  4. Solar Advocate Wednesday, March 20, 2013

    Please don’t make the mistake of applying normal business logic to a nationalized company, let alone one in China. ;-)

    The bad thing about this-short term-is prices will likely stabilize if not edge up a bit, slowing adoption. Looking longer out, the good thing is it will likely continue to drive funding and research in raising the efficiencies of thin film solar and graphene based solar.

    Share
  5. Utomo Prawiro Thursday, March 21, 2013

    Innovation is needed to increase the efficiency. If the efficiency increase and also battery price drop (not the panel price drop) it will make more bigger sales.

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post