15 Comments

Summary:

LTE phones are the fastest things on the airwaves, but they can also suck a battery dry in a few hours. Here are five reasons why your new Samsung Galaxy Nexus or HTC Vivid is going dead right after lunch time.

iPhone Battery 10-percent

LTE phones are fast, but they can also suck a battery dry in a few hours. Nokia Siemens Networks did some preliminary studies on LTE phone’s power drain versus their HSPA (3G) counterparts and found that LTE devices consume from 5 percent to 20 percent more than previous-generation phones, depending on the application used. Those numbers, however, seem conservative compared to the anecdotal evidence. In its review of the Samsung Galaxy Nexus, Engadget found that the Google Navigation running over the LTE network ate battery power faster than the Nexus’ car charger could restore it.

Why is LTE so greedy? For starters, the radio in your LTE device is doing a lot more than it ever did in your old 3G handset. The radio is the single biggest source of power drain in any device apart from the LED screen, but unlike the display, the radio is always on. And LTE is particularly hungry. The next time your new Galaxy Nexus or HTC Vivid conks out right after lunch, here are five reasons why:

  • Your phone has rabbit ears. All LTE devices sold today use a technology called MIMO, which doesn’t just send or receive a single signal, but rather multiple parallel transmissions. Today’s devices support two such paths – future devices will support more — which means each phone has two antennas, each of which requires its own power amplifier. It’s not quite as bad as the running two phones off of a single battery, but you get the idea.
  • Look at all those networks! Verizon Wireless and MetroPCS 4G phones aren’t just maintaining two LTE links, they’re running an additional radio to boot. Devices from these carriers have to remain in constant contact with both the CDMA network – to receive phone calls and texts – and the LTE network.
  • LTE devices are co-dependent. Your screen may be dark, but your phone is constantly pining for the network. That means its periodically scans the airwaves around it to determine which tower it should tether itself to. The more networks there are to choose from the more scans it must make. With the typical operator sporting some combination of GSM, HSPA, CDMA and EV-DO systems — often multiple version of each in different frequency bands — there are a lot of other networks for an LTE device to flip between.
  • Is that a tower on the horizon? Operators haven’t built out their new LTE footprints densely yet. With cells spaced much further apart, devices have to reach further – and thus boost their transmission power — to latch onto a tower. And since there are still plenty of coverage holes in these networks, phones are dropping in and out of LTE coverage quite often, initiating new rounds of scans and taxing the battery further.
  • This ain’t no FM radio. There is a reason each generation of wireless technology is faster and more efficient than its predecessors. RF engineers are finding more and better ways to wrestle more bits into a radio wave. But, the more complex the waveform, the more computing power phone processors use up modulating and demodulating that radio wave. The 64-state quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM) and orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) techniques used in LTE are as complicated as they sound. Consequently, the faster and more spectrally efficient networks become, the more power phones will consume trying to make sense of their signals.

So are we doomed forever to a life of constantly reaching for our battery chargers? On Monday, we’ll explore what handset makers and network suppliers are doing to improve LTE battery life, but also how they may be fighting a losing battle.

Tesla coil image courtesy of Flickr user caseyyee

  1. Yea, I’m having issues with my Verizon XYBOARD tablet. It barely keeps up even though there is no CDMA radio. What is needed is a EVDO/Lte toggle widget, but sadly there are none…yet!

    Share
  2. I’ve got a Samsung Charge and the battery is terrible. I’m sure the LTE technology isn’t helping, but according to the battery monitor my biggest problem is the screen, which eats up a little more than 60% of my battery life on average. I’ve tried adjusting screen brightness and lockout times to find a healthy balance between what I can live with in the moment and how long my battery lasts, but it still only gets me through about 2/3rds of the day.

    But after reading this I suppose I ought to consider my monitoring my data connection a bit more closely. Thanks for the info.

    Share
  3. Thanks for the article, much appreciated. I keep hearing about how LTE would kill the battery life but when I asked why I would either hear crickets or “it just does”.

    Share
  4. I guess wifi can be a more viable and attractive option for those of us seeking to maximize our phone battery lives!

    Share
  5. Sounds like a job for nuclear-powered batteries!

    Share
    1. Kevin Fitchard Friday, February 17, 2012

      Might want to keep that phone away from your pocket, Alberth :)

      Share
  6. Google is just waiting for apple iOS upgrade and then conveniently write very similar code to solve the artery issue …

    Share
    1. Not so fast... Friday, February 17, 2012

      I believe you have that backwards.

      Share
  7. HTC had bad Q4 last year just because of poor battery life of LTE phones. New phones like Titan II (http://harryminhas.wordpress.com/2012/01/20/htc-titan-ii/) & One X (http://harryminhas.wordpress.com/2012/01/20/htc-titan-ii/) will have large battery in 2012.

    Share
  8. Dead phones for me are a thing of the past. My solution to all-day battery power comes from an Energizer XP8000 mobile battery pack. It goes on my belt or inside a jacket pocket easily, and I can use it to keep both my smartphone and mobile hotspot going all day long, with multiple charges.

    Share
  9. I have a Verizon galaxy nexus and battery life sucks, plus 3rd party external batteries and car chargers cannot supply enough current to recharge or even maintain the battery.
    My solution was replace the 1750mah battery with seidio 3800mah bat. Battery life now is very very good. Also use either verizon supplied car charger or 3rd parry charger that supplies 2amps. I would not purchase a LTE phone without at least a 3000mah battery. Otherwise you will be constantly running out of juice.

    Share
  10. Well, I’m sorry but as telecoms engineer focused on LTE technology all this is simply not true. LTE radio is not so different from WCDMA found on 3.5G (HSU/D ready) phones. Moreover LTE phones are not really looking for 2G/3G/4G separately… Also there is power/MB ration and it is lower on 4G phones. etc etc etc…

    Share
    1. Hi Tom, I actually am covering the last point you made in my next post on the topic. While decoding/encoding LTE transmissions consume more power they also are more spectrally efficient, thus completing their business and ending their data sessions far faster than 3G device. I split the post in to two so I could give equal weight to how LTE power efficiency can improve. Should be up Monday morning.

      Share
  11. For a handset to support both 4G and be able to drop back to 3G in areas where there isn’t 4G yet it actually requires 2 different radios. Both of which are always on and using battery. Doesn’t LTE require yet a 3rd radio?

    Share
  12. Fact is LTE consumes more battery. Toggling over to 3G or 2G and powerful battery with a fatter phone is solution.

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post