4 Comments

Summary:

When DeskMag polled 1,500 international members of the coworking movement, it found only 40 percent of coworking spaces are profitable. How bad is this figure? When you take the movement’s young age into account, not as bad as it first appears, claims the magazine.

376143268_8655d3fbef

When coworking magazine DeskMag recently asked 1,500 international members of the coworking movement about their experiences, most of the news was positive. But as we reported at the time, one negative figure stood out. Only 40 percent of coworking spaces appeared to be profitable.

How bad is the news that more than half of coworking spaces are losing money? Does this spell possibly fatal trouble for the advance of the idea? DeskMag dug further into the figures to find out.

It turns out there’s a big disparity between the profitability of brand new coworking spaces and those that have been around for more than two years. And, as DeskMag explains, this fact coupled with the relative infancy of the movement means the prognosis isn’t so dire:

It should be noted that very few companies in any industries achieve a profit in their first months of existence. And currently, more than half of all coworking spaces are under one year old. That the majority of spaces are not turning a profit could have much to do with the infancy of the movement.

Another important limitation is the corporate form. If 13% of all spaces utilize a non-profit organizational form, economic gains are placed behind social gains for a portion of the industry….

And finally, the long-term picture should be kept in mind. The second Global Coworking Survey shows that 72 percent of all coworking spaces become profitable after more than two years in operation. For privately-run [sic] coworking spaces (those which are not non-profit groups or government-run), the profitability rate after more than two years is even higher, at 87 percent.

Like many of the coworking space founders we’ve talked to, DeskMag also agrees larger spaces tend to do better financially.

70 percent of all privately operated coworking spaces that serve 50 or more members run a profit. Only one in five spaces in this category suffer losses. Coworking spaces with between 10 and 49 members have a profitability rate of about 40 percent — close to the overall average. The more members they take on, the more profitable they become. Economies of scale also affect coworking spaces.

The most difficulties are suffered by small spaces with less than ten members; 56% of them report a loss. Even though they pay less rent and have lower operating costs, only a quarter of small spaces achieved a direct profit.

The overall takeaway here may simply be that while coworking is a “movement” and for some is more about community and quality of life than the bottom line, the spaces themselves are also businesses and will be subject to the same principles — including those that dictate profitability won’t be instant and economies of scale will be in effect — as any other enterprise.

For much more on the finances of coworking spaces, especially details of how many founders initially make it work, check out the complete post.

If you’re a member of a coworking space, do you know how it’s doing financially?

At Net:Work, we’ll explore coworking’s growing collaboration with big business. Is this a boon for both? The event will be held in San Francisco on Dec. 8.

Image courtesy of Flickr user timetrax23.

  1. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits?: When coworking magazine DeskMag recently asked 1,500 inter… http://t.co/QmbGeszm

    Share
  2. Freelance Advice | Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits?: When coworking magazine Desk… http://t.co/TRxi11eA #webdesign

    Share
  3. #virtual events Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits?: When coworking magazine DeskMag recently a… http://t.co/9bX1x5Am

    Share
  4. #virtual events Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits?: When coworking magazine DeskMag recently a… http://t.co/gJFxVbgJ

    Share
  5. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits?: When coworking magazine DeskMag recently asked 1,500 inter… http://t.co/5vw6cCs4

    Share
  6. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits?: When coworking magazine DeskMag recently asked 1,500 inter… http://t.co/ernuZ0er

    Share
  7. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/PGs7dwP7 #smallbiztech

    Share
  8. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/s5VoOuuP #businessapps

    Share
  9. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits?: When coworking magazine DeskMag recently asked 1,500 inter… http://t.co/werFu7sn

    Share
  10. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits?: When coworking magazine DeskMag recently asked 1,500 inter… http://t.co/KmFDJsgB

    Share
  11. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits?: When coworking magazine DeskMag recently asked 1,500 inter… http://t.co/IJVHZyqq

    Share
  12. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits?: When coworking magazine DeskMag recently asked 1,500 inter… http://t.co/0Cu5vlyj

    Share
  13. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits?: When coworking magazine DeskMag recently asked 1,500 inter… http://t.co/w6D1sKmr

    Share
  14. #collabortion Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits?: When coworking magazine DeskMag recently ask… http://t.co/nKr5chjH

    Share
  15. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits?: When coworking magazine DeskMag recently asked 1,500 inter… http://t.co/QT0JoVg8

    Share
  16. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/K94c2vr8

    Share
  17. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/jPe7k6xh

    Share
  18. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/TQncQb7k

    Share
  19. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/x1jmf1IA #webdevfeeds

    Share
  20. [DocDocc] Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/4sjdgu1V via gigaOM

    Share
  21. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/UQ5wEBBB #productivity

    Share
  22. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? – When DeskMag polled 1,500 international members of the cowork… http://t.co/YWXw1LTG

    Share
  23. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? – When DeskMag polled 1,500 international members of the cowork… http://t.co/GfGUs78d

    Share
  24. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/R04EfsE5

    Share
  25. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits?: When DeskMag polled 1,500 international members… http://t.co/aRjs83u3 #JobCircle

    Share
  26. Fburnr: Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits?: When coworking magazine… http://t.co/1y8tPXzM

    Share
  27. RT @WebWorkerDaily: Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/W2YPaXV3 #coworkingeu @deskmag

    Share
  28. RT @CoworkingDE: RT @WebWorkerDaily: Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/W2YPaXV3 #coworkingeu @deskmag

    Share
  29. I’m getting bored with the sensational stuff about coworking here on GigaOm. 99% of internet startups aren’t generating revenue, let alone profit…and yet coworking spaces, 40% of whom are turning a profit, are in trouble?

    Share
    1. I think the headline is sensational but the context was measured.

      Share
  30. RT CoworkingDE: RT @WebWorkerDaily: Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/NbikSTdi #cowor… http://t.co/HWdF9mVU

    Share
  31. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/FgM97KTa

    Share
  32. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/u0HsXR6j

    Share
  33. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/oQj9HVeU

    Share
  34. Thank you for pointing out that many coworking spaces are new and less than two years old. Most business don’t turn a profit until they are 3 or 4 years into operations, and coworking spaces have the extra challenge of awareness of the concept and not just the space. This means that coworking spaces have to first educate people and then awareness of the ‘brand/space’ itself.

    Creative Density was the first coworking space in Denver to open in three years and many of the older spaces stopped promoting the coworking concept in any meaningful way. When Density opened up in June I had a lot of education to do about coworking before I could even talk about Density, but this also means there isn’t much competition. We will likely be operationally profitable this January (7 months old).

    I think we will start to find that coworking spaces will start to start to be profitable after their first 18 months or so. As the new movement ages the percentage of survivors will go up dramatically.

    Share
  35. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/xJPvZpN4

    Share
  36. “40% of #coworking spaces are turning a profit & are in trouble?” http://t.co/uSx6dXKZ

    Share
  37. RT @deskmag: “40% of #coworking spaces are turning a profit & are in trouble?” http://t.co/uSx6dXKZ

    Share
  38. RT @deskmag: “40% of #coworking spaces are turning a profit & are in trouble?” http://t.co/uSx6dXKZ

    Share
  39. We started Lightbulb Coworking in fall of 2009 based on a close to break-even model. We have been cash-flow positive since 90 days in and continue to do well. We have even reached a decent level of profitability after upgrading our space and amenities and adjusting rates accordingly.

    As the article and comments allude to, the only major obstacle we have encountered is the need to educate the community. Even in the relatively large city of Charlotte, the concept is often a new and novel idea that is not commonly understood. That has been mitigated by our city being so transient and bringing people from more coworking-friendly markets to Charlotte.

    Having been the first coworking space in Charlotte, we have seen about a half dozen other attempts which have all closed within 6 months or are basically just sitting empty. Several of those were simply people with extra space who decided coworking might be a way to put surplus square footage to work.

    I think that one of the problems with the coworking “movement” is that it often is treated too much like a “movement” or intangible idea, and less like a business. Find a need, meet the need, develop a profitable business model, make a profit. Even from my early research into the idea, I have been less inspired by the “movement” and more inspired by the fact that the model of a more flexible and accessible office space is simply a good idea that resonates with today’s worker. More “head” and less “heart” guiding the process.

    Perhaps more focus on the business, the desks, the space, etc…and less focus on the acoustic Kumbaya circles that are suppose to spontaneously appear when the “community” gathers would better serve some space operators. I was even told, and have heard other well-known space operators around the country state that coworking cannot work without a community already established. I knew no one when we started. No community, no followers…but we have that now.

    We have a great community…great collaboration, social interaction, a high level of sub-contracting between members and all of the things that coworking can provide.

    But…it started with a great space…with a desk, a chair, a great internet connection…at the right price. Simple.

    Share
  40. Important: Education and Awareness- in response to “Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits?” @gigaom: http://t.co/kf017fY9

    Share
  41. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/cHpgZv4a

    Share
  42. “@fridley: Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/G62ob2Ny” @kellysims

    Share
  43. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/YRmAh6tG

    Share
  44. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? — Online Collaboration http://t.co/1gc7hv8y via @addthis

    Share
  45. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/kAxQGrAt cc @guilhembertholet pour ton espace lyonnais

    Share
  46. @stephtara That’s good news, given what I read this week: http://t.co/G2T7Y6Vw :)

    Share
  47. RT @MeridianOffices @CoworkingDE @WebWorkerDaily: Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/ZE0CDAj6 #coworkingeu

    Share
  48. But most current co-working sites are losing $$$ http://t.co/zfkIqByV

    Share
  49. RT @deskmag: “40% of #coworking spaces are turning a profit & are in trouble?” http://t.co/uSx6dXKZ

    Share
  50. Theres hope after 2 years @WebWorkerDaily: Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/BQheQ8nk #coworkingeu @deskmag

    Share
  51. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/DW40XssK

    Share
  52. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/DW40XssK

    Share
  53. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? http://t.co/JZkBtx2h

    Share
  54. A little dose of reality for those thinking running a coworking space is a great way to get rich: http://t.co/Jv1wNk3l

    Share
  55. RT @locusworkspace: A little dose of reality for those thinking running a coworking space is a great way to get rich: http://t.co/Jv1wNk3l

    Share
  56. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? – GigaOm http://t.co/a7prtLuu

    Share
  57. Are most coworking spaces in dire financial straits? – GigaOm http://t.co/ZavPt0LJ

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post