24 Comments

Summary:

Apple’s iconic iPod is credited for reviving the company and helping it dominate consumer mind share over the past decade, but of my greatest fears has started to come true where analysts are now throwing the notion out there that the iPod is dead or dying.

Apple’s iconic iPod digital music player is credited for reviving the company and helping the it dominate consumer mind share and spending over the past decade. It still amazes me when I think about all of the MP3 players and companies who failed and the music stores that are now on life support and how badly Apple has hurt Sony, Microsoft and other companies who bet millions on defeating the iPod. One of my greatest fears has started to come true where analysts are now throwing the notion out there that the iPod is dead or dying.

We all knew this was coming when analysts first asked that same question upon the introduction of iPhone then iPad but now we’re at a point where it’s clear that the iPod isn’t key to Apple’s success in earnings and shareholders don’t have to worry about consumers growing tired of the iPod or music in general (as if that’s ever going to happen). The iPhone, iPad and Mac are the largest legs of Apple’s business and iPod is just iPod.

Of course, Apple has sold hundreds of millions of iPods and a solid 50 percent of its stock value as it skyrocketed from 2004-2008 is due to the iPod, but its impact on Apple’s bottom line is dropping with every new iPhone release. I was enthralled in a piece featured on AppleInsider written by Andy Zaky. The piece took a logical and very up front look at Apple’s iPod segment in how it relates to the market, Apple’s bottom line and raw sales and opened my eyes to just how well the nine year old music player is holding up.

Before I review a bit of the findings in Andy’s research, I’d like to point out that Apple is approaching a 10 year dominance in a huge market with one product line. Yes, I know the iPod has seen many revisions and form factors but it’s digital music and Apple still maintains 70 percent market share for MP3 players. That’s incredible when you think of the thousands of competitors and dozens of music stores aimed directly at Apple and let’s hope the same fate is in store for iPhone. If you ever had an argument whether a closed system is good for the consumer, look no further than iPod’s success.

Health of the iPod and Apple’s bottom line

Analysts who measure Apple’s stock value based on trends, market health, future products and current sales will look at this figure when calling the death of iPod:

This chart shows the iPod’s decline in percentage of Apple’s revenue has dropped from 55 percent during 2005′s Winter sales to 24 percent upon the introduction of the first iPhone. Naturally, analysts were freaking out a bit and today’s 8.6 percent for a product that once made up for half of their revenue is a reason to be quite worried. Prior to the iPhone 3G’s release in 2008, I did see a few reports that spurred a sharp decline in AAPL that year, mostly because the iPod was selling to a saturated market where everyone that wanted one already had one and features like an FM receiver weren’t enough for most users to upgrade.

Of course, anyone reading this blog knows that the iPhone has iPod built right in and, of the iPods sold, the App Store enabled iPod touch completely dominates sales compared to the nano, shuffle or classic models. Apple sells an iPod every time you buy an iPhone, but it’s clear that the iPod isn’t the golden egg for Apple any more, but have people stopped buying iPods? Is the iPod dead? This data proves otherwise.

Compared to 2006 numbers, when the iPod was nearly half of Apple’s quarterly profit, iPod sales have actually risen from 8.5 million units per quarter (non-holiday) to an average of 10 million per quarter. This is huge and over half of iPod sales in the past year (based on rumors and Apple Store public iPod sales chart review), the iPod touch makes up for a majority of iPod sales. The iPod is stronger than it was in 2006, which was a year before the iPhone came out. The iPod isn’t dead or dying; it’s stronger than ever.

Why does it feel like the iPod is dead?

I may have a bit of bias here, but in big cities, the iPod is a device you simply don’t see anymore. Instead, you see one or two iPods for every 10 iPhones or iPads. The reason is that the iPod is a part of our touch devices and we don’t need the extra device in our bag or pocket.

Another fact is that, other than Apple’s yearly iPod event (that happens every September like clockwork), Apple doesn’t push the iPod at every keynote like it did before the iPhone. Now, the App Store, iPhone and iPad get all of the attention, and rightly so. You may pay $199 for an iPhone 4, but that’s after carrier subsidy. In fact, AT&T (s att0 pays the rest of the bill, which to Apple is between $499 and $699 for every iPhone sold for a product that costs less than $200 in parts to build, so profits of the iPhone are significantly higher than the sale of an iPod nano, and paired with Apple’s 30 percent cut of the sales of every app you buy for the iPhone and it’s obvious which device is more profitable.

It’s too early to call the death of iPod. Its impact on Apple’s earnings may get smaller, especially if the iPad sales continue to rise and Apple’s next TV appliance is the killer iOS based device that we’re all hoping for, but 10 million units a quarter is not small potatoes and iPod continues to do well for the foreseeable future. That shrinking percentage of iPod’s impact on Apple’s sales is only because the amount of money Apple is making from its other segments is growing at an astronomical rate as seen here:

This was mostly a summary of the data Andy reviewed over at AppleInsider. Both parts one and two are worth a read for anyone that follows Apple closely and enjoys data that backs up the usual speculation.

Do you still own an iPod? Do you also have an iPhone and do you use both on a daily basis?

  1. I have both an iPhone 3G (I know, behind the times) and an iPod Nano. I use both frequently. With the iPhone battery as notoriously short as it is, I find that having the iPod for music is a wonderful solution to getting the phone through the day without a recharge.

    Share
  2. I have an iPhone 4, iPad and iPod classic. My iPod recently died and I am actually getting ready to buy a new one. I buy the 16gig iPhone to save money and have created a special “iPhone + iPad” playlist of my favorite music and my new finds. It’s around 200+ songs, but my iPod classic has over 5,000 songs. I love having all my songs for a spur of the moment request while driving with friends. I am waiting till spetembet for the new iPod classic and hopefully they won’t kill it, because I LOVE mine and use it every day.

    Share
  3. I have an iPod touch 3G 64GB. I love it, and I don’t seem to be affected by the short battery life issues with iOS 4 so many people complain about. It runs just about anything you throw at it like a dream, but the speaker needs…help. Anyway, an awesome device for people like me that can afford neither an iPhone data plan nor an unsubsidized iPhone.

    Share
  4. I’ll only own an iPod as long as it takes to sell the free one that comes with my new Mac. Summer is a great time to buy a Mac if you have a university ID.

    Share
  5. I use an iPod classic in the car (connected with Ford Sync for hands free control). I’ll probably never give it up. Plenty of space, and small enough to take on a bike ride or whatever.

    Share
  6. i have both and use them both almost every day. i leave my ipod hooked up in the car all the time because if i don’t, i either forget to bring my iphone out of the car with me when i leave the car or i forget to hook it up when i get in so i drive around forever before i realize i have no music.

    Share
  7. I have a 30gb video iPod that is 4.5yrs old now and still rockin’ & a 32gb iPhone 3Gs. Needless to say I have plenty of gigs for music (no pun intended). I use the iPod primarily in my truck, which has an auxiliary input. Using my iPhone in the truck means taking off my case in order to plug it in. Then when I get out, I have to put it back on. If I receive a call I have to unplug it to talk. Obviously, it makes much more sense to use my iPod in the car. Props to Apple quality in the iPod. Battery life is the only thing that is noticeably aging.

    Share
  8. I have an Ipod touch 3rd Gen and I use it on a daily basis…best product I’ve ever bought!

    Share
  9. I have an iPhone 3Gs and an iPod touch. Many people have asked me why I still own a iPod since an iPhone serves just as well. At first I thought about selling my iPod before i would get my iPhone, but then I began to realize. If I have an iPod I wouldn’t have use my iPhone while jogging or training in the gym, due to the risk of dropping it as an example. This way I know I won’t put my iPhone in danger although I did drop it once while I was playing a song with my earplugs in. Since then I never ever thought about using it as an music player because of the wire sticking out. So for me its just al okay to use an iPod and iPhone at the same time.

    Share
  10. the iPod won’t die for me until the iPhone has enough capacity to replace it completely. I actually look forward to this day, but mostly because I want to carry less gadgets – not because I want the iPod to die off.

    Share
  11. I have 2 iPhones, an iPod Touch, 2 iPod Nanos, and an iPod Classic. I rarely use any of them for music, simply because for music these devices feel primitive and antiquated. I purchased a Zune HD when it was released, and for music it is leaps and bounds better then Apple’s devices. I know Steve Jobs and Apple believe that people do not care about music as anything other than disposable entertainment, but for those of us who appreciate music as art and regard musicians as artists, the Zune HD is a wonderful device. Yes, the Zune HD has its shortcomings, but I hope Microsoft will continue to enhance the OS and that they won’t try to turn it into something like the iPhone/iPod Touch where the focus is on games and apps. I want a device that gives me access to information about the music I listen to and that helps me explore and find new music. The products from Apple do not do any of this. R.I.P. iPod.

    Share
  12. I use a 2G iPod Touch 32Gb every single day for everything from gaming to emails to watching videos streamed from my Mac. Having a work phone for calls/texts, I don’t need the extra functionality. Besides, there’s something enjoyable about knowing that my game or video won’t be interrupted by a call half way through! I’m really hoping for a new form factor this September, preferably with more storage and a camera. Evernote is screaming out for it!

    I’ve also got an iPod Nano “Fatty”, which has proven awesome for running with. The form factor is perfect.

    Share
  13. Two years ago, I had an iPod that I used when I worked out at the gym. At that time, I just bought my iPhone 3G. My iPod got stolen and since then, never really had a need to buy another iPod. I need to have my iPhone4 with me at all times because of work reasons, so it does not make sense to carry devices, when my iPhone4 kills two birds with one stolen.

    Share
    1. Adam Jackson Tuesday, July 13, 2010

      Haha. I see what you did there.

      Share
  14. It is time for everyone to upgrade their iPod for the one with the bigger Gee Bees !!!
    Listen to me now and believe me later.

    Share
  15. I have an iPod Classic 160gb, and two 3rd generation iPod 40gb’s, plus an iPhone 3G. I use iTunes and beaTunes to manage an enormous music collection of over 10,000 full CDs, vinyl rips and thousands of MP3 mixes by creating extensive lists and manually syncing on the devices (important, since auto sync can easily remove songs unintentionally). beaTunes adds title and art tagging as well as BPM and color coding which makes it easy to create mixes for any occasion. Thanks to the lyrics tab in iTunes, I can import and maintain notes above and beyond the tagging metadata.

    All the ipods/iphones travel with me in my car which has a Sony CD/mp3 stereo hybrid to iPod connector, USB AND an aux stereo in which provides me access to at least 232gb of music and video choices at the touch of a button. ALL without having to install one of those retarded in-car computers. There isn’t any other computer-based music system that comes close, short of hooking up your laptop.

    On the hunt for a 5th gen 80gb iPod that uses the high-end Wolfson DAC chip that I will get modded by Red Wine Audio for lossless playback.

    Share
  16. I still use my 2nd generation iPod nano. it works just fine but the only downside is that it is only 8 gigs.

    Share
  17. “but in big cities, the iPod is a device you simply don’t see anymore. Instead, you see one or two iPods for every 10 iPhones or iPads”

    Umm I was just in San Fran/San Jose for two weeks and I saw the reverse actually. In fact in the two weeks I was there I saw only one iPad. I saw netbooks everywhere, especially on the 4 planes I took and in the airports. iPods where everwhere as well. I did see a lot of iPhones, but no more than the generic, multi colored texting based phones I saw teenagers texting on. I went to the movies over the weekend while I was there and every female kid between 8-18 had a non-iPhone, phone, constantly texting, like they had to survive.

    Share
    1. Hamranhansenhansen Friday, July 16, 2010

      That is not at all my San Francisco experience, which is iPhones everywhere. Maybe you were in tourist spots. Those were Texans you were looking at. I live here and the whole of Northern California is lousy with iPhones. But iPod was also very popular here even in 2001, when it was Mac-only. You expect to see iPods at airports and gyms, where people are buttoning down for a long flight or workout with no phone service. But try a commuter train or downtown at lunch time … it is ridiculous.

      Share
  18. I have such an eclectic taste in music that I like to take my entire collection with me everywhere. Until the iPhone has a capacity to suit my needs, I will still have to carry my iPod classic 160gb. In fact, I don’t even have music on my phone right now. There are also safety concerns, at least for me, in trying to navigate a touch music device while driving. I guess I could get a mount for it but it still doesn’t seem all that safe and the voice rec isn’t that great. Call me old school I guess.

    Share
  19. I’ve had an 8G iTouch for almost 3 years, I guess. I became a Mac guy in 2007 with my first MBook, then added the Touch shortly after. I missed getting into the iPhone splurge here in Canada because my BBerry contract had just been renewed. I still use the Touch extensively for tunes and podcasts. It’s a pain not having Wifi everywhere, of course. The BBerry takes over at that point. I’m not sure what I’ll do in 2 years when the BBerry contract’s up. The furor over the iPhone’s a bit silly. People always jumping on the next best thing. I’m not a trender. More than likely, I’ll get an iPhone, which leaves the Touch where? Interesting dilemma.

    Share
  20. It all depends on what you use each device for, and how you use it. I own both the iPhone 3G and the iPod Classic (160gb). I’m a serious music listener. I have an external amplifier for my iPod as well as high-end headphones. When I’m in the mood for serious listening and I’m not worried about what I’m carrying, I’ll certainly break out the iPod. When I’m commuting to work and don’t want to carry too many devices or think about taking my headphones on and off I’ll just use my iPhone as an all purpose device. If I had to choose one or the other I would obviously choose the iPhone because it can do it all; but I am glad that I do have my iPod as an alternate listening device. I consider it the superior device of the two when it comes to music playback, if only because I’ve made it to be so (higher bit rate music, external amp, etc).

    Share
  21. Hi guys. Just bought my Iphone 4g and now looking for the microsim adapter. I’ve heard http://www.gomicrosim.com has good price and quality and is based in UK. What do you think, is it worth buing one?

    Share
  22. i bught my ipod 2yrs ago.now it wont take a charge.what can i do.

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post