8 Comments

Summary:

The way people have been talking about near field communication, digital wallets and carrier billing, you’d think consumers were ready to embrace mobile payments. But Consumer Reports said consumers may not be as excited about paying for goods with their phones, nor should they be.

isis1

The way people have been talking about near field communication, digital wallets and carrier billing, you’d think consumers were ready to embrace mobile payments. But Consumer Reports thinks consumers may not be that excited yet about paying for goods with their phones, nor should they be.

The consumer advocacy organization highlighted transaction problems and fees when warning about potential hurdles standing in the way for mobile payments. Consumer Reports said only 5 percent of recent survey respondents had used their cell phone to pay for day-to-day purchases in the previous month, and only 10 percent had billed a purchase to their home or cell phone account.

The low usage number isn’t completely surprising, given that mobile payments are still quite new to most people, but it underscores the challenges ahead in getting consumers to opt-in to the tech. Many are open to the idea, but there needs to be a good case for ease of use and added flexibility. Payment processes like near field communication require new hardware purchases and some changes in behavior. The challenge for Google , the carrier consortium Isis and others pursuing NFC payments will be to convince consumers that it’s clearly a better option than swiping a card, which is pretty familiar and easy for people.

Consumer Reports said consumers will need to consider how different payment methods handle problems and errors. It found that one in four respondents said they had an unauthorized charge, billing error, non-credited payment, or other problem in the last year when paying for purchases or paying bills. The frequency of those problems could present issues for the growth of mobile payments if left unchecked.

The publication said digital wallet payment services linked to a credit card offer the most protection. Payment methods based on prepaid debit cards offer few guaranteed protections, while direct billing is affected by wireless operator contracts, which Consumer Reports said provides less protection generally that credit-card based payments.

Another issue is the cost of transaction fees for mobile payments, many of which are tied to credit and debit cards and carry the same fees. In most cases, consumers won’t be saving any money with mobile payments, Consumers Reports said.

Now Consumer Reports is going to be conservative here as it looks to protect consumers. But it’s a good reminder that with all the hype around mobile payments, payment providers will need to tell a good story about why this is all necessary. People paying with a wave of their phone makes for a nice commercial, but there’s more to it than that. Consumers will need to know that it’s really that easy, and perhaps more importantly, that it’s safe and secure.

This, however, opens opportunities for companies that can better convey the benefits of mobile payments, or of their particular approach. Mobile payments are expected to take off in the coming years, and could generate $670 billion by 2015. But I think for it to gain more mainstream momentum, the industry will need to show the value of mobile payments to consumers and merchants alike.

You can hear more about mobile payments at GigaOM’s Mobilize Conference on Sept. 26 and 27 in San Francisco, where we’ll be discussing the issue during a panel called: Mobile Payments 2012: Will This Be the Year?

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. Why do we skirt the critical issue here? Do we think that just because we communicate the value of something that people will want to use it? As if how good it is for me, or how easy it makes my life is the defining factor? Paying for things (whether via card, cash, or check) is a deeply-rooted psychological process and will take decades to overcome by “digitizing” the entire payment paradigm. Let’s keep things in perspective.

    1. Not sure it will take decades to move to digital payments but i agree it’s going to take some time for people. Thanks for the perspective.

  2. Peter Antypas Tuesday, August 2, 2011

    Thank you for re-confirming that I’m not the only skeptic. I have been chewed up for my outspoken criticism of the whole NFC hype as being too “top-down” and ripe for failure.

    1. NFC has been hyped for years and it won’t be a mainstream hit right away. So skepticism is warranted. But it looks like a lot of pieces have fallen into place recently so maybe the hype starts to fade next year. We’ll have to see.

  3. I love how there are already experts in this field when it hasn’t even gone to market yet. Come on, “Consumer’s Reports???” Isn’t that something you go to for research on which toaster to buy?

    It is way, way, way too early to determine how mobile payments will evolve. Some of us are old enough to remember when debit cards and ATMs were first introduced (and, wow, we read GigOM too). It wasn’t instantaneous and it was a bigger leap than mobile payments will be. See that person still writing a cheque in the grocery line? It will never be 100%.

    But it will happen. NFC is an interface that is intuitive and can be accomplished without any concentration. Not much different from pulling out a credit card.

  4. J Bhattacharya Wednesday, August 3, 2011

    Great comment Ryan, and I think the emphasis on companies with a new “approach” is key. That’s how we think at Zipmark, mobile is a great touchpoint, but innovation and value has to be right down to the settlement process.

  5. Greg Golebiewski Thursday, August 4, 2011

    To extend the perspective, during a recent payment and banking professionals’ conference that had a panel on mobile payments a speaker asked those in attendance how many of them had smartphones or other devices ready to use NFC technologies — out of perhaps 30-40 high-level professionals only two confirmed they did.

    So, why a regular consumer shoudl be more ready?

  6. AW Sports Car Club Friday, August 5, 2011

    The bigger opportunity for mobile payments is in the MPOS space – not NFC. Vendors like Square, Intuit’s GoPayment and FocusPay by TF Payments offer merchants the ability to accept payments using inexpensive smart phones and tablets, bypassing the expense of “traditional” plug-in-the-wall terminals.

Comments have been disabled for this post