18 Comments

Summary:

After All Facebook reported this morning that Facebook is testing a new “Questions” feature, someone turned to Quora, the well-funded Q&A site created by former Facebook execs, to ask “Why is Facebook creating a Q&A product to compete against Quora?” Facebook’s Blake Ross answered.

After All Facebook reported this morning that the social networking site is testing a new “Questions” feature, someone turned to Quora, the well-funded Q&A site created by former Facebook execs, to ask, “Why is Facebook creating a Q&A product to compete against Quora?” (Quora is still in private beta so you may not be able to view that page.)

Guess who should turn up but Facebook’s director of product, Blake Ross, saying, “I’ll answer this since I’m involved in the questions prototype at Facebook.” He explains that Questions is an evolution of Facebook’s former Polls product, with the idea of delivering instantaneous results to questions about logistics and recommendations. According to the screenshot on All Facebook, Questions pops up in the ad sidebar on the site — presumably to reach would-be answerers in a questioners’ network in the moment.

Ross opines that tech pundits perceive unnecessary and untrue competitive dynamics with our eagerness to declare that things are killers of other things. He says Facebook’s motivations are anything but anti-Quora:

Facebook’s experimentation in this “space” is actually a direct result of internal circumstances at the company rather than all this recent outside activity. For the last few years, we didn’t have enough engineers to make significant, sustained investments in our applications (e.g. photos and events). Earlier this year, we finally got comfortable enough with our recruiting numbers to reorganize the product engineering group into dedicated application teams of 4-5 people each. That’s why you’re suddenly seeing improvements to applications that haven’t evolved in years, such as our recent launch of higher res photos. One of our app teams is charged with experimentation and we decided to pursue this vision of real-time Q&A now that the resources were finally in place.

Ross also says that he thinks the Q&A category is misunderstood, since Quora and Aardvark have different focuses, the former a knowledge base and the latter “really fast results for more day-to-day queries.” So it sounds like what he’s saying, if I may, is that Facebook Questions is an Aardvark killer.

Please see the disclosure about Facebook in my bio.

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. Apparently Facebook Questions Is An Aardvark Competitor, Not A Quora Killer Tuesday, April 13, 2010

    [...] been upgraded until recently in addition to clarifying what the new product is about. Liz Ganne postulates that rather than comparing the new product to Quora, it should instead be compared to Aardvark, the [...]

  2. What’s the Deal With Facebook’s Q&A Competitor? Blake Ross Answers on Quora (Liz Gannes/GigaOM) « My Blog Tuesday, April 13, 2010

    [...] Gannes / GigaOM: What’s the Deal With Facebook’s Q&A Competitor?  Blake Ross Answers on Quora  —  After All Facebook reported this morning that the social networking site is [...]

  3. Zillow CEO Pozits a Social Q&A Site – A Collection of Latest Happening in Technology Field Tuesday, May 11, 2010

    [...] the most direct Pozit competitor is a prototype Facebook product called “Questions,” which looks like it will push out queries to a user’s network with the aim of getting [...]

  4. Zillow CEO Pozits a Social Q&A Site Tuesday, May 11, 2010

    [...] the most direct Pozit competitor is a prototype Facebook product called “Questions,” which looks like it will push out queries to a user’s network with the aim of getting [...]

  5. Is Firefox Headed Towards A Massive Decline? Its Co-Founder Thinks So Tuesday, May 18, 2010

    [...] who is currently a Director of Product at Facebook (coincidentally working on a Quora competitor), has an argument that seems inline with his Facebook colleague (and former [...]

  6. Is Firefox Headed Towards A Massive Decline? Its Co-Founder Thinks So | Magazine Tuesday, May 18, 2010

    [...] is already looking good.Ross, who is currently a Director of Product at Facebook (coincidentally working on a Quora competitor), has an argument that seems inline with his Facebook colleague (and former [...]

  7. An Inside Look At Facebook Questions, The Next “Killer App” Of Facebook | Venture Capital & Angel Investors Lists News and Jobs Sunday, May 23, 2010

    [...] the Facebook employee (with quite the illustrious history of his own) behind the project quickly poured water on those fires — on Quora, [...]

  8. An Inside Look At Facebook Questions, The Next “Killer App” Of Facebook | Technology Magazine Monday, May 24, 2010

    [...] the Facebook employee (with quite the illustrious history of his own) behind the project quickly poured water on those fires — on Quora, [...]

  9. PeerPong Asks for Expert Advice on Twitter Tuesday, June 1, 2010

    [...] PeerPong Asks for Expert Advice on Twitter By Liz Gannes May. 31, 2010, 10:40pm PDT 1 Comment        0 PeerPong, a new Q&A site with an adorable name, is launching a public beta today. The company’s premise to bring users’ questions to qualified experts given their history talking about that topic online — right now, on Twitter. Yes, it’s yet another Q&A company looking to build up page views for its portal, in the vein of Yahoo Answers and competing with startups like Quora and Stack Overflow as well as the pre-launch Facebook Questions product. [...]

  10. Facebook, Steve Jobs, And Dog Day Afternoon | Venture Capital & Angel Investors Lists News and Jobs Saturday, June 5, 2010

    [...] As for Quora, it’s a product being built by ex-Facebook executives (not just your average new startup). And Facebook has already said (on Quora, no less) that it’s not trying to compete with Quora. [...]

Comments have been disabled for this post