Summary:

A week after slapping down Google-owned Motorola and Apple for some of their “ridiculous” claims in their ongoing patent lawsuit, Judge Richard Posner has given the case a small reprieve. There will be an injunction hearing held in Chicago next week.

Apple Motorola Legal Battle

A week after slapping down Google-owned Motorola and Apple for some of their “ridiculous” claims in their ongoing patent lawsuit, Judge Richard Posner has given the case a small reprieve. In a follow-up to last week’s initial decision, Posner said he would allow one more hearing to weigh a possible injunction.

The judge on Wednesday signed an order granting Apple’s request for a “traditional injunction hearing” at which both sides will argue whether they have met a four-part legal test to obtain a ban on the other’s product.

The hearing is consistent with his earlier decision to take the case out of the hands of a jury.

At the new hearing, scheduled for next Wednesday, the parties will also argue whether royalty payments should be imposed.

The decision is a bit of a surprise. Last week it looked as though Posner was inclined to dismiss the whole thing, based on his strongly worded ruling and what appeared like a chance to take a stand on the totally out-of-control patent system. As my colleague Jeff Roberts wrote at the time:

[Posner] stated that there was no point in holding a trial because it was apparent that neither side could show they had been harmed by the other’s patent infringement. He said he was inclined to dismiss the case with prejudice — meaning the parties can’t come back to fight over the same patents — and that he would enter a more formal opinion confirming this next week.

That “formal opinion” gives both sides another chance. It’s not a jury trial, but instead will be decided by the judge.

The order was spotted by FOSS Patents.

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

Comments have been disabled for this post