6 Comments

Summary:

Last night at a Google Women Techmakers talk I expected more talk about big problems bringing women into tech. What I got were complaints about the lack of female-sized T-shirts and the sense that the female speakers were treated well by their male colleagues.

googlewomen

This has been a big week for women in technology. Facebook has finally put a woman on its board. Yesterday the Girls who Code project backed by Google, Twitter and eBay got a lot of attention. So last night at a Google Women Techmakers talk I expected more talk about big problems bringing women into tech. What I got were complaints about the lack of female-sized T-shirts and the sense that the female speakers were treated well by their male colleagues.

“I’m always surprised there aren’t more women, because if you look at technology, it’s a very new field,” said Susan Wojcicki, senior vice president for advertising at Google. “There’s not enough time to be biased. If you have a great product, it doesn’t matter.”

But there still aren’t enough female engineers working in tech. Many tech companies want to hire more female engineers, but figuring out how to get them in the door remains a challenge.

According to the National Center for Women & Information Technology, women made up only 14 percent of 2010 computer science graduates at major research universities. While women are 57 percent of the U.S. workforce, they hold only 25 percent of computing occupations. Women make up only 20 percent of CIO (chief information officer) positions at Fortune 500 companies.

The women on the Google panel said one primary reason they have difficulty recruiting women to engineering positions has to do with stereotypes. They said many people are taught to think of the “loner programmer,” or the image of the engineer working by himself in a numbers-driven field:

“Computer sicence has this vision of being solitary,” Wojcicki said. “But I sort of fell into it accidentally too, and I was surprised by how creative it really was.”

So if the tech companies can market programming as creative to recruit smart, talented women, can they support them within the corporate culture? Several of the Google women said that in their experiences, once women get into the field, the tech industry treats them well and makes them feel like equal players on the team:

“The culture of technology is very rational and objective,” said Angela Lai, the vice president of engineering of payments at Google. She noted that she’s often been the only woman in a room of designers or engineers, but that she’s forged bonds with her male coworkers.

Issues of recruiting aside, how well the tech world has totally adopted female engineers and business leaders into its ranks is still contentious. Venture capital firm Kleiner Perkins is fighting a highly public lawsuit brought by one if its female partners who has accused the company of perpetuating sexual discrimination against her.

With Sheryl Sandberg’s appointment to Facebook’s board on Monday, only now has Facebook responded to longstanding criticism that it needed a more diverse board. In a final example, angel investor Joanne Wilson wrote recently that while she was pleased to be named to Business Insider’s “New York’s Top Early Stage Investors,” her entry noted that she’s the wife of investor Fred Wilson, whereas Fred’s entry made no mention of her.

But even Google, a company the panelists praised for its efforts to recruit and retain female engineers, did not escape criticism from a mostly female audience on Tuesday.

One female audience member asked why, when she had applied to work at Google as an engineer, she had been interviewed by an all-male team. Another woman demanded to know why t-shirts distributed to attendees of the Google I/O conference only come in male sizes:

“I don’t want to be told that I can sleep in it,” she said, to knowing chuckles from her fellow audience members. Someone else asked that women’s shirts be distributed next year, and “please don’t make them pink.”

Wojcicki promised there would be t-shirts in women’s sizes next year. Then the company closed the event by distributing tote bags with a “Women at Google” logo. The logo was pink.

Google provided a livestream of this panel, and noted that the full video would be available online later. The video will be posted here when it becomes available.

  1. From those stats you provide, women hold a disproportionate share of jobs in the computer industry, relative to how many are actually trained in CS. If only 14% of the CS graduates in 2010 were women, it might be safe to assume that the percentage was probably no greater than 10% 10 or 15 years ago. However, they hold 20% of the CIO positions at Fortune 500 companies, which means a female CS graduate is more likely to advance to CIO than a male graduate. And even though they only comprise 10-15% of the CS graduates, they hold 25% of the computing occupations.

    While I am generally skeptical of statistics, these numbers seem to imply that the main reason for the low percentage of women in tech is due to the low percentage of women studying CS and engineering. It’s not a corporate culture issue, but one of supply.

    Share
    1. P. Oppenheimer Wednesday, June 27, 2012

      The number of computer science and engineering degrees granted to women reached 37% in 1984. The sharp decline started only about 10 years ago when women became concerned that there would not be any jobs. Many of the women who graduated in the 80s and 90s are still in the computer field. Some are C-level execs. Others are software engineers, network engineers, hardware engineers, Q& analysts, managers, etc.

      Share
  2. I just ordered t-shits for my company the other day, and I made sure to order 1/3 of them in a female specific style. Learned my lesson the first time ordering shirts when my wife said “wtf, I don’t want to wear a mans shirt!”

    Share
  3. Reblogged this on Women In Technology Hamilton and commented:
    I agree: Don’t make the shirts pink! DevTO had better get on this too. ;)

    Share
  4. Maybe they should use their venture, grants, acquisitions to encourage women. So far, it just looks like they are doing it for PR, without any skin in the game.

    Share
  5. n074v41L4BL34u Thursday, July 5, 2012

    “I’m always surprised there aren’t more women, because if you look at technology, it’s a very new field” – there aren’t many women in tech precisely because it is new/innovative. Well, at least it was.

    I don’t know the cause, some of it might be social in nature but most of it is probably genetic – women are mostly non-innovative creatures. New fields of knowledge are very rarely created by women.

    If you want to know what’s brewing in the world just look what the boys are doing – 10 years form know it’s going to me an innovative field, and 20 years form now it will start to become mainstream and only then more women will start to enter the field.

    Women have centuries old tendency to lag behind. It’s nothing new, it’s normal. Men and women are different in this respect, they have always been that way and it’s unlikely to ever change. It’s nature.

    Though, one negative thing about female employees emerges when one reads the article. You can already see a trend in classic female whining: all-male boards, all-male interviews, wrong sized t-shirts etc. I mean, c’mon! IT is an efficient business precisely because nobody gave a damn about such petty things. Well, it seems that is about to change, unfortunately.

    Then again, I do recognize that women have other qualities that will probably be useful in IT. They are hard working and pay more attention to detail so it’s possible that the overall software quality might improve. We’ll see.

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post