17 Comments

Summary:

There’s a movement underfoot. A movement to break free of cable provider’s high costs and poor service. A movement to time- and device-shift. A movement to watch what we want, where we want, when we want. So let’s take a look at Hulu Plus and Netflix.

hulu_netflix_thumb

There’s a movement underfoot. A movement to break free of cable providers’ high costs and poor service. A movement to time- and device-shift. A movement to watch what we want, where we want, when we want. For me, personally, there’s no way I can rid myself of my cable bill. My wife is the chief TV watcher in the family who also pays the bills, so, well, we’re getting cable. However, were I to be a single guy, I’d not pay for cable; I just can’t justify the money. Plus, I tend to get wind of the cool TV show to watch three years after it debuted, leaving me to play catch-up. Usually, that’s in the form of an expensive DVD set or iTunes purchase. I am also usually just as comfortable watching something in my office, or in bed on the iPad.

This has made me take a serious look at Hulu Plus and Netflix.

The CliffsNotes version of this article: if you’re a movie person, get Netflix, If you’re a TV person, get Hulu Plus. The reason: Hulu’s movie selection is completely abysmal, whereas Hulu Plus is good for current-run TV shows.

Now, lets look at the apps. Our sister site NewTeeVee has a write-up covering the availability of shows here, so I’m not going to subject you to a large table in this post.

Hulu Plus ($9.99 per month)

There’s been a lot of bloviating about the short ads you’re forced to watch, even on the paid version of Hulu. They are noticeable, with an announcer’s voice that frequently grated on me. While I can kinda see the point, for me, it’s not a big deal; my cable-only channels subject me to longer, more frequent commercial interruptions. The ads on Hulu Plus aren’t a deal-breaker for me, but they are a point against the service.

What’s more of a bother to me is how limited the mobile offerings are. Not all Hulu shows are available for viewing on the iPad or iPhone. Stargate SG-1 is available in its entirety on the web; not at all on mobile (according to Netflix, this will be available for streaming August 15, so we’ll see if it’ll be on Hulu Plus then). However, Hulu Plus’s offering are deeper — where the free version might only have three shows of a season, the Hulu Plus version is more likely to have the full season. I did find Hulu was more likely to have older TV shows, as full seasons of Hill Street Blues and the A-Team are available (and let me say, the A-Team does not hold up well after all these years). Hulu’s movie selection is very weak — no mainstream movies to be found.

The app performs well. You can manage your queue, although, oddly, you can’t add a full season in one press. Because Hulu’s service is entirely streaming, I found the app a little easier to navigate than the Netflix app. However, in a curious technical decision, the Hulu Plus app doesn’t support the VGA output cable. Since I don’t have a 3G iPad, Hulu was the only one I was able to test over a cellular connection, and the results were fair, but from a small sample set: On the train to work, where AT&T coverage is spotty, the video was pixellated; at home with a better signal, it worked fine. One annoying feature in the Hulu Plus app is every time I launched it, it reminded me I was watching a video and did I want to continue watching it?

Netflix ($8.99 per month)

Comparing Hulu to Netflix is a lot like comparing iBookstore to Amazon’s Kindle store; like Amazon, Netflix has the benefit of a large library. As with Hulu, there are shows only available on Netflix — I could not find Nip/Tuck, Weeds, and Thirtysomething on Hulu; the complete offerings are only on Netflix. It also bears repeating for people who skipped my intro bit that Netflix is the place for you to go if you’re into movies.

I found the Netflix app to be a little sluggish. The video playing was usually fine, but I encountered a lot of slowness browsing the libraries. It’s also hard to pull down the Genres list — postings at the bottom were cut off. In addition, it’s impossible to just search by the titles available for streaming. Unlike the Hulu app, Netflix actually uses the VGA cable.

Final Thoughts

I was hoping that, at least for TV shows, one service would be a home run. Sadly, that’s not the case. While I found more TV shows on Netflix than Hulu that I enjoyed, I could convince myself to pay for Hulu for a few months to re-watch Hill Street Blues as well as start House and Law and Order. I’d be well ahead of the DVD costs. Hulu also earns points for current shows.

Given the economics, it’s not a requirement for an either-or service, For less than $20 a month, you can have access to a great library of movies and TV shows. The ads on Hulu Plus are a bummer. You get no commercials and larger selection (including movies, on Netflix) but Hulu Plus also lets you stay current on your shows. If you’re just staying current,  and not digging through a backlist, there’s little reason to sign up for Hulu Plus.

Looking Ahead: My Wishlist

Both these apps are fantastic, but operate under the necessity of an Internet connection, which means you’re screwed if you’re on a plane or in a bad cell area without Wi-Fi. What I’d love is for these apps to have the ability to also download movies into their device library for off-line viewing. I’m not sure how the licensing or logistics would work, but I hope that’s in their plans.

Which app do you prefer, and why?

Related GigaOM Pro Research: Three Reasons Hulu Plus is No Threat to Netflix

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. Hi Mark,
    I keep waiting for the day that I can cancel my cable and still feel like I am not missing anything, but I just can’t yet.

    Personally I pay for Netflix and use free Hulu. When I see key networks (like CBS) joining on either of these offering the latest shows, I would probably cancel my cable in a heartbeat.

    I love how there is more online content showing up from non major networks like Revision 3 and TWiT that supplement the online offerings, but I can’t get my sitcoms and hold them on a DVR to plunge through the latest season on one lazy weekend through the web.

    I also wanted to point out the Blockbuster app that Verizon offers. In that app they allow you to download content in case you don’t have internet connection. Too bad it is only for Verizon right now. I really wanted to try it out.

  2. Until Hulu Plus gets the same shows on the mobile devices that they have on their web pages I can’t see paying for it. Every current show that I wanted to be able to catch is either from USA or SyFy and none of them are on the mobile app to stream. I’m giving them until the end of my first month to see if it gets fixed but if it doesn’t then I’m keeping the DVR and losing Hulu Plus.

    1. I’m with you. I love Hulu, but Hulu Plus has so little content compared to the regular site, it’s just not worth it yet.

  3. Just cancelled my Netflix trial because of the lack of streamable content in my interest area, which is pretty much anything. The problem was that while Netflix has all the content I am interested in, 90+ % of it was only on DVD, and with the iPad, Wii, and a media center in my future, it just was not giving me what I wanted.

    I assumed, when I joined, that everything would be available to stream at any time. Not so, which was a huge disappointment.

  4. I read somewhere that Netflix consideres Hulu Plus to be a competitor and plans on beefing up their offerings of current tv-shows. Great for me, since I’m already paying for Netflix and because as much as I love Hulu on my MacBook, I fail to see why I’d pay $10 a month just to say I have it on my iPhone. Netflix works on way more devices at no extra charge.

  5. Netflix is the way to go for movies been saying that forever …Hulu is good for T.V shows and that is it. I have Netflix works perfect for both I think. I have my Lost series on it.

    1. Except that the selection of streamable movies are limited. You cannot, for example, get Bond or Startrek movies, but you can get some Disney.

  6. Richard Velez Monday, August 9, 2010

    I’ve cancelled the cable subscription about 2 years ago. Currently receiving over the air signals for normal tv channel in my area. I also have Netflix at the $8.99 1 DVD out plus unlimited streaming and LOVE IT! Also watch hulu.com for tv shows that I’ve missed or want to see again.

    All together, without having cable, I have saved over $2000 in two years. Money is happy in my pockets.

  7. A movement is afoot… Or under way… But not underfoot!! Sorry, I just had to get that out there…

    1. hah, oops.

  8. I have NetFlix streaming on my iPad, Powerbook and PS3 with high definition videos. I have trail version of Hulu on my iPad. I may upgrade this to Hulu Plus if my wife let go the cable and watch Hulu Plus on Powerbook or PS3 and ofcourse I can watch the same on my iPad.

    Just waiting for the right time to convince her….make a wise move to save some Dollars!!!

  9. Ah, but Hulu isn’t available via Roku. This presents a problem; if Google TV uses specific hardware and Hulu uses other hardware, and Netflix is only available on different hardware and. . . Well, you get the picture. Trading “cable providers’ high costs and poor service” for the need to purchase, connect, maintain and upgrade various set-top boxes and whatever piece of hardware is required – well, that’s just not a trade-off that makes sense.

    Hulu needs to make peace with Roku and X-Box and Wii and several of the other existing DVD Blu-Ray players that connect to the Internet. Until that time, I don’t expect to see Hulu Plus available in my home.

  10. Hulu = Up to Date TV Shows
    Netflix = Lots o’ Movies.

    Netflix is not good for TV shows as it doesn’t have latest episodes so I don’t think there is much competition as they both have different benefits.

Comments have been disabled for this post