27 Comments

Summary:

Once the Google Music store in the Android Market went live, I decided to use all the Apple products I love but to replace iTunes Match and iTunes Music Store with Google Music, both for shopping for playback. Here’s how it went.

Android GoogleWeb gMusic

Once the Google Music store in the Android Market went live, I made my first Android Market music purchase. Not from an Android device and not from a Chrome browser but from Safari running on my iPhone. Then I decided to use all the Apple products I love but to replace iTunes Match and iTunes Music Store with Google Music. Here’s how it went.

Shopping Android’s Music Market from mobile Safari

One great thing about Google’s cloud strategy is that it is primarily browser-based. While this has many shortcomings when it comes to offline access, bandwidth and overall performance, it means I can access the Android Market for Music directly from Safari running on my iOS devices.

Unfortunately, I get sent to the full desktop site, which is less than ideal but still usable. Luckily the Android Market is set up to use Google Payments (makes sense), which I have had set up for some time now. While I was able to complete the transaction despite navigation issues, it was not a process I’m eager to repeat.

From Google Music in the cloud to Apple TV in the living room

One of the most convenient features of the iTunes experience is that no matter where you purchase your music, it will be instantly available on any iOS, Mac or Windows device with iCloud. I hoped that Google Music might be able to replicate that experience, so first I wanted to see if I could get music to play back on my Apple TV.

At first I thought it would be as easy as using Google’s Music Player in Safari to stream directly to my Apple TV using AirPlay. Unfortunately this didn’t work. The way Google has implemented its mobile web player seems to have inhibited my ability to use AirPlay on mobile Safari.

Instead, I decided to route music through iTunes first. I had already been uploading music from my Mac into Google’s Music Player in the cloud, so I assumed that it would be just as easy to download music, and it was. Google has updated its Music Manager on Macs to download purchased music as well as upload your preexisting music library. Once the album was on my Mac, I imported the music into iTunes, but I had to do this manually. It seems as if Google could have learned a thing or two from Amazon in this regard, as purchases from Amazon’s MP3 store can be automatically added to my iTunes library without any manual intervention. Once the music was in iTunes, I was all set to play back on my Apple TV via AirPlay.

Listening to Google Music on an iOS device

It took quite some time before the music I purchased was viewable via the mobile web version of the Google Music Player on my iPhone. What surprised me was that unlike in the web player, the music was almost instantly accessible when using Google’s Music service through the native iOS app gMusic.

GMusic is actually a great player: The interface is almost identical to that of the native Android music player, and it is very similar to Apple’s own Music App. The best part is that gPlus fully supports multitasking playback as well as AirPlay directly from your iOS device. If you are looking to switch from iTunes to Google for buying music and all you care about is playing it back on your iPhone, then this is the app to get.

Overall experience: not a better mousetrap

I don’t think that I will be abandoning iTunes anytime soon for Google’s new Music Store. That’s not surprising, since iTunes is tied so closely to iOS and Mac devices, but what is surprising is that to do exactly the same thing using an Android smartphone leaves you with a very similar experience.

What this experiment indicates to me is that Google thinks the smartphone is the central locus of most people’s music lives. Over the past ten years, Apple has expanded the reaches of its iTunes experience through iPod docks, car kits and AirPlay to help spread your music to anywhere you could hope to listen, and Google has a ways to go before it can match that level of maturity.

  1. I’m surprised you didn’t mention the Apple contrapositive or negative in this case. Apple has 1 data center with no redundancy.

    Well thanks for leaving that out, lol. Chalkie Walkie Talkies probably could care less. Time will tell about the iChalkie device.

    Share
  2. It’s not about Apple’s UI for which they win hands down, it’s about playing by Apple’s rules in Apple’s world. Like many “visionaries”, jobs was a megalomaniac. Open standards are the only standards a customer should accept.

    Share
  3. You mention a lot of things that are not quite correct, for example importing music, you choose which folders you want gm to upload, and select the option if you always want it to upload if new files are added, that’s simple synchronization – in fact when you first install google music on your desktop/notebook it asks you if you want to sync itunes at first start. your problem with the android market is, you didn’t go to google’s mobile version, would of solved your problems, not sure why your web version of gm didn’t show instant updates, i’ve been a beta tester from the beginning, problem with your apple tv is that apple has propriearized all of there creations, good luck with any apple invention, that’s the power of open source, so your airplay problem isn’t googles fault. Gmusic vs Googles Music App, googles if far much richer and better .. I know google republished its gmail for iphone today so shortyly you should see google music in your itunes store app selection..

    Share
  4. You mention a lot of things that are not quite correct, for example importing music, you choose which folders you want gm to upload, and select the option if you always want it to upload if new files are added, that’s simple synchronization – in fact when you first install google music on your desktop/notebook it asks you if you want to sync itunes at first start. your problem with the android market is, you didn’t go to google’s mobile version, would of solved your problems, not sure why your web version of gm didn’t show instant updates, i’ve been a beta tester from the beginning, problem with your apple tv is that apple has propriearized all of there creations, good luck with any apple invention, that’s the power of open source, so your airplay problem isn’t googles fault. Gmusic vs Googles Music App, googles if far much richer and better .. I know google republished its gmail for iphone today so shortyly you should see google music in your itunes store app selection..

    Share
  5. FYI, any program can automatically add music to iTunes. Copy the file into C:\Users\Name\My Music\iTunes\iTunes Media\Automatically add to iTunes. The next time the program is opened it will be imported into iTunes. Not sure if you could just make shortcuts to the original files to save space temporarily or not.

    Share
    1. That is a one way ticket. I also use the same directory to upload to Google. It may be that I need to find a different music player on Mac, and just use Rogue Amoeba’s Airfoil to get to the AppleTV, as I have done with Spotify in the past. http://goo.gl/Lm2EA

      Share
  6. This article is very disjointed. It points out how the Google Music to iOS experience isn’t the same as the iTunes to iOS experience. This should be a given, even from someone who uses neither.

    The weird part comes in where the author suggests that the same problems exist in the Google Music to Android experience. It doesn’t, but the author is perfectly happy to claim so without giving any evidence other than an anecdotal story.

    It could also be said that the iTunes to Android experience isn’t smooth either, but I’m sure the author would blame this on Android rather than on iTunes.

    Perhaps this is where the world is today.

    Share
    1. Using a Samsung Charge I found the experience the same on iOS as on Android. I especially liked gMusic on iOS and felt it was as good or better than the Google Music App on Android. I have always been looking for better ways to use Google’s services from my iOS devices. http://goo.gl/gXAHV

      Share
  7. Google music is nice

    Share
  8. Apple has not spread itunes to all of the devices that I want to listen. How do I listen to itunes music on my Android phone? The real question is not people leaving itunes for Google Music. The question now is which service to use with non-Apple products? Personally I get music from both Amazon and Google and it all resides on Google Music.

    Share
    1. I do really like Amazon’s Music service, and find that it fits into Apple’s hardware ecosystem better than Google’s Music service. IIS also has a native iOS App for Amazon that will hopefully be back in the App Store soon.

      Share
  9. GASP! You mean to tell me that Google Music doesn’t work as well on iOS devices as it does on Android devices that it was developed for?? Who woulda thunk?!

    Share
  10. it hurt reading that….what a pain in the assssss. who wants to go to safari to buy music anyway.

    Share
    1. I do prefer Amazons native App on iOS to purchase music over Googles browser based music store experience.

      Share
  11. apples cost money. this one doesn’t. end of discussion for me. I’m not rich or have money to burn.

    Share
  12. “What this experiment indicates to me is that Google thinks the smartphone is the central locus of most people’s music lives.” I would have to agree that the smartphone is the locus that plagues people’s lives.

    “Over the past ten years, Apple has expanded the reaches of its iTunes experience through iPod docks, car kits, and AirPlay to help spread your music to anywhere you could hope to listen, and Google has a ways to go before it can match that level of maturity.”
    The rest of this 2 sentence paragraph that should be at least 3 sentences long has no problem comparing a software experience with hardware accessories. Apples to oranges anyone?

    Finally, the author must have been very pleased with himself when he delivered his final conclusion that states a 2 day old music service doesn’t seem to be as mature as a nearly 11 year old music service. You humble me with such a bold statement.

    Share
  13. Google music is a much better experience than iTunes. Open it up from any browser or Android device. I don’t know why anyone would post a review using Safari from an iOS device when it clearly is not targeted towards an iOS device. When you say “level of maturity”, you’re really only referring to people who are stuck in Apple’s ecosystem. Google Music is for Android and desktop users primarily and honestly its just a lot better than iTunes overall.

    Share
    1. There is also a growing consensus online that web apps developed using HTML, JavaScript and CS3 will just ‘work’ on all mobile devices. This clearly is not the case in this instance.

      Share
      1. Are you just a selective reader? “Open it up from an browser or ANDROID DEVICE.” Try to get out of such a proprietary mindset. Taking a reading comprehension course wouldn’t hurt either.

        Share
  14. It was so much better beack when all the mac fanboys were just graphic artists…

    Share
  15. I had no problems getting the safari web based media player to stream to my Apple TV. Double tap your home button, scroll to left TWICE to access AirPlay controller. Hit the airplay button and choose your Apple TV device. Worked like a champ for me.

    Share
    1. For me, whenever I try to do exactly the same steps just as you you outlined, I still just see a volume control and no AirPlay control. If I do the same thing in Safari using Amazon’s Music Player, I can see the AirPlay control and it just works. I am not sure why the two would behave differently.

      Share
  16. Turning on Airplay through the Built in Music App on the iPhone, then streaming the songs through Safari will allow Google Music to stream to your apple TV. I just did it.

    Share
  17. Using Google’s new music store with Apple hardware http://t.co/il4hCCOK

    Share
  18. Using Google’s new music store with Apple hardware http://t.co/MVDANwUr

    Share
  19. RT @jrgibson1: Using Google’s new music store with Apple hardware | http://t.co/x95bvJUd

    Does @thespurofthings know this?

    Share
  20. Using Google’s new music store with Apple hardware — Apple …: Once the Google Music store in the Android Marke… http://t.co/HgYyPfOP

    Share
  21. Using Google’s new music store with Apple hardware — Apple …: Once the Google Music store in the Android Marke… http://t.co/4TCKwlXC

    Share
  22. Using Google’s new music store with Apple hardware — Apple …: Once the Google Music store in the Android Marke… http://t.co/xJEoINYn

    Share
  23. Using Google’s new music store with Apple hardware | Apple News, Tips and Reviews http://t.co/TPHDnrjN

    Share
  24. Using Google’s new music store with Apple hardware http://t.co/xa7wgj4n < Hey, Google – listen to appleheads! (To break into the segment)

    Share
  25. Using Google’s new music store with Apple hardware — Apple …: Once the Google Music store in the Android Marke… http://t.co/EYMXIuBg

    Share
  26. Using Google’s new music store with Apple hardware — Apple …: Once the Google Music store in the Android Marke… http://t.co/DIq9EWjp

    Share
  27. Using Google’s new music store with Apple hardware http://t.co/YZhksT5q

    Share
  28. Using Google’s new music store with Apple hardware http://t.co/lqKRWvvQ

    Share
  29. RT @teknomagus: Using Google’s new music store with Apple hardware | Apple News, Tips and Reviews http://t.co/TPHDnrjN

    Share
  30. Using Google’s new music store with Apple hardware http://t.co/tdLjOeoe

    Share
  31. or you could just listen to the entire world of music on MOG, which is now free, including albums. The MOG desktop app for Mac works great and in the lower right corner of the app is a menu to choose Apple TV. Works great!
    Pandora for free either has ads (on browsers, not on Roku) and does not play albums – only artists in mixes.

    Share
  32. RT @GinoRossi: Using Google’s new music store with Apple hardware http://t.co/tdLjOeoe

    Share
  33. Using Google’s new music store with Apple hardware http://t.co/Gx5bStln

    Share
  34. So in regards to your last paragraph about how “Google has a ways to go before it can match that level of maturity”: exactly what are you referring to? If you’re saying Apple is so advanced because of the way it has spread the iTunes experience through said devices, I’d say you need to re-word or re-think that statement. The examples you use (iPod docks, car kits, etc.) do not spread iTunes’ reaches in the way you describe; all of these examples are simply hardware extensions to either an iPhone or an iPod.
    In all honesty, your derogatory statement insinuating Google is inferior to Apple based on your inaccurate review of Google Music needs some work.

    Share
    1. If you add ‘on Apple’s hardware’ to the very end I think the point may be clearer. I was attempting to use Google’s Music services exclusively on Apple products and even via third party extions to those products, both hardware an software alike. How well can Google Music replace Apple iTunes on Apple’s hardware.

      Share
  35. I´ve read somewhere else that Google signed no contract with Warner, which would leave a huge open hole in the market (just think of all the sub-labels or labels that have distribution operated by Warner) in favor of iTunes. Is it really like that?
    I for one still prefer to buy physical objects instead of files when it comes to music, so I´m not really that concerned, but sooner or later we all end up wanting to hear that album while waiting for the bus on the way to work or whatever, so…

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post