Sen. Al Franken may be after answers from Steve Jobs, but last year, Congressmen Edward J. Markey and Joe Barton asked similar questions and got an answer from Apple SVP and General Counsel Bruce Sewell. That letter answers some of Franken’s questions regarding iOS location info.


Sen. Al Franken (D-Minn.) may be after answers from Steve Jobs, but this isn’t the first time lawmakers have been curious about Apple’s use of location information. Last year, Congressmen Edward J. Markey (D-Mass.) and Joe Barton (R-Tex.) sent a letter to Jobs about similar issues and received a letter from Apple SVP and General Counsel Bruce Sewell. In the letter, Sewell provides answers to at least some of Franken’s new round of questions.

While Sewell doesn’t address the local, unencrypted storage of location information anywhere in his response to Markey and Barton, he does clearly outline Apple’s location data use policy and the methods the company uses to gather said data. So, at least partial answers to a good portion of Franken’s questions are already on record.

Sewell describes Apple’s reasoning behind collecting location data, which is “to enhance and improve the services we can offer to our customers,” and also with whom Apple shares the data. Those parties include only Apple’s application developer licensees (with whom Apple only shares the data once a user has given their explicit consent that it be allowed to do so), and Apple’s external mapping database partners, which are used for location services on older devices. Apple shares only “anonymous, non-identifying location information” with those partners in order to improve service.

Sen. Franken also asked about whether laptops collect location data. Sewell lists explicitly which devices collect location data, and the list includes “Mac computers running Snow Leopard and Windows or Mac computers running Safari 5.”

Sewell’s letter also explains how the data is generated and when. Wi-Fi access point, cell tower and GPS information are all used to determine location, and data from each is collected when apps approved to use said data are actively running. Anonymous data “may also be collected when an iPhone is using GPS to search for a cellular network,” writes Sewell.

As I mentioned, the letter does not address those questions Sen. Franken asked that specifically involve the local, unencrypted storage of location data. For instance, Franken asked “Why is this data not encrypted? What steps will Apple take to encrypt the data?” Apple also hasn’t specifically addressed the question of why consumers aren’t informed about local data storage, or asked for consent for that particular type of location information usage.

Turns out I was wrong when I wrote earlier that “there are no definite answers” to Franken’s questions. Just goes to show how quickly information can get lost or forgotten in the age of the Internet. You can read the letter from Sewell in full below.

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. Senator Franken should be concentrating of doing something about our trillion dollar deficits. The Mac community is perfectly capable of sorting this out without his meddling.

  2. Maybe the senator should also ask these questions to Google because Android devices also caches the same sort of information, see:


  3. Apple also collects data with every Mac repair via AST. Although it is unclear where this data goes, if it is stored, and exact clarification of use (possibly engineering metrics for hardware failure/software conflict issues). How’s that for a warranty!

  4. @ Mike…completely agree…its time to think about how to improve the economy, rather than things like this. :X

  5. System requirements Friday, April 22, 2011

    I see this news on Tv. I don’t think this is true..

  6. portable phones have had this ability pretty much since they came out. You just never knew. This is old unfortnate news. Call it progress.

  7. please can I get answer for question given by Penton in inquiring minds want to know case study?

Comments have been disabled for this post