92 Comments

Summary:

Android shopping traffic over the holiday lagged iOS even though there are more Android smartphones. We look at why Android still produces far less engagement than iOS and what might be contributing to the gap.

Android

Android has raced ahead of iOS in smartphone share but it continues to fall behind in usage and engagement in the U.S. The latest data from IBM  on Black Friday shopping traffic underscores just how much iOS outperforms Android. Asymco has some good charts that highlight the engagement gap.

IBM said that 77 percent of mobile traffic on Black Friday came from iOS devices. This despite the fact that Comscore said that Android has 52.5 percent of smartphone subscribers while iOS has 34.3 percent. Some of it comes down to the iPad, which is still the dominant tablet and produces the most traffic compared to iPhones and Android phones. But like the iPhone, the iPad exhibits outsized usage patterns beyond its actual marketshare. Gartner said in the third quarter, iPad shipments have dropped to 50.4 percent. But IBM said it contributed 88 percent of the tablet traffic over the long weekend.

Android engagement, Asymco

This is a pattern than has been in place over the last few years. But now that Android is now the top dog on smartphones marketshare-wise and is eating into the iPad’s lead thanks to the Kindle Fire, Nook and other Android tablets, why is iOS still so dominant?

Here are some theories we’ve gathered from around the web alongside our thoughts:

  • Horace Dediu of Asymco wondered if Android was attracting more late adopters, who were prone to do less with their phones than hardcore smartphone users. But he’s not convinced that’s the answer. Perhaps, it has more to do with “design considerations” or “user experience flaws or integration.”
  • One thought is that Android users are more apt to want things for free, so they’re not as likely to shop for things on their devices. We’ve seen a gap in how Android and iOS users are willing to pay for apps — Android users prefer free apps — but that difference is going down over time.
  • Some Android users are just graduating up from a feature phone and really don’t understand all they can do with their device. Considering the declining number of feature phone options, it’s possible that people are graduating to cheap Android devices, but just still talk and text on them, something Daring Fireball’s John Gruber mentioned before. 
  • Tim Windsor from Digitally Speaking goes a step further, saying that most iOS buyers are specifically buying their devices for the features they can access, while most Android users are just buying what’s available to them. Most, he believes, aren’t interested in serious computing power.
  • Jason Grisby of Cloud Four recently wrote that the gap doesn’t exist when looking at web traffic over cellular. It’s only when you examine iOS and Android traffic over Wi-Fi that a usage gap emerges. He believes that Android users might not be aware of the availability of Wi-Fi networks through their device or are in lower income brackets and have less access to Wi-Fi networks.
  • Some people believe there is no gap at the high end when looking top Android devices. The problem is with cheaper and older Android devices, which don’t provide as good an experience or are saddled with older versions of Android, which are worse at browsing. It is true there are more cheap Android phones options available, so that might contribute to some of the gap. And a majority of Android users are still on devices running Android 2.0x.
  • Apple users are more likely to use apps, which can provide a better user experience. Android users who turn to a browser may not find it as inviting or engaging.
  • It’s also possible that shopping data is not an accurate proxy for engagement. NetMarketShare earlier this year said, however, also came up with general browsing data that showed iOS devices have 65 percent of mobile traffic compared to 20 percent for Android.

To be clear, the data we’re looking at is from the U.S. only, and it’s based primarily on shopping traffic. My theory is that there are people who walk into a cellular store, see only a handful of feature phones available and a salesperson who is heavily pushing Android devices. If they want to walk out with a new phone, it’s likely going to be an Android unless they came in already looking for an iPhone. Those people may not be savvy now, but they will get more experienced over time. What are your theories on this Android paradox?

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. Jack E Mabry Jr Monday, November 26, 2012

    As an Android user, I kind of feel that people that choose iOS know up front that there is cool stuff to do and buy from their mobile device. It started for me that way when I bought my iPod Touch a few years ago. What happened is that I got bored of just icons on a screen, talked to some IT friends that I have and bought a phone with Android, the Motorola Photon and now the Galaxy S3. I still have 2 iPod Touches and an Apple TV because I have content there but I now own 2 Google TV’s, 2 Android tablets and the GS3. I have pretty much switched my content and app buying from Apple to Google.

  2. `It’s only when you examine iOS and Android traffic over Wi-Fi that a usage gap emerges. `

    This quote is very telling for me. As an avid Android user, i never chose my Android over my notebook, but my boss, an avid iOS user, sometimes prefer to type an email on iPad even when his MacBook pro is just in front of him (literally). I cannot understand why he does that. But i see a lot of iOS users doing the same. So anecdotally, my guess would be: Android users just stick with their PCs when at home (presumably when they have Wi-Fi), whereas iOS users prefer the small screen, for some reason.

    1. I have seen exactly the same and I too wonder why they do it. My friends surf on the tiny 3.5″ screen and I almost always prefer the PC. I have core i7 PCs at home and work with 27″ screens and I’d be insane to use my relatively small 4.8″ Galaxy S3. The only time I use the phone is when I’m truly mobile.

      On my Transformer Prime, I use the desktop mode most of the time. I wonder what user agent that sends. I’d be interested in seeing whether that contributes, but I think not. I don’t think most users will know how to do that.

      1. Sounds about the same with me.

        My Verizon Nexus works great when I’m out and about – I’m grandfathered into unlimited data, 10 days in my billing cycle, I’ve used 6 GB, lots of Netflix, Youtube. At work, it’s all Windows desktops. At home, I’m on my big-screen Windows desktop, more than on my Nexus. Also, my home wifi is slower than LTE, so I don’t bother turning on wifi on my Nexus.

        I do lots of online shopping on desktops, hardly on my Nexus; I prefer the desktop big -screen for shopping. The apps I use the most are Gmail, Google Maps, and stock Android browser. I mostly use mobile websites since they work fine with me and I find apps mostly buggy, generally useless, so I hardly buy apps.

    2. People just want to showoff that they have IFAD. Isn’t that Apple’s marketing strategy all about

    3. This is exactly my thought. Even with a Google Nexus 7, I find myself reaching for my Dell XT3 tablet PC when I want to do anything that requires more than a few quick gestures. Even shopping, I can view 20 items at a time instead of 4. I only use my phone or tablet when using the notebook is inconvenient.

  3. I can’t understand (I’m lying I know exactly why) one of the most obvious scenarios hasn’t been brought up by any of the major tech media. Google something like “what’s my user agent” on an Android device. When you get to the site if you aren’t already have your broswer request the desktop site. You don’t see any hint of Android in that UA string do you? That’s because the whole point is to hide that you are mobile so that you get the desktop site.

    Has anyone questioned how sites are determining when Android devices are hitting sites? Of course not. The iFans have started coming up with any ridiculous reason they can from poor user experience to price of handsets. Meanwhile in the real world I can hardly find anyone that actually wants to do anything complex on an iPhone and hardly see them in use in public anymore.

    1. I think you’re delusional if you think most Android users even know what “user agent” means, let alone cares what it means.

      1. I doubt this. I think more android users are PC junkies who refuse to go with the iOS because of how dumbed-down it is and were pushed away from Windows mobile by MS after they gave up on the enterprise and PC geeks to go after the same market apple markets to. I have my browser set to request the desktop sites and so do my wife and all three of my kids.

    2. I see no “iFans” coming up with these reasons, these are analysts.
      I do many complex things on my iOS devices. I live in the real world. Sorry to burst your bubble of imagination

    3. Many iOS browsers allow you to change the user agent string as well. Those aren’t being counted as iOS.

    4. it still shows that you are running on android.

  4. My theory is that iOS is just that much more fun and easy to use. People gravitate toward these types of devices, and thus far Android (while powerful and certainly feature rich) is no the experience people want.

    I saw this over the long weekend here in the US. People grabbed for the iPads and iPhones… the Kindles and Android devices sat on shelves or tables as last-used devices, some collecting dust all weekend while iOS devices were actually fought for by kids and adults alike.

    I also saw laptop computers sitting idle in the mornings while iPads were out in full force as people drank their coffee and shopped sales.

    Android sells for many of the reasons already listed. It still not that awe inspiring experience that Apple provides. Only the blind Android techno geeks dont’ see this… the rest just open their eyes and it is obvious.

    1. Or it could be that iOS users force themselves to use their over priced devises to justify the premium they paid to get them.

    2. Its all yuck for me on iOS. Its so stale and static and navigation using single physical button is cumbersome and uninspiring. As far as I have seen no IFAD and I phony owners has suggested a single concrete feature that makes their experience on iOS easy.

      1. Android users are mostly bullies

  5. Has anyone considered the impact of training resources on device usage? Apple offers setup services, free workshops, and in-depth one to one and group training through its retail stores, as well as further learning opportunities via phone (AppleCare) and Internet (apple.com).

    1. Apple Stores are only available in 15 countries around the world. iOS devices are being sold at hundreds of countries.

      1. All the stats reported in this post are USA only. Apple stores have the US covered twice over.

    2. And iOS is so easy to use there is no need for anyone to learn how to use it. Seriously, even a 5 year old kid can use it.

      1. Yup, to design that kind of ux need a lot of efforts. To copy and throw everything inside is very easy.

  6. It comes down to the controversial argument of iOS vs Android. And the statistics show who’s the obvious winner. We can safely assume, with the usage statistics, that a person with both an Android and iOS device will choose the iOS device for actual use. Yes, that Android device may not be a high-end device. But the gap is so big, I believe there must be something iOS is doing right that Android isn’t.

    iOS lets users focus on their content they care about and gets everything out of the way. No widgets, no toggle switches for key settings, no this, no that. That’s sounds like a bad thing. When you actually get down to using the device, 90% of the time you are using apps. So what does the iOS Homescreen let you do? Lets you view all of your apps and launch them. Together with the overall intuitiveness and consistency of the user interface in iOS, the operating system just disappears between the user and the user’s content, letting users totally immerse in their content.

    So in the end, iOS wins on the usability segment. No matter how many features it doesn’t have, that’s what matters.

    1. Big words just based on one non-scientific results

    2. Also it seems that while many Android users claim they love android for the powerful hardware, very few of them actually even use/need that power. This just leaves them doing the same thing as iOS users, just with a slightly less clean experience + widgets.

      In the end with or without the powerful processors and graphics, they are in the same boat as any iOS user. Without a good user experience and good applications, the hardware is just excess battery drain.

      1. It seems that ifans will forever be envious of android devices and their widgets. Widgets are actually one of the reasons I went android. Was going to buy an iphone 4 at first, I just like the idea of having widgets. And yes, I do use my droid for browsing, but only if I’m not near a computer. It’s retarded to choose a small screen for browsing the net when you have a larger on right in front of you.

  7. As an Android user, I have purchased nothing other than apps from my android devices. I open my laptop when I have to. I also find it simpler to discover things I want to read on the desktop and then push hem to my tablet using Pocket. Once in pocket I can read from either phone or tablet. I take care to use the most efficient way to do stuff using a combination of devices that include my two laptops and television as well. There in lies your explanation

    1. Then that’s a failure of the OS, shouldn’t it be just as enjoyable on that device?

    2. How does that explain the discrepancy? Pocket is on ios as well.

  8. Obviously, ios user had no life and stuck to their devices on black Friday. Android users?
    Went out to experience life!

    1. I doubt that! LOL!

    2. dont you mean iOS users were out and on their phone, while andriod users were on their desktops at home.

  9. Android is so screwed. Clearly Android users hate not just their devices but themselves too.

    1. Thanks for your insightful contribution to the discussion.

  10. Tethering works on Android. iOS users can’t tell which apps are wasting their data like droid users can. A lot of mobile sites are really only iOS sites. (see Facebook droidfooding for example). This site also drags on every droid browser except opera. Siri results are shopping oriented. Read Woz’s comments about Siri before and after Apple.

    Personally, I use my droid for its utility. Maps, camera, SMS, music, flashlight, calculator, etc. The only time I use it for shopping is to check if I can get something significantly cheaper online.

    1. I use my iOS device the same way that you do. No problems at all. Camera, SMS (iMessage). Music (Spotify), flashlight, calculator etc. But I admit I use Google maps in the browser until a better solution appears.

      1. Spotify is easier / cooler on Android. No ‘hide’ button. Drag from off screen to access menu,. Larger screen makes all apps cooler. Capacitive ‘menu’ and ‘back’ buttons along with drag from off screen commands make the UI of any app less cluttered. The new camera menu you just hold your finger anywhere and the menu pops up in a circle around your finger. I use 2 half screen Google plus widgets, a full screen Gmail widget and NOVA launcher to customize the UX so it is exactly what I want.

        Want to experiences IOS on Android? just don’t use any cool android features.

    2. Manfred Smellington No one Tuesday, November 27, 2012

      Tethering works on ios too.

      1. It may, but it doesn’t matter because it costs too much. Nobody uses it.

        I have unlimited data with tethering on TMo for $30/mo. It costs $20/mo on AT&T just for the privilege of tethering alone. The data costs much more and it’s capped.

        iPhone users have budgets too. It pains me to see my friends with iphones paying extra for things I get free. I play bad piggies for free. My friend has an iphone. It will cost him a dollar.

      2. jailbreak tethering = free for ios users

Comments have been disabled for this post