20 Comments

Summary:

A fuss about Bruce Willis and iTunes reminded people that our kids can’t inherit our digital media because we don’t own it in the first place. Here are some practical ways around that.

Grave, funeral, death, die

A U.K. paper created a fuss this week when it reported that Bruce Willis would sue Apple for the right to pass on his iTunes collection to his children when he dies.

The story turned out to be baloney and was quickly debunked by Willis’ wife. But the tale still raises an important point: how do you leave digital books and music to your loved ones?

The Problem

Last week, a Wall Street Journal story called attention to a long-standing issue that many people are just beginning to discover: we don’t own our iTunes songs, Kindle books and other digital debris.

Here’s why: When you click “I agree,” you don’t receive a piece of property but instead get a license from Apple, Amazon or whoever. And the terms of the license say the media in question is just for you. Unlike a book or a record, digital media can’t be transferred to your friends or, say, to your beloved grandson on your death.

Professor Richard Gold, an intellectual property expert at McGill University, summed up the legal implications of iTunes after death in an email to GigaOM:

Apple presumably has a license to distribute music and it then sublicenses to customers. Licences provide them more control on our use — the number of computers, sharing, etc. The benefit of the contract (licence) should become part of the estate but this would depend on the wording of the licence. This would not necessarily permit a transfer — you cannot force Apple to agree to an assignment of the contract — so would not be of much use. The only way I could imagine around this would be to say that a property right of some sort was transferred through the contract but I can’t think of an example that would work.

The upshot is that you can’t leave iTunes as property in your will because it’s not your property in the first place. State legislatures are beginning to take up the issue but it will be years (if at all) before we have a “who gets your iTunes” law. But don’t fret. Despite the weird licensing rules, you still have options to ensure Junior gets your digital Beatles collection:

Option 1:  Create a fancy legal trust

The original U.K. news story reported that Bruce Willis was asking his lawyers to create “family trusts” to hold his digital music. Since then, others have reported on fancy legal tools like “DAP Trust” to circumvent the iTunes rules. David Goldman, the man behind the DAP trust, says he is working on software that will let estate lawyers offer digital inheritance to their clients.

The problem here is that there is no guarantee a trust will work. After you die, the benefit of the trust would transfer to someone else — which appears off limits under Apple’s rules. “I would want to see the contract,” says Gregg Weiss, a New York estate lawyer. “You can’t change a policy in a license through a trust.”

Option 2: Burn your media onto a device and put the device in your will

Apple, Amazon and other retailers permit users to download digital books or music to multiple devices. This means that Bruce Willis and the rest of us can load up an e-reader or an MP3 player with content and then bequeath the device. Unlike the digital media, you do have a property right in the device.

Sticklers might note that Apple or Amazon have the right to take the digital content away from your chosen heir or heiress, leaving them with a barren Kindle or iPod. But we’re betting the lawyers for those companies have better things to do than crash wakes and inspect devices.

Option 3: Write down the darn password

This is the simplest and most obvious answer — simply provide your media passwords to your loved ones. Weiss, the estate lawyer, says it’s already common practice for attorneys to advise their clients to prepare a list of banking passwords. Simply add your iTunes account to the list and place it an envelope or an email to be sent when you die.

If you want to be technical, you could also provide the password in your will. Your digital songs and e-books are not your property — but your password is. Handing it over will let your digital media live on.

(Image by Chris Harvey via Shutterstock)

  1. “Your digital songs and e-books are not your property — but your password is”.

    So I`m not buying anything, just paying rent to a service?

    Share
    1. Thanks for your comment, Alex. Yes, you can loosely say you’re renting a service. A more precise way to look at it is that you’re entering a contract; you pay 99 cents in return for the right to listen to a song and, in some cases, to copy it to your iPod. These type of contractual right are not the same as property rights (which are much stronger) which is one of the reasons the inheritance issue is so messy.

      Share
  2. These tips aren’t solutions – they are simply telling you to pirate the material in various ways.

    Therefore it’s no different that downloading the music/video from BitTorrent.

    This ‘renting’ agreement needs to be addressed as no doubt most average consumers would be completely unaware that they don’t own it after they purchased it.

    Share
    1. Mikie, I’m not sure most people would equate this with piracy. In this case, you’ve paid for something which is very different than simply stealing something with the help of BitTorrent.

      Share
      1. David Woodhouse Friday, September 7, 2012

        What if I pay for it and *then* get it with BitTorrent? Not an unrealistic prospect — I do it a lot with books. If the ebook isn’t available in my country then I download it, and then buy a paperback.

        In both cases, even though I’ve paid for the use of *one* copy, the other one is still a copyright violation under the law. Morally it’s different, I agree. But legally it’s not.

        Note that it’s *not* theft. Please don’t conflate copyright violation with theft which is something completely different.

        Share
      2. That’s interesting. I bought a video game for one console, then torrented it for a different console. i still got a warning from my ISP. Are you saying I have the right to download all copies of the game since I bought one?

        Share
  3. The password argument might bump up against identity fraud. If the password is being used to as the credential to establish the identity of the person/corporation/group having purchased the license, then its use by others might be open to question when they try to do so

    In fact the combination is almost always an identifier and a credential. So the item at issue who or what is the entity being identified and is the credential being used within the terms of the license to verify that entity?

    Share
  4. EU Brainwashing Thursday, September 6, 2012

    Always purchase content on CD ROM, rip the files to a hard-drive, update your MP3 player from your hard-drive. Don’t be lazy or impulsive in your purchasing habits. Only ‘rent’ digital files when the deal is so substantially better value than purchasing a CD – for example via Spotify. I calculated the cost of purchasing all the music I wanted to have access to and which I have via Spotify would cost the same as 20 years of Spotify subscriptions. Now I hope I last a little longer than that but I also hope my musical preferences have moved-on too!

    Share
  5. Option 4: Store your passwords at https://secure.cloudsafe.com and give access to your loved-ones.

    Share
  6. What about all of your other assets online, music only makes up a small part of what people have created, shared, own or access via the web – all of these things need to be thought of as well

    Firms are out there to help collate all your information in one place and then pass the information on

    Cirrus Legacy is one in the UK http://www.cirruslegacy.com
    Legacy Locker one in the US
    http://www.leagcylocker.com

    Share
  7. All the more reason to be wary of cloud-based storage as your only backup of music or other data you might be “renting” without realizing it. Strip the DRMs, and backup to a hard disk.

    Consider this ramification: I purchased Mountain Lion from the App store. Does that mean that if I die, by wife can no longer use the software because it was on “loan” from Apple?

    Share
  8. Option 2 is the cleanest, particularly if you have avoided DRM. Files are files, and you should never keep your only copies of precious files only in a device and cloud controlled by someone else (who has very different incentives than you). Backup, early and often, to multiple devices. Even share your files with family before you die.

    Share
  9. Another option would be provide a financial incentive to digital content producers to allow sharing bit.ly/OX3lKj

    Share
  10. Lo mejor es estar conectados en todo momento por las grandes acciones y eventos que se dando día con día fabuloso

    Share
  11. Connie J. Mableson Thursday, September 6, 2012

    Another Option- Store your passwords on a mobile device and give the password to a trusted friend so when you die, your family has access to your accounts. One great device is the DAK at http://www.digitalassetadvisors.com. Its cheap at around $30.00. Provides for different levels of security as you wish. Remember one password instead of hundreds of user ids and passwords.

    Share
  12. My wife and I jointly own all our devices and we share a common spreadsheet of passwords so if one was to pass on, we are not fraudulently using our devices. Apple is not ‘exercising’ its right to remove the songs and e-books at that point and add to that the fact that our joint bank account funded the purchases…yeah I feel good with knowning my library will live on.

    Share
  13. Un gran negocio es creer que se puede

    Share
  14. Gloria Quintanilla Monday, September 10, 2012

    This question of ownership in the digital age is quite fascinating. If anyone is interested in exploring how this relates to our changing relationship with media and the future of print, I encourage you to check out my commentary on this discussion in the following link: http://www.peecho.com/blog/index.html

    Share
  15. Who cares whats against the law anyhow? this stuff is on private property (our computers) who can say what you have got that is against so called laws, all BS if you ask me, you would need a search warrant to view whats on my system, you guys do worry way to much. I stole everything I wanted before all these digital BS laws came out, so that makes it grandfathered in my opinion, I don’t care about yours!

    Share
  16. I practice the honor system. I have a really reliable torrent site that I “Back-up” my digitally purchased recordings. “With great power comes great responsibility”. Aside from that there are ways to own your iTunes library. Don you see!!!?? We still have the power!!! Buy what you listen to please!!!

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post