4 Comments

Summary:

Google this morning asked a court to dismiss Oracle’s patent suit alleging the Android operating system violates Oracle’s newly acquired patents and copyrights for Java. Google asserts it has not violated any of the alleged patents, which Oracle obtained after it bought Sun Microsystems.

383476178_8fe0f5e767_z1

Google this morning asked a court to dismiss Oracle’s patent suit alleging the Android operating system violates Oracle’s newly acquired patents and copyrights for Java.

In an answer filed in U.S. District Court in Northern California, Google asserted that Google and its Android partners have not violated any of the seven alleged patents related to Java, which Oracle obtained after it bought Sun Microsystems. Google said the patents in question have been dedicated to public use and Android, while it utilizes Java, was created independently and uses its own Dalvik virtual machine.

Google asked that the patents be declared invalid. A hearing has been set for Nov. 18 to evaluate Google’s request to dismiss the copyright claim.

“It’s disappointing that after years of supporting open source, Oracle turned around to attack not just Android, but the entire open source Java community with vague software patent claims,” a Google spokesperson  said in an email statement.

The case is going to be an important test for Android in particular and open-source software in general. At issue is whether Android is distinct from Java and whether other open-source projects written with Java will be affected as well.

Android has been touted as a free platform that’s open to development by any member of the Open Handset Alliance. Google asserts that its open-source approach to Android has helped fuel its success to the point that it is being activated on 200,000 phones daily. That success may in fact be why Oracle has attacked Android. Mobile is where the heat is in technology today and Oracle would like a piece of the action, it seems. Many have suggested that Oracle was sold on the purchase of Sun partly by the case it could mount against Google for its implementation of Android.

The question of how free Android is becoming an open debate. Microsoft sued Motorola last week over its use of Android, claiming patent infringement, and Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer recently disputed the notion that Android is free because of patent fees associated with its use. HTC also previously signed a patent licensing deal with Microsoft for its use of Android.

In its reply, Google tries to point out the hypocrisy of Oracle, saying the software company actually pushed for broader use of Java without restrictions in 2007. In February 2009, Oracle again pushed Sun to full open-source Java and not use its position to restrict Java implementations. That was all, of course, before Oracle bought Sun and Java.

Related content from GigaOM Pro (sub req’d):

  1. Lucian Armasu Tuesday, October 5, 2010

    The nerve on Oracle is unbelievable.

    Share
  2. Acer Aspire 7730ZG-343G16Mn, portable 17 “

    The Acer Aspire 7730ZG-343G16Mn has a dual processor Core T3400 (2.16 GHz), 3 GB DDR2 667 MHz memory, a hard disk drive SATA 160 GB 5400 rpm, a Geforce 9300M GS 512 MB dedicated 2 GB TurboCache, a 17-inch WXGA + CrystalBrite (1440 × 900), a 0.3 megapixel webcam with microphone Crystal Eye, a double layer DVD burner, a card reader 5 in 1, a keypad, a 2.1 sound system compatible Dolby Home Theater and port Wi-Fi a / b / g / n, HDMI (HDCP), ExpressCard54, VGA, Infrared, Microphone, Headphone / SPDIF, Modem RJ-11 Gigabit Ethernet and USB 2.0 (x4 including one eSATA) Windows Vista Home Premium.

    It weighs 4.1 kg, measures 402 × 297×41-43.9 mm and comes with integrated office Works 8.5.

    The Acer Aspire 7730ZG-343G16Mn laptop is designed for desktop use. He enjoys a comfortable size screen and full connectivity with particular support for Wi-Fi 802.11 n, more efficient if all of your network supports this standard, but also HDMI and eSATA ports.

    The Acer Aspire 7730ZG-343G16Mn has a configuration similar to that of its competitors, however, some models have a greater storage capacity.

    Share
  3. Indeed, Java’s been in use by tons of companies for such a long time and now out of blue its restricted by Oracle’s patents? Smells like someone just wants to remind of themselves.

    Share
  4. [...] the patents were dedicated to public use and furthermore, Google’s implementation of Java was built independently and uses its own Dalvik virtual machine. Oracle countered with an amended complaint last month alleging that Google directly copied [...]

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post