15 Comments

Summary:

In a ruling that could have broad implications for video hosting sites that operate in Italy, three Google executives were found guilty of violating privacy laws yesterday for a video that was uploaded to Google Video by one of its users. Will this be overturned?

In a ruling that could have broad implications for video hosting sites that operate in Italy, three Google executives were found guilty of violating privacy laws yesterday for a video that was uploaded to Google Video by one of its users. Although Google has already said it would appeal the decision, the ruling could set a negative precedent if not overturned.

The case centers around a cellphone video of a disabled teenager being bullied by classmates that was uploaded to Google Video in 2006. The EU and Italy have passed legislation to protect Internet service providers from legal claims against third-party uploads, as long they take down content when complaints are filed. The video in question was uploaded on Sept. 8, 2006, but Google did not receive complaints about it until Nov. 6, 2006, at which time it took the video down.

In addition to removing the video, Google also cooperated with Italian police to help them identify the person responsible for uploading the video. She, along with the other students involved, were sentenced to 10 months community service by a court in Turin.

But the story didn’t stop there. About a year ago, David Drummond, Google’s senior vice president and chief legal officer; George Reyes, its former chief financial officer; Peter Fleischer, Google’s global privacy counsel; and Arvind Desikan, an executive from the Google Video team in London were called to trial and charged with defamation and invasion of privacy violations for hosting the video. And yesterday, Drummond, Fleischer and Reyes were convicted of failing to comply with Italy’s privacy code.

“In essence this ruling means that employees of hosting platforms like Google Video are criminally responsible for content that users upload,” Matt Sucherman, Google’s VP and Deputy General Counsel for EMEA, wrote on the official Google blog. Calling the decision “astonishing,” he said that Google would vigorously appeal the ruling. But if the decision is allowed to stand, there could be deeper problems for hosting providers and the Internet in general, Sucherman writes:

“[We] are deeply troubled by this conviction for another equally important reason. It attacks the very principles of freedom on which the Internet is built. Common sense dictates that only the person who films and uploads a video to a hosting platform could take the steps necessary to protect the privacy and obtain the consent of the people they are filming. European Union law was drafted specifically to give hosting providers a safe harbor from liability so long as they remove illegal content once they are notified of its existence. The belief, rightly in our opinion, was that a notice and take down regime of this kind would help creativity flourish and support free speech while protecting personal privacy. If that principle is swept aside and sites like Blogger, YouTube and indeed every social network and any community bulletin board, are held responsible for vetting every single piece of content that is uploaded to them — every piece of text, every photo, every file, every video — then the Web as we know it will cease to exist, and many of the economic, social, political and technological benefits it brings could disappear.”

The 2006 video case isn’t the only issue that Google has had in Italy recently. In December, YouTube lost a copyright infringement suit to Mediaset, for which the Italian broadcasting firm is seeking damages of €500 million (about $730 million).

Related GigaOM Pro Content (subscription required): Not Your Grandfather’s Streaming Video Business

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. Se uno non capisce uno YouTube — Livia Iacolare Wednesday, February 24, 2010

    [...] bella figura di merda made in [...]

  2. Normally I would love to pounce on the giant, but this time it appears they did the right thing. Italy is being quite pathetic on this one

  3. I’m italian and i feel so ashamed of some italian people… :-(

  4. EU Wants Google Street View Curbed – GigaOM Friday, February 26, 2010

    [...] countries. News of the EU demands comes just days after several senior Google executives were convicted by an Italian court of violating privacy laws by allowing a video to be uploaded that showed a mentally disabled child [...]

  5. Larry Downes has an interesting take on what the convictions are really about. yes, it has ramifications about corporate (executive) liability for 3rd party content hosted on a company’s website(s). But could it also be a statement by the Italian government about free speech? In his blog he writes, “In the end it isnt’ a case about liability on the Internet so much as a case about the power of new media to challenge governments that aren’t especially interested in free speech.”

    http://larrydownes.com/the-italian-job-what-the-google-convictions-are-really-about/

    1. This whole Larry Downes this is bullshit: Italy is a free country with as much freedom of speech as in the US… However I agree that Google did what they were supposed to. On the other hand it must also be considered that privacy law in the EU is a very tricky business…

      1. Paolo, I’m sorry but as an Italian, I must disagree.
        If you’re saying that in Italy there’s the possibility to speak freely when less then 10 people hear you, you’re correct.
        While, if you’re saying that in Italy you have the possibility to talk in television or on the newspapers in a free way, that is totally false.
        Unfortunately, if you don’t have a robust “background”, you will be simply smashed and muted by those who have the political power (which is also the economical)…and the demonstration is that also a giant like Google is having many difficulties to change this aspect.

  6. On Google, Italy and the Future of Media – GigaOM Sunday, February 28, 2010

    [...] been spilled in response to the recent Italian court decision that found several Google executives guilty of privacy violations, after a video was uploaded to Google Video that showed an autistic boy being tormented by bullies. [...]

  7. but if this bit about youtube execs knowing full well what content was going and doing their best to make sure it added to their financial well being is correct, maybe the judge got it right

    http://blogmaverick.com/2010/03/18/a-quick-thought-on-the-viacomyoutube-lawsuit-disclosures/

  8. Facebook Feeling More Privacy Pain in Europe – GigaOM Wednesday, March 24, 2010

    [...] service, and Italy recently took the unprecedented step of finding three senior Google executives guilty of privacy law violations for a video that was uploaded to YouTube. But Europe isn’t the only one criticizing the way [...]

  9. Google Slammed by Privacy Authorities Over Buzz Tuesday, April 20, 2010

    [...] repercussions in Italy, where three senior Google executives were found guilty in February of breaching Italian privacy regulations as a result of a video that was uploaded to [...]

  10. Google Slammed by Privacy Authorities Over Buzz | Gadget Public Informations Tuesday, April 20, 2010

    [...] repercussions in Italy, where three senior Google executives were found guilty in February of breaching Italian privacy regulations as a result of a video that was uploaded to [...]

Comments have been disabled for this post