13 Comments

Summary:

LapDock and Clamcase look like they both had the same idea at the same time: convert the iPad into a netbook/slate hybrid, and get the best of both worlds. The idea is genius, and the execution, from what we can see so far, looks great.

lapdock_thumb
iPad LapDock Prototype

iPad LapDock Prototype

LapDock and Clamcase look like they both had the same idea at the same time: convert the iPad into a netbook/slate hybrid, and get the best of both worlds. The idea is genius, and the execution, from what we can see so far, looks great, but are the two products trying to fit a round peg in a square hole?

Two things come to mind when looking at the these cases: one, the iPad is all about the touch interface, and two, bluetooth keyboard support is not fully baked yet. After using the iPad for a couple of weeks, the conclusion I come to is that hardware keyboard support was an afterthought. Many of the normal features of a keyboard do not work, and the bluetooth keyboard is missing a few of the special keys that the Apple keyboard dock has. It’s hard to say, without using the case, if it will turn out to be awkward, if the iPad will be easy to pop out of the case, if the iPad’s screen will be protected from the keys on the keyboard when the case is closed, or how heavy the case will be. Both the LapDock and Clamcase seem to want to shoehorn the new paradigm of the touch computer interface into the old familiar one.

That’s not necessarily a bad thing. We are at the beginning of the wave of new world devices, a wave that has not nearly begun to crest yet. The keyboard has been used as an input device for decades, so finding a middle ground between the new world of touch screens and the old world of the touch typist is a reasonable objective. Apple has made a similar admission by including support for hardware keyboards in iPhone OS 4.

The real test of any new product is answering the question “What problem does this solve?” For me, the answer is simple, if I had the Clamcase now, I would have typed out this article sitting on the couch with my iPad in my lap, instead of at the table.

Related GigaOM Pro Research: Is The Age of the Web Tablet Finally Upon Us?

You're subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

Related stories

  1. Frankly, I think these cases miss the point of the device really. It’s not supposed to be a netbook, or else Apple would have just made it exactly this product.

    I think if you are looking for a highly portable laptop, a MB or MBA may be much options than trying to turn your iPad into a laptop. Using the iPad for what it is perfect at (lounging back and computing rather than hunched forward and computing) seems to be a better use than trying to make it into something it is not.

    Share
  2. These sorts of “products” come from the clueless marketing minds who figure that the leading marathon runner will have “twice the appeal if we break both his legs so he can compete in the wheelchair category.”

    Share
  3. These cases are an interesting concept, at the very least. As you say, time will determine how useful they are. What I think is a more interesting concept, and I’d like to see if any peripheral manufacturers are up to the challenge, is if someone were to create an iPhone case that features a slide-out horizontel thumbboard, similar to some other touchscreen smartphones (notably a few Android models). If Bluetooth keyboard support is in fact going to be available on iPhones as well via OS 4, then at the very least I could see a small niche market who would be interested in this idea.

    Share
  4. Try also our leather cases – http://aligata.com/ . Genuine, bovine leather, natural grain. (I work for Aligata).

    Share
  5. I don’t have a problem with the concept of adding a keyboard to the iPad, but I don’t think this is a very creative way to do it…..

    Why can’t someone make a case similar to Apple’s iPad case that has a built-in fabric or thin rubberized flexible keyboard that slides out of the side of it? They could run it on a couple button-cell type batteries, to keep the bulk down.

    Share
  6. Well, I like the Clamcase. LapDock just turns the iPad into a touchscreen netbook, while Clamcase lets people use the iPad as in a normal case, there’s simply also a keyboard for when you need it. It’s a pretty cool way to have the keyboard always with you, and it makes it possible to do heavier word processing while on the go, unlike the Bluetooth keyboard which was designed for a desktop Mac. And when you’re done writing, fold the case back or close it, and no more netbook.

    Share
  7. WOW great iPad will be like a note book than

    well when this case will be actually launched?

    Share
  8. The thing about a case with a keyboard is unless there’s some switch that turns off bluetooth without you having to disable it in preferences, it’s useless. Yes I suppose one could use the switch on the keyboard, but that defeats the purpose of speed. Plus if you then lay the thing down, do you lay it on the keyboard? Not a good thing for keeping those keys in good shape. Awkward to hold, etc.

    I like Apple’s Case for the ipad. It feels like you’re carrying a smooth tablet of paper in your hand. You can set it down, it easily angles for typing on your lap or on a desk, and it does not require shoehorning in the unit to work.

    Plus for $39 you get that really cool Apple logo on it and since this is a great apple product that’s only fitting :)

    Share
  9. What will they think of next? Well, you can get two skateboards and strap one to each foot.

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post