A survey published by the National Academy of Sciences earlier this week highlighted the fact that going solar isn’t high on the list of energy saving measures that consumers can take. In fact, more survey respondents said they would buy energy efficient lights, appliances and cars or “sleep more” if they had to choose a single most effective action they could take to conserve energy.
The researchers of the study concluded that cost is a big stumbling block to adopting energy efficient technologies because their subjects cited curtailing current energy consumption, like turning off the lights and hopping on public transit, as the top choices over buying new greener tech.
Which brings us to the topic of: just how expensive are solar electric systems these days and how to do you compare them? I spoke with Molly Sterkel, program manager for the California Solar Initiative, to get some answers. California is the largest solar state in the country, thanks in part to the CSI incentive that gives rebates for installing smaller solar energy system owners (less than 30-kilowatts). Owners of systems 30-kilowatt or larger get payments on the electricity produced. Most homeowners install systems less than 10KW.
As it turns out, there is a lot of pricing information floating around that isn’t easily comparable. Over the past two years, solar panel manufacturers and their component suppliers have reported a steep drop in the costs of materials (up to 50 percent) along with the prices for which they sell their equipment. Back in May, Bloomberg Energy Finance’s Jenny Chase told me that major crystalline silicon solar panel makers were selling their goods at EUR 1.7 ($2.16) per watt and large solar power projects were being built at EU 2.7 ($3.43) per watt. In December 2008, the market research firm said the manufacturers were selling silicon-based panels at around $4 per watt.
But the lower costs and prices for manufacturers tend to translate into more savings for whole-sale purchases for large, megawatt-size projects. Consumers will pay more because they buy from retailers (installers), and the size of a typical system hovers from 3KW to 5KW.
Retail prices haven’t seen a dramatic fall. Check out this helpful retail price index by Solarbuzz for solar panels of all flavors in the U.S. and Europe. In the U.S., the retail prices have fallen almost 14 percent from $4.84 per watt in January 2009 to $4.17 per watt this month (excluding sales taxes), if you buy only one panel from a dealer.
A solar energy system is made up more than just solar panels; it comes with racks and other parts, and you have to consider the labor cost as well. Solar panels typically make up about 50 percent of the cost of installing a system. The homepage of Go Solar California, the umbrella term for the state’s solar programs, showed that the average price for a solar energy system at less than 10KW is $9.21 per watt. Sterkel pointed out that the number is an average of all the small systems installed over time, and it’s not adjusted for inflation.
So a better set of numbers would come from the CSI progress report posted in July this year, she said. Figure 9 of the report showed how much a buyer would pay for solar energy systems of less than 10KW, and the graph showed a gradual decline, from $10.04 per watt in the first quarter of 2007 to $8.49 per watt in the fourth quarter of 2009. That’s roughly a 15 percent drop. And it’s about an 8 percent cut from the beginning of 2008 to the end of 2009.
Sterkel pointed out that the financing options available to consumers, such as leases or power purchase agreements, have likely countered the effect of a big drop in solar panel prices. In a power-purchase agreement, homeowners pay for the solar electricity generated from the system on their rooftop, but the system is owned by their installer or an investor who financed the installation.
“It’s in our data that third-party systems cost more on average than” systems owned directly by consumers, Sterkel said. “People need to be aware that that’s what goes into a system’s cost, if financing is part of the system.”
One tricky thing about reading the CSI Progress Report chart is that the 10KW system size comes from a formula set by the California Energy Commission, and it’s in AC (alternating current). The same metric is used throughout the report. Solar panel manufacturers, on the other hand, typically discuss their prices in DC (direct current) because that’s the rating they use to describe the generation capacity of their panels. Solar panels are connected to one or more inverters in order to convert the DC to AC for feeding the grid, and the energy loss during the conversion means the AC number is lower. As a result, the cost-per-watt for a system rated in AC would be higher than in DC.
So, yes, it takes some math to get a better comparison of costs. But now you know where and what to look for. The price of a system depends mostly on its size, the brand of solar panels and other parts, as well as the local labor cost. Sterkel said consumers should always get bids from three contractors in order to do a good price comparison. According to this CSI page, California consumers are likely see an average price of around $8.50 per watt. That means about $34,000 for a 4KW system, the average size of a residential system.
For more research on solar check out GigaOM Pro (subscription required):