Updated: Cisco said it plans to buy newScale, a software provider that allows more control and visibility inside a compute cloud, for an undisclosed sum. The deal highlights the rise in M&A activity among cloud vendors, as well as the need for more accountability in corporate cloud environments that’s occurring as the nature of enterprise computing shifts in response to trends that include cost containment and more agility. It may also signal Cisco’s attempts to do more deals in this space now that it has Lew Tucker, the former Sun Microsystems’ CTO & VP of cloud computing, as the leader of its own cloud efforts.
NewScale offers a self-service portal that lets business users provision their own resources, with the IT department’s policies already built into the experience (i.e., users only have the option of getting what they’re approved to get). As more companies use public or private clouds as development sandboxes, making sure people remember to stop paying for compute when a project is done or that they buy the compute levels appropriate for their department or job is important. This allows an IT department to control those things by setting policies in advance.
For Cisco, which offers servers for the cloud and is part of a partnership to provide modular building blocks for private clouds in conjunction with VMware and EMC, this buy falls in line with its focus on enterprise customers building out private clouds. It’s unclear what this buy means for rPath and Eucalyptus, which have joined up with newScale to create a software stack for private clouds called the NRE. I’ve asked for comment from the respective companies and will update the post when I get them. According to the Cisco FAQs about the proposed deal, newScale will continue to offer its products as part of Cisco and its sales and services team will join Cisco.
Cisco has been very active in the M&A market around its other lines of businesses, but it hasn’t made a lot of cloud buys. My colleague Derrick Harris has written that Cisco may not do that many deals (GigaOM Pro subscription required) preferring to build rather than buy. He writes:
Not every vendor is buying its way into the cloud game, though. Cisco famously built its own Unified Computing System server lineup, and has partnered with VMware and EMC to fill out the virtualization and storage components of the infrastructure stack. Thus far, its only cloud acquisitions have been on the services side (and continued networking purchases), but not operations or software. Don’t count on a big acquisition down the line (although I’ve heard some big names bandied about), but do count on a fair amount of continued innovation, especially with Lew Tucker on board.
NewScale represents a relatively small acquisition, but it does leave Cisco with an open infrastructure as a service strategy that could help change its image of a company that doesn’t do open source software. Assuming the Eucalyptus partnership remains intact, Cisco customers should have the choice to build the IaaS layers of their cloud stacks with the open-core Eucalyptus or, perhaps, with OpenStack. Cisco joined the OpenStack project in February.
Given Cisco’s enterprise focus, it’s likely future deals will involve smaller service offerings that can help make Cisco’s hardware shine, although as low-cost competitors enter its markets, perhaps it should be thinking of pulling an IBM and refocusing its efforts gradually toward a services and software strategy as hardware margins come under pressure. It hasn’t done too well in the consumer market with a software strategy, but maybe the enterprise cloud offers it a new chance.
Update: Jake Sorofman, CMO at rPath, didn’t answer our questions about what this acquisition means for the NRE partnership, but said rPath remains committed to it and expects to see further M&A in the self-service IT delivery sector. From the statement:
rPath is committed to the NRE Alliance as the reference architecture for the enterprise cloud and a best-in-class example of the enterprise cloud tool chain, but we’ll continue to be open and agnostic to wherever this same pattern repeats. For example, in the coming days rPath will announce support for VMware vCloud Director and OpenStack, extending the self-service/automation/elasticity pattern to yet another cloud ecosystem.


Let’s see if Cisco made a right decision to purchase NewScale.This strategy may be a good chance for Cisco. It’s about time that Cisco become active in cloud buys.
Hi Stacey,
Cisco VP Inder Singh named in insider trading scandal:
An opening trial slide (page 5) delivered in court during the trial of Raj Rajaratnam (the largest crackdown on hedge-fund insider trading in U.S. history according to Business Week), names Cisco Vice President – Inder Singh as an alleged conspirator who provided inside information about Cisco’s potential acquisition of EMC.
The opening trial slide states that Raj Rajaratnam is alleged to have conspired to obtain inside information from Cisco Vice President – Inder Singh about Cisco’s potential acquisition of EMC in July and August 2008. Interestingly, according to Singh’s biography, Singh joined Cisco in July 2008 which is confirmed by a July 18, 2008 report that appeared in Light Reading.
At the time of the alleged conspiracy, Singh was reporting to the highly respected Manny Rivelo (who earned CCIE #1305), Rivelo at the time was senior vice president of operations for the Cisco Development Council and was one of its nine members.
Note: Curiously as shown in the trial slide, yet another alleged insider trading conspirator is named Surya Panditi.
Cisco announced on May 20, 2010 that it was acquiring CoreOptics and in that news release, Surya Panditi – Cisco vice president and general manager of Cisco’s Service Provider Access and Transport Technology Group is quoted.
I mean, is it possible that Cisco had 2 of its Vice Presidents leaking inside information about future Cisco acquisitions?
Both Cisco Vice Presidents Inder Singh and Surya Panditi appear on a list of possible witnesses during the Raj Rajaratnam insider trading trial.
Another opening trial slide states that Raj Rajaratnam is alleged to have conspired to obtain material, nonpublic information about Cisco’s acquisition of Starent Networks before it was announced on October 13, 2009. According to a March 21, 2011 Financial Times report:
“Mr. Smith speculated to the government that Mr. Rajaratnam’s source may have been a Cisco employee who used to work as an analyst with Prudential.”
Perhaps revealingly, Cisco Vice President – Inder Singh’s biography states that he was previously employed by Prudential Securities.
Note: Cisco has not responded to a request to confirm whether its 2 Vice Presidents – Inder Singh and Surya Panditi are currently employed by Cisco Systems.
Sincerely,
Brad Reese