13 Comments

Summary:

With its latest update the MacBook Air inches ever closer to its high-powered siblings in the Pro line of Apple notebooks. But how does it stand up as a replacement for the MacBook Pro, and how does it compare to its predecessors? Here’s what we found.

macbook-air-feature

With its latest update, the MacBook Air  inches ever closer to its high-powered siblings in the Pro line of Apple notebooks. With new Intel Core i5 and i7 processors that offer up to 2.5 times the performance of the previous Airs, they can probably suit the needs of many more a consumer, and likely a few more pro users, too. Here’s how I found the 11.6-inch Air met the task of replacing my 2009 13-inch MacBook Pro, and how it might work for you, too, depending on your needs.

Specs and stats

The 11.6-inch MacBook Air I’m reviewing has all the customization options available for the machine. That means a 1.8 GHz Core i7 Intel processor, 4 GB of RAM, a 256 GB SSD, and an Intel HD Graphics 3000 integrated card with 384 MB of shared memory. The price before tax for this computer as reviewed is $1,649.

With those specs, I ran the Air through the Geekbench tests to determine how fast it was relative to my existing machine and previous Air models. On average after three tests, my Air scored 6308 on the tests. Higher scores on Geekbench are better, and that number is in line with (and slightly exceeds) the Geekbench scores for the 15- and 17-inch MacBook Pros from early 2010. The highest-scoring MacBook Air before this latest release was the top-of-the-line 2010 13-inch model, which rated just 3292 on Geekbench. The bottom line? Thanks to the new Core-series chips, these new Airs can handle quite the CPU load.

 

Real-world performance

The tale of the tape is promising, but how does the new Air respond to real-world challenges? Quite well. My typical workflow involves fairly heavy use of a browser (which is becoming Safari more and more often with OS X Lion), Twitter for OS X, Reeder for Mac, Mail, Sparrow and Photoshop. It can be a demanding mix, but the Air held up well. I was particularly impressed with Photoshop CS5’s performance on the Air; the program launches quickly, and photo editing doesn’t feel like a chore on this ultra-portable, as it can on some notebooks.

But how it behaves when running apps is only half the story. The Air has remarkable startup and shutdown times, thanks to its solid-state storage and Lion’s new emphasis of that as a feature. From the time I press the power button to full desktop takes only 16-18 seconds on average, and shutting down is even faster: around 2-5 seconds. But if you’d rather save yourself even more time, closing and opening the lid to enter and resume from sleep mode shaves off precious seconds.

Tradeoffs

Apple has reduced the sacrifices you have to make in exchange for the Air’s gains in portability and drive speed, but a few still exist, and they may be deal-breakers for some. For example, I found battery life on my Air to be just shy of that on my 2009 13-inch MacBook Pro, even though one has clearly been through far more cycles than the others. You can probably squeeze out the five hours Apple promises, but to do so, you’d have to go with keyboard illumination off (a shame because it’s such a welcome addition to the Air), a fairly low screen brightness and not very much multitasking or video viewing. With average use, I can probably get about three hours out of the Air, compared to about four on my MacBook Pro. The 13-inch Air, with its larger battery, should provide more usage for those looking for it.

Two other sacrifices are the lack of optical disc drive and relatively few ports. You don’t get an SD card slot on the 11.6-inch Air (though you do on the 13-inch), for example, and only two USB ports, with no FireWire and no Ethernet. Apple has brought Thunderbolt to the Air, however, which could more than make up for the lack of other on-device ports when hubs and other Thunderbolt accessories start hitting the market. It’s also worth noting that the Thunderbolt spec used in the new Airs is different from that used in Apple’s Pro notebooks and desktops, so you won’t be able to power more than one external display using it.

Like the Thunderbolt tech, the Air’s FaceTime camera isn’t exactly the same as those that ship with new iMacs and MacBook Pros, since it lacks the “HD” designation. Unless you do a lot of video calling and care deeply about resolution during said calls, however, this shouldn’t prove a major buying consideration.

The lack of an optical disc drive and the presence of only a few ports honestly don’t affect my opinion of the Air, but that’s because I use my notebooks almost exclusively while on the road. For those who want a laptop that can be both a docked desktop workstation and a road warrior, a Pro might be a better option.

Form factor and design

Arguably, the MacBook Air’s greatest asset is its unique hardware design. At just 0.68 inches at its thickest point, and only 2.38 pounds for the 11.6-inch model, it’s a portable computer that truly redefines the meaning of the term. The aluminum unibody construction, and the LED-backlit 1366×768 screen also make it very easy on the eyes, as does the new backlit keyboard. I also found that the screen, while glossy, was less prone to glare than the glass screen on my older MacBook Pro — a definite plus if you’re thinking about using the computer outside at all.

Of all the benefits of its design, it’s the weight that many will most appreciate. When held in hand with the unibody MacBook Pro, the difference is startling. And in a backpack or shoulder bag, the weight it adds is virtually unnoticeable. The only downside to its design that I can see is the inability to easily upgrade system components like RAM or storage, something which DIY aficionados might want to consider before making a purchase.

Verdict

The new MacBook Air is the best Air yet, which is saying a lot after the impressive update it received last year. If you’re currently working with an older Pro notebook and wonder if the Air is a suitable replacement, the answer is probably yes. If you bought the Air last year and are wondering if this Air is worth an upgrade, consider that the processor powering these latest models is two generations newer, and it shows. Like the iPad and the iPhone, the MacBook Air sets the standard for its entire device category, and the latest upgrade is a worthwhile raising of that bar.

  1. Still waiting for mine to arrive, not to happy that because I selected the 2nd 11″ version with a DVI cable for my monitor Apple consider this a custom build so it won’t arrive till August 5th (I purchased this machine on Monday 25th July)

    Share
    1. niels marijn Friday, July 29, 2011

      Just received my 13″ i7 1,8Ghz 256Gb today and I am very impressed. Beats my 2009 3,06Ghz MacBook Pro 15″.

      Share
  2. Just got mine 11″ 4GB SM128C SSD and I L..O..V..E it!!!

    Share
  3. Darrell, thank you for the review. What about using the 11″ Air, fully tricked out as the one you have reviewed, with developer and sys admin tools? Its great to have the Geekbench metrics and nice that you (and many people such as yourself) have multiple web pages open, but how about for the developer crowd (who run tools such as Xcode or Eclipse, who want to install Java, who also make a lot of use of the command-line for sys admin requirements, maybe even remote access to another machine via VNC)? Equally important IMHO, what about eye fatigue when using the 11″ Air (or even the 13″ Air / Pro for that matter) when working for many contiguous hours in a row? What about handling of network traffic on the new Air? And what about, say, VOIP applications like Skype which is known to be processor intense because its of its VOIP and associated audio codecs. Have you tried the new Air with, say, one of the third party makers of USB modems that work on Verizon’s new LTE 4G data services? More please!

    Share
    1. Billy Newport Friday, July 29, 2011

      I’d buy a 13″ for development which I’ve done. The battery was the issue for me, I wanted more than 3 hours and the 13″ is a solid 5 I’d say.

      Share
  4. Great review,.. still doubting if I want to replace my 11″ 2010 model with a 13″ 2011 model, but I’m also looking into a new 11″ because I don’t want to buy another new http://jolioriginals.com sleeve and the 11″ is also really nice to take on the road. :)

    Share
  5. What a wonderful computer and perfect for my uses

    Share
  6. I’ve picked up the 11″ MBA fully loaded (4Gb, 256Gb SSD, 1.8 i7) and have no regrets. My 13″ MBA (2nd Gen) is now my wife’s daily use computer and our 17″ MBP (2010) is being considered for NAS like duties. Easily handles 20 web pages, Twitter app, Facebook app (Fluid), Mail, Aperture and iTunes.

    Share
  7. > plus if … using the computer outside at all.
    Seriously? The machine is viewable — actually usable –outdoors in daylight? In _sunlight_?

    Share
  8. Chen Shunkang Tuesday, August 2, 2011

    I found a lot of beautiful shoes,includingchristianlouboutin,namely
    red bottom shoes,they are really beautiful, especially Christian Louboutin Daffodile160mm. in a word,i am a louboutins fan,
    and i suggest you buy Christian Louboutin Daffodile 160mm
    to make you more sexy.

    Share
  9. The best computer I’ve ever bought. It installed Windows 7 in VMWare Fusion in under 5 minutes, and runs it faster virtualized than my 2010 MBP ran it in Boot Camp. Unbelievable.

    Share
  10. I just think a 11.6″ screen will get old after a while no matter what the resolution. Its really a expensive investment to get anything in storage and RAM. $1600 for a fast Netbook? If you offered this on the PC side you would get few takers.

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post