8 Comments

Summary:

Despite apologies from Google, and changes to the innerworkings of its Buzz social networking service, a high-profile privacy group has taken its complaints to the Federal Trade Commission. The Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) has urged the FTC to open an investigation into Buzz.

Despite apologies from Google, and changes to the inner workings of its Buzz social networking service, a high-profile privacy group has taken its complaints to the Federal Trade Commission. The Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) has urged the FTC to open an investigation into Buzz.

EPIC in its complaint (PDF) charges that Google has contradicted its own privacy policy, engaged in unfair and deceptive trade practices, failed to give up to 37 million Gmail users “meaningful control over personal information,” and may have violated federal wiretap laws.

Buzz has been scrutinized heavily due to privacy concerns in recent days, leading Google to make numerous changes to the service. EPIC’s opposition to Buzz isn’t its first disagreement with Google’s practices regarding the cloud. In March of 2009, EPIC urged the FTC to investigate Google’s cloud policies, and warned that the company had failed to safeguard the privacy and security of users.

Among specific requests that EPIC is making to the FTC, it is asking for it to compel Google to:

  • Make Google Buzz a fully opt-in service for Gmail users;
  • Cease using Gmail users’ private address book contacts to compile social networking lists;
  • Give Google Buzz users more control over their information by allowing them to accept or reject followers from the outset.

Notably, EPIC’s complaint also quotes numerous bloggers who have written about the privacy issues surrounding Buzz, as well as a Yahoo Fellow at the Institute for the Study of Diplomacy at Georgetown University, who wrote:

I am extremely concerned about hundreds of activists in authoritarian countries who would neveer want to reveal a list of their interlocutors to the outside world…many of their contacts are other activists…and democracy promoters.

Google may well have an international problem on its hands with Buzz, and other privacy groups are entering the fray. Canada’s Office of the Privacy Commissioner is investigating the service, and The Electronic Frontier Foundation has leveled criticism against Buzz.

Related Post From GigaOM Pro: Where Google Buzz for Mobile Fails

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. FTC Complaint filed against Google Buzz for alleged privacy violations (copy of original complaint included) Wednesday, February 17, 2010

    [...] Privacy Group Demands FTC Investigation Into Google Buzz (gigaom.com) [...]

  2. Congratulations to EPIC. Google (and I love ‘em) has enough data on me. They can integrate social aps without owning it all.
    Grateful that someone cares about that little privacy issue.
    Google is not to big to fail

  3. Privacy Group Demands FTC Investigation Into Google Buzz – GigaOM | NoiseBlogger – A Dynamic, Upto Date, Revolutionary News Blog Wednesday, February 17, 2010

    [...] See the article here: Privacy Group Demands FTC Investigation Into Google Buzz – GigaOM [...]

  4. Sorry Google — Buzz Just Isn’t Working for Me – GigaOM Thursday, February 18, 2010

    [...] Is the Trojan Horse to Take the iPad Beyond Apple’s OS See All Articles » Privacy Group Demands FTC Investigation Into [...]

  5. Dear Eric: The Proper Response Is “I’m Sorry” – GigaOM Thursday, February 18, 2010

    [...] Is the Trojan Horse to Take the iPad Beyond Apple’s OS See All Articles » Privacy Group Demands FTC Investigation Into [...]

  6. Google Accepts Buzz Criticism, Invites Boyd to Speak on Privacy – GigaOM Sunday, March 14, 2010

    [...] and implemented Buzz, its new social web aggregation product. The primary complaint was over privacy — since Buzz exposed and made assumptions about pre-existing Gmail users’ relationships [...]

  7. Google Slammed by Privacy Authorities Over Buzz Tuesday, April 20, 2010

    [...] Not long after the new service was launched in February, the Electronic Privacy Information Center asked the FTC to open an investigation into privacy concerns surrounding Buzz, and that was followed in March by [...]

  8. Google Slammed by Privacy Authorities Over Buzz « AccessTech News Tuesday, April 20, 2010

    [...] Not long after the new service was launched in February, the Electronic Privacy Information Center asked the FTC to open an investigation into privacy concerns surrounding Buzz, and that was followed in March by [...]

Comments have been disabled for this post