7 Comments

Summary:

It doesn’t seem easy, but April 2010 might mark the first time someone succeeds in killing a meme. According to the Open Video Alliance, a recent surge of copyright claims has taken offline a majority of the Hitler parodies on YouTube using footage from the 2004 […]

It doesn’t seem easy, but April 2010 might mark the first time someone succeeds in killing a meme. According to the Open Video Alliance, a recent surge of copyright claims has taken offline a majority of the Hitler parodies on YouTube using footage from the 2004 film Downfall.

As an example of the meme, and to imagine what it must have looked like in the offices of Constantin Films when they discovered it, we turn to Hitler Is Informed About the Hitler Downfall Parodies (which is still online as of writing).

This decision is made all the more ironic by the fact that the director of Downfall really likes this meme — in January, he told New York Magazine’s Vulture blog that “you couldn’t get a better compliment as a director.”

But checking on some of director Oliver Hirschbiegel’s favorites, only one remains online — Hitler Can’t Get Billy Elliot Tickets.

Of course, it’s Constantin Film, not Hirschbiegel, who owns the copyright. But this represents a big blow against mash-up culture, and an awfully short-sighted move on the part of the copyright holder. Sure, the scene’s being used for parody, but it’s kept a great film alive in the public sphere years beyond any foreign film in recent memory.

So I ask this: When do I get to see Hitler getting upset over the Hitler Downfall meme getting taken down? Or, more importantly, where?

Related GigaOm Pro Content (subscription required): Can Online Video Show Us the Future of Newspapers?

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. What Should You Do If YouTube Takes Down Your Video? Tuesday, April 20, 2010

    [...] Should You Do If YouTube Takes Down Your Video? This morning it was observed that a number of videos using footage from the film Downfall to mock pop culture issues had been taken off YouTube for copyright reasons. But how do the creators of those videos go about [...]

  2. See the original meta Hitler Downfall parody:
    http://sean-o.com/hitlermeme

    And the Hitler DMCA Takedown Downfall parody you requested:
    http://ideas.4brad.com/hitler-tries-dmca-takedown

  3. Where to Watch ROFLCon Live Thursday, April 29, 2010

    [...] to Watch ROFLCon Live We love our memes here at camp NewTeeVee. Rick Astley, angry Hitler, cute kittens, drugged-out kids: The web video world wouldn’t be half as exciting without all [...]

  4. YouTube Takes Down Twilight Eclipse: The 8-Bit Interactive Game Thursday, July 1, 2010

    [...] the first time YouTube has shut down popular viral videos on behalf of copyright holders. The video site has taken down a number of Hitler parodies that used footage from the 2004 film Downfall, even though copyright [...]

  5. YouTube Improves Community Takedown Appeals Process Tuesday, July 6, 2010

    [...] a copyright violation. As a result, the new appeals process wouldn’t apply to videos like the Hitler Downfall meme or Twilight Eclipse: The 8-Bit Interactive Game. For those cases, users would have to follow the [...]

  6. YouTube Improves Community Takedown Appeals Process | Newsroom News Tuesday, July 6, 2010

    [...] a copyright violation. As a result, the new appeals process wouldn’t apply to videos like the Hitler Downfall meme or Twilight Eclipse: The 8-Bit Interactive Game. For those cases, users would have to follow the [...]

  7. YouTube Improves Community Takedown Appeals Process | iPhone, iPad Weblog Tuesday, July 6, 2010

    [...] a copyright violation. As a result, the new appeals process wouldn’t apply to videos like the Hitler Downfall meme or Twilight Eclipse: The 8-Bit Interactive Game. For those cases, users would have to follow the [...]

Comments have been disabled for this post