10 Comments

Summary:

Streaming services like Netflix and Hulu are attracting more eyeballs every month, stealing attention away from traditional TV. But cable providers could soon fight back, by basing their pricing on how much a given user streams every month. That would effectively raise prices for streaming services.

parking meter

Streaming services like Netflix and Hulu are attracting more eyeballs every month, stealing attention away from traditional TV. But cable providers could soon fight back, by basing their pricing on how much a given user streams every month.

comScore reported earlier this week that viewers watched a record-high 42.6 billion videos online in October, with YouTube leading the way. Viewers watched an average of 21 hours of online video a piece during the month, which is a far cry from the four or five hours a day that they watch of broadcast TV. But its a 50 percent increase from the 14.5 hours of video that online viewers averaged in December 2010.

Pay TV services finally on the decline?

As online viewership has increased, there’s evidence that it’s finally causing some viewers to avoid paying for cable. Credit Suisse analyst Stefan Anninger forecast in a research note this week that the multichannel video industry will lose 200,000 subscribers in 2012, which is a big about-face from the 250,000 new subscribers that he previously estimated cable, satellite and IPTV providers would gain next year. The reason? Economically driven “cord avoiders” who can’t afford cable or satellite TV, as well as “cord nevers” — young people who get their first homes but choose not to pay for TV, choosing to stream video over broadband instead.

That’s led to a new round of concerns about the future of the pay TV industry — and what cable companies might due to combat potential threats from streaming competitors. And it’s prompted more speculation that an increased focus on broadband could lead cable companies to institute usage-based pricing that links the amount of bandwidth users consume with the amount that they pay. The latest comes from Sanford Bernstein analyst Craig Moffett, who said in an interview with Bloomberg that at least one cable provider will institute that type of pricing model over the next year.

The specter of usage-based pricing

For years, usage-based pricing has loomed as a threat to the mostly unlimited broadband Internet plans that users subscribe to today. While cable companies like Comcast have long instituted caps to limit the amount of data some of its users consume, they’ve stopped short of charging more based upon customer usage. But now more than ever, it seems like operators are finally ready to pull the trigger on usage-based pricing.

One big reason is the ever-growing amount of video traffic popping up on their networks. Earlier this year, Sandvine reported that Netflix users, on average, stream about 40 GB a month, and that the streaming provider makes up about a third of all peak downstream Internet traffic.

Killing two birds with one pricing model

Not only do services like Netflix clog their pipes, but they’re also competing with traditional TV services. For that reason, usage-based pricing is being promoted as a way to kill two birds with one stone: By effectively raising rates that customers pay to access streaming services, the effect could be less competition with their video services, while also possibly decreasing the amount of traffic that goes over their pipes.

Services like Netflix and Hulu Plus are attractive in part because they’re cheap: At $7.99, both services are significantly less expensive than the $70 on average that cable subscribers pay. But if more streaming means higher broadband prices, those services don’t look as cheap.

There are other reasons for cable companies to pitch broadband services, of course. They have better margins than traditional video services, and that profitability isn’t threatened by content costs that continue to rise. It’s also a key differentiator from satellite competitors who can’t bundle their own Internet services with TV packages. But as streaming video continues to gain consumer adoption, carriers will be looking to slow that growth and make competing online options less attractive.

Image courtesy of Flickr user LWY.

  1. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/MzDuTcCN

    Share
  2. [DocDocc] Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/hEh5fBo4 via gigaOM

    Share
  3. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/xHDYrau9

    Share
  4. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/rx50rdbA @amarchugg #news

    Share
  5. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/ZmtjEZxU @amarchugg #news

    Share
  6. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/xvdWxmgK

    Share
  7. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star?: Streaming services like Netflix and Hulu are attracting… http://t.co/wNBjppL3

    Share
  8. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star?: Streaming services like Netflix and Hulu are attracting… http://t.co/3plDoWMU

    Share
  9. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star?: Streaming services like Netflix and Hulu are attracting… http://t.co/XLs2CtOn

    Share
  10. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star?: Streaming services like Netflix and Hulu are attracting… http://t.co/KHgQKQ8O

    Share
  11. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star?: Streaming services like Netflix and Hulu are attracting… http://t.co/Ee8VbrtC

    Share
  12. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star?: Streaming services like Netflix and Hulu are attracting… http://t.co/dSSw3iS3

    Share
  13. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star?: Streaming services like Netflix and Hulu are attracting… http://t.co/AGAKPd8p

    Share
  14. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star?: Streaming services like Netflix and Hulu are attracting… http://t.co/AGAKPd8p

    Share
  15. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star?: Streaming services like Netflix and Hulu are attracting… http://t.co/dT9FgzpW

    Share
  16. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star?: Streaming services like Netflix and Hulu are attracting… http://t.co/ZB6q8veN

    Share
  17. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/GanFvbRt via Ryan Lawler

    Share
  18. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/nmBbR57o

    Share
  19. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/Bg1a8NCg

    Share
  20. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/oxhvsWVD

    Share
  21. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/HKNJtsXt

    Share
  22. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/Qq7KoAlB

    Share
  23. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/oBDdl9xK

    Share
  24. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/XCjb0nAf

    Share
  25. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/d6VXJ5Wm

    Share
  26. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/j9QRdrLp

    Share
  27. No. S/he’ll switch to an unmetered-charge ISP. RT @ryanlawler Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/wEtm4pvw…

    Share
  28. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star?: Streaming services like Netflix and… http://t.co/GGdh7wVq

    Share
  29. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/XF0OHnS8

    Share
  30. Cable providers could change their pricing methods to battle online streaming sites like #Netflix http://t.co/kVMFRFm6

    Share
  31. Something I have been concerned about… RT: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/E4q4MVdt

    Share
  32. Obviously – Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/lr1imW3U

    Share
  33. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/i1r9UwvC

    Share
  34. RT @NewTeeVee: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/xHDYrau9

    Share
  35. RT @gigaom: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/Bg1a8NCg

    Share
  36. RT @gigaom: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/Bg1a8NCg

    Share
  37. RT @gigaom: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/Bg1a8NCg

    Share
  38. gigaom: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/7aSHi2Mn

    Share
  39. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/zS28HlaW

    Share
  40. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/nh2hvN93

    Share
  41. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star?: Streaming services like Netflix and Hulu are… http://t.co/A1Q16J01 #webseries

    Share
  42. You knew this was coming sooner or later! http://t.co/U4sHje5g

    Share
  43. RT @NewTeeVee: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/xHDYrau9

    Share
  44. NewTeeVee: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/dBYpu2y8

    Share
  45. @gigaom Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/Pb67OjzU >>surprised it hasn’t happened yet. Cloud services too

    Share
  46. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/iJ3uPWoz

    Share
  47. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star?: Streaming services like Netflix and… http://t.co/4zml0wkg

    Share
  48. Time for a new approach to streaming video? http://t.co/QzdMqKT5

    Share
  49. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/omXTD2Jn

    Share
  50. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/Av4Qxhe8

    Share
  51. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star?: Streaming services like Netflix and Hulu are attracting… http://t.co/ec5aosn5

    Share
  52. GigaOM: Netflix vs. cable industry – Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/qfafHn6k

    Share
  53. RT @gigaom: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/Bg1a8NCg

    Share
  54. RT @gigaom: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/Bg1a8NCg

    Share
  55. #converg asked ? re. download caps & vid streaming.Note effect of poss move away frm unlimitd plans to usage basd in US http://t.co/uI4fstlE

    Share
  56. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/Tclr1Pxd

    Share
  57. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? – Streaming services like Netflix and Hulu are attracting mo… http://t.co/ls6HR8zj

    Share
  58. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? – Streaming services like Netflix and Hulu are attracting mo… http://t.co/Idah4KUu

    Share
  59. RT @gigaOM: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/0FBcPwSy

    Share
  60. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/pRiIKXob

    Share
  61. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/lWlXdm80

    Share
  62. With the margins local cable monopolies are reporting on their broadband business versus scheduled TV channels, the main challenge for world consumers is holding corrupt politicians’ feet to the fire to allow, mandate, or incentivize competition in each market. We don’t need DVR’s; we need a cheap pipe to the recordings on content providers’ and licensees’ servers available 24/7/365, so that the consumer can take full advantage of the competition between content providers, as the backlog of often excellent vintage content versus overpriced, often inferior new content, not to mention public domain content that will continue to build even in this era of absurd, Congressional whore-extended copyright terms.

    Share
  63. add “, continues to grow.” to the end.

    Share
  64. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/TIDPSiLR

    Share
  65. RT @gigaom: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/Bg1a8NCg

    Share
  66. Is there good evidence that Netflix is “clogging the pipes”? There is data that says video traffic is increasing dramatically, but this doesn’t necessarily mean “clogged pipes”.

    Share
  67. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star?: 30, 2011, 4:42pm PT No Comments Streaming services like… http://t.co/ZZvSt09X

    Share
  68. Kinda expected – Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/k9J1FoWU

    Share
  69. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/padDKHNY

    Share
  70. Will usage-based #pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/PQay7CrL

    Share
  71. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? — Online Video News http://t.co/6KN6tPx9

    Share
  72. RT @KITdigital: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? (@gigaOm) http://t.co/fKR9c7wm

    Share
  73. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/b4udqF3a

    Share
  74. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/Vxv6CyBI

    Share
  75. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/qAnOQgyQ #onlinevideo

    Share
  76. RT @tdgnewsfeed:@NewTeeVee: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/P3Vkw4iN

    Share
  77. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/5ciDIDCZ

    Share
  78. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star?: Streaming services like Netflix and Hulu are attracting… http://t.co/ADrV3faA

    Share
  79. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/z6vFr8Ta

    Share
  80. RT @gigaom: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/DTwnYuTl

    Share
  81. RT @gigaom: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/Bg1a8NCg

    Share
  82. Konkurrenz von Streaming Video und Kabel-TV führt in USA u.U. zu mengenabhängigen Preisen für Netzzugang http://t.co/84USKLWI via @newteevee

    Share
  83. Answer: likely no, but it will suck >>> Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/TBrLBvEn

    Share
  84. Answer: likely no, but it will suck >>> Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/TD4ikSXa

    Share
  85. #in Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video?  http://t.co/6FotO7dz

    Share
  86. RT @DevioMedia: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/qAnOQgyQ #onlinevideo

    Share
  87. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/JMaZ4Gsb

    Share
  88. RT @gigaom: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/Bg1a8NCg

    Share
  89. Will usage-based pricing kill Netflix and Hulu? http://t.co/60d6z3GG via @gigaom #streamingmedia

    Share
  90. #Cable companies fight back! Will usage-based pricing kill the #streaming video star? http://t.co/UJTVAyXc

    Share
  91. This will backfire. The cable operators will lose TV subscribers to the cheaper satellite operators. As wireless access speeds increase, more folks will be cutting the cord. To foster ever more competition, regulators need to come up with simple rules that allow the market to work. The relationship between regulators and the major players in the telecom industry is much too cozy now.

    Share
  92. The danger of cable and broadband provider as one: http://t.co/8R9OSAu3

    Share
  93. Scary future since most don’t have choice of BB providers. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star http://t.co/xOo5qkDC

    Share
  94. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? — Online … http://t.co/iQGfvakv

    Share
  95. For what it is worth, we think that the future of OTT video streaming will see companies “pre-budling” free bandwidth into their own apps so that any rental/purchase download will be “toll-free” to the end user. This allows a free market mechanism to come into the picture and provides value and price transparency to end users. It will obviously eat into the streaming margins a bit for companies like Netflix (their revenues will be shared with carriers in exchange for the free byte delivery), but it’s a small price to pay really. Funny enough, free byte delivery is how Netflix got started (and succeeded wildly) — the bytes were snail mailed to you for free via the post office. In the future the bytes will likely be mailed to you digitally for free via AT&T, Sprint, and Verizon. Pre-bundling bytes into apps (we call it “FreeBand”) is also the best way for the carriers to introduce dynamic pricing of bytes (the apps turn red, yellow or green throughout the day depending on how much bandwidth is being subsidized by the app provider at that particular time) and manage their load using free market principles. If anyone wants more info on the subject, feel free to review our FreeBand platform online at http://www.boxtop.tv Thanks!

    Share
    1. Thomas, I like your (boxtop’s) business model. Heck, I just looked at my ATT Uverse bill. FreeBand looks like a great alternative. I hope the carriers “get it” – the service and the concept.

      Share
      1. Thanks for the kind words Fred.

        The mobile (and some wireline) carriers definitely get it — but it is very different thinking to what their management grew up with (centralized data management / one size fits all). But with app / cloud / edge trends storming the market, even the most conservative carriers are now investigating dynamic pricing (just like the electric companies already do for grid load management). As such, we think 2012 will be the year we’ll see dynamically priced bandwidth and content merging once and for all (actual bytes + byte delivery = the “all in” product), so watch this space.

        Share
  96. Interesting comment on “Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star?” @gigaom: http://t.co/ppxYi8Ed via @gigaom

    Share
  97. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? — GigaOm http://t.co/w73u8KpS

    Share
  98. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/2YqYtrc1

    Share
  99. “Now more than ever, it seems like [cable] operators are finally ready to pull the trigger on usage-based pricing.” http://t.co/nIENbvWn

    Share
  100. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/CZhi8AfR

    Share
  101. New pricing models could be on the horizon for cable TV with more declines in subscribers hitting the bottom line: http://t.co/fCiEtSk2

    Share
  102. #Cable provider will institute usage-based pricing over the next year http://t.co/POL4izFX Will this kill streaming video? #PayTV #OTT…

    Share
  103. This is easy. It’ll never happen. The technology never goes backwards. If anything, there will be more. You can’t give something to customers then take it away. Ask Netflix.

    Share
    1. Sure they can. Look at tiered data pricing for cell phones. For years we had “unlimited” data and now it’s all but gone. They offered it because the usage wouldn’t ever hit their limits. Now with new technologies and people wanting to stream everything to their phones, we’re seeing carriers panic because we’re actually taxing their networks.

      Share
  104. RT @iptvtwit: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/CZhi8AfR

    Share
  105. A lot of people are quoting Craig Moffett, but I’m wondering if anyone checked with the DOJ for an opinion. The telcos and cablecos would need to be prepared to prove that this isn’t a “restraint of trade” scenario.

    My point: surely Netflix and other video streamers would claim a conflict of interest — that broadband service providers who also offer pay-TV services could use price-tiers as an anti-competitive business practice.

    Share
  106. More people R choosing to stream videos online and not pay 4 cable. What do U prefer: cable or streaming online videos? http://t.co/BzUhzV4i

    Share
  107. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/VtrwuhJh

    Share
  108. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? — Online Video News http://t.co/7ElTaPvD

    Share
  109. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/AgadE0pv

    Share
  110. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/tLpYRCAl

    Share
  111. RT @gigaom: Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/Y4BimMpf

    Share
  112. http://t.co/47kMvwwD Important for operators

    Share
  113. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/ujLI4E7l

    Share
  114. This looks like the best way to kill innovation & alienate your customer: http://t.co/Ou0MQjTb. Usage-based broadband raises your video cost

    Share
  115. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/jRHXn6ZH

    Share
  116. Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/9JgB3xvh by @ryanlawler

    Share
  117. How will we stop cable companies? Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/ifZ21FWO

    Share
  118. RT @Christinekorda: How will we stop cable companies? Will usage-based pricing kill the streaming video star? http://t.co/ifZ21FWO

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post